ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
AboutFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

  1. Home/
  2. Games/
  3. MLB 19: The Show
M

MLB 19: The Show

Released: 3/26/2019

This is more than baseball. Welcome to The Show™ The Show is back! MLB® The Show™ 19 brings you the best of baseball. Play America’s pastime your way, with new game modes, expanded team building and player customization, and an extensive personalized RPG experience. Create your own player and rise through the MLB ranks or play against others as baseball’s greatest stars and legends. Fierce online competition*, exciting RPG action, lightning fast gameplay––The Show 19 has it all. Key Features New Game Mode: Moments. Recreate or change some of the biggest moments in baseball history New Unannounced Game Mode: March to October. New in Road to The Show: deeper RPG elements, more ways to improve your player on and off the field, and the removal of level caps. New in Diamond Dynasty: more streamlined mission and reward systems and numerous new quality-of-life improvements make earning rewards faster and clearer than previous years. Conquer and defend territories in new Conquest maps, designed to provide a more dynamic and reward-filled Conquest experience. We’ve spent the offseason studying gameplay telemetry and community feedback to drive changes in our hitting engine and defensive AI. Impress your friends and the competition with all new options for customization.

This is more than baseball. Welcome to The Show™ The Show is back! MLB® The Show™ 19 brings you the best of baseball. Play America’s pastime your way, with new game modes, expanded team building and player customization, and an extensive personalized RPG experience. Create your own player and rise through the MLB ranks or play against others as baseball’s greatest stars and legends. Fierce online competition*, exciting RPG action, lightning fast gameplay––The Show 19 has it all. Key Features New Game Mode: Moments. Recreate or change some of the biggest moments in baseball history New Unannounced Game Mode: March to October. New in Road to The Show: deeper RPG elements, more ways to improve your player on and off the field, and the removal of level caps. New in Diamond Dynasty: more streamlined mission and reward systems and numerous new quality-of-life improvements make earning rewards faster and clearer than previous years. Conquer and defend territories in new Conquest maps, designed to provide a more dynamic and reward-filled Conquest experience. We’ve spent the offseason studying gameplay telemetry and community feedback to drive changes in our hitting engine and defensive AI. Impress your friends and the competition with all new options for customization.

This is more than baseball. Welcome to The Show™ The Show is back! MLB® The Show™ 19 brings you the best of baseball. Play America’s pastime your way, with new game modes, expanded team building and player customization, and an extensive personalized RPG experience. Create your own player and rise through the MLB ranks or play against others as baseball’s greatest stars and legends. Fierce online competition*, exciting RPG action, lightning fast gameplay––The Show 19 has it all. Key Features New Game Mode: Moments. Recreate or change some of the biggest moments in baseball history New Unannounced Game Mode: March to October. New in Road to The Show: deeper RPG elements, more ways to improve your player on and off the field, and the removal of level caps. New in Diamond Dynasty: more streamlined mission and reward systems and numerous new quality-of-life improvements make earning rewards faster and clearer than previous years. Conquer and defend territories in new Conquest maps, designed to provide a more dynamic and reward-filled Conquest experience. We’ve spent the offseason studying gameplay telemetry and community feedback to drive changes in our hitting engine and defensive AI. Impress your friends and the competition with all new options for customization.

Critics
86
Metacritic
74

Score Breakdown

86.1

Critic Average

30 reviews

N/A

Steam User Score

Less than 50 reviews

74

Metacritic User Score

225 reviews

Disparity Breakdown

Steam Disparity
N/A
Metacritic Disparity
+12.1
Combined Disparity
+12.1

Average of both sources

Review Timing

1 early (3%)28 launch window (93%)1 late (3%)