ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

A

Antonio Russo

55 reviews

Latest: Shift at Midnight

STWGames ItaliaAug 30, 2026Score 80

“Shift At Midnight turns out to be a delightful surprise, full of personality, capable of taking the anxieties of working with the public and transforming them into a fascinating nightmare. The idea of blending the routine of a management sim with a detective investigation works wonders, creating an anxiety-inducing gameplay loop that reaches its peak in the excellent environmental storytelling. It’s a real shame that the game stumbles just when it decides to flex its muscles, offering shooter sequences and stealth mechanics that don’t measure up to the rest of the game. However, setting aside a clunky combat system and an infinite mode that’s still a work in progress, the nocturnal odyssey crafted by the developers is absolutely worth experiencing, especially when played in co-op. A little gem where the real fear isn’t dying, but receiving a one-star review from a shapeshifter.”

-5.9
S

Steven Landray

24 reviews

Latest: Database Detective: Minor Crimes Division

So Many GamesAug 30, 2026Score 70

“Database Detective: Minor Crime Division is a Schrödinger’s Cat of educational content – on one hand it teaches concepts easily and practically, on the other hand it puts fun front and centre – it’s only when you open the box that you’ll find out if it’s useful for you. Either way, an entertaining, comical story wrapped in the interest of learning something new cannot be ignored – sadly, the game does lose half a star due to a current lack of accessibility options.”

+0.6
James Fraser-Smith

James Fraser-Smith

20 reviews

Latest: TV Archive: Tidy Up Together

MKAU GamingAug 29, 2026Score 75

“TV Archive: Tidy Up Together knows exactly what it wants to be. It isn’t trying to reinvent the simulation genre. There isn’t a huge narrative hiding beneath the shelves, nor is there some elaborate endgame waiting for you once you’ve sorted the final tape. The satisfaction comes from watching the archive gradually take shape. A chaotic floor becomes an organised collection. An empty shelf fills up. A section that initially looks overwhelming eventually becomes perfectly tidy.”

+6.3
F

Fabio Fiorini

3 reviews

Latest: Star Wars Zero Company

Videogiocare.itAug 29, 2026Score 90

“Star Wars Zero Company blends XCOM's tactical depth with Respawn's cinematic flair, delivering memorable characters and aggressive, distinctive combat — one of the best Star Wars games in years, held back only by limited enemy variety.”

+4.8
Hayden Nelson

Hayden Nelson

106 reviews

Latest: Nightmare Shift

MKAU GamingAug 29, 2026Score 80

“Nightmare Shift delivers an unsettling psychological horror experience through its mysterious story, excellent art style and atmospheric sound design. While the awkward controller navigation and emotionless voice acting occasionally pulled me away from the experience, they were not enough to ruin what the game did well. Overall, I genuinely enjoyed my time working the night shift and would recommend it to anyone who loves a slow-burning psychological horror.”

+10.8
R

Rashid Sayed

53 reviews

Latest: Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 2

GamingBoltAug 29, 2026Score 90

“Metal Gear Solid Master Collection Vol. 2 delivers definitive versions of two franchise classics. It looks and runs great, making it an easy recommendation for returning fans and newcomers alike.”

+11.6
J

Joonatan Syrjätie

12 reviews

Latest: Gold Gold Adventure Gold

Netto’s Game RoomAug 28, 2026Score 80

“Gold Gold Adventure Gold is an ambitious project with a lot of charm, a beautiful art style, delightful music, and an addictive gameplay loop. It is not perfect and still needs work to reach its full potential, but even so, the game provides a relaxing atmosphere that you can easily lose hours to.”

-0.3
Chris Garcia

Chris Garcia

59 reviews

Latest: Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters

One More GameAug 28, 2026Score 80

“Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters is a love letter and a compelling arcade sports game for fans of the well-known series. It expands on its predecessor in meaningful ways, such as a much larger roster and deeper systems. The goalkeeper tactical battles and chain system give matches a satisfying pace, while super moves and miracle moments deliver the dramatic highs the series is known for.”

+7.2
L

Libero Zerini

4 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

Videogiocare.itAug 28, 2026Score 72

“Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy takes bold risks by shifting from stealth to melee combat, and while the ancient civilization storyline pays off, Sophia's underdeveloped arc and repetitive combat keep this prequel from matching the heights of Innocence and Requiem.”

+2.9
J

Jordan Ramée

81 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

GameSpotAug 28, 2026Score 60

“Overall, I liked Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy. I think it adds a valuable chapter to the overall mythos of the series, and manages to carve out its own identity in several places without continuing to rely on fan-favorite Amicia or the terror of contending with waves of rats.”

-3.3
Justin Nation

Justin Nation

5015 reviews

Latest: Mai: Child of Ages - Storms of Time

Nindie SpotlightAug 28, 2026Score 43

“A DLC package elsewhere that has for some reason been released as a stand-alone in the eShop, this is a plain buggy and brutal mess to start from zero with”

-7.2
Josh Piedra

Josh Piedra

36 reviews

Latest: Vampire Survivors: Legacy of the Bloodmoon

The Outerhaven ProductionsAug 28, 2026Score 90

“While Legacy of the Bloodmoon doesn't change Vampire Survivors' formula, it doesn't have to. Even with new characters, you'll still be filling the screen with indiscernible pixels as you stand still and try to watch enemies get obliterated underneath the 8-bit acid trip.”

-2.2
P

PS4Blog.net Staff

1380 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

PS4Blog.netAug 28, 2026Score 85

“Is there a way to end the flood and recover your loved one's soul?”

+3.0
P

PS3Blog.net Staff

405 reviews

Latest: Berry Bury Berry

PS3Blog.netAug 28, 2026Score 70

“Collect berries, drop the berries in the hole, escape from the eternal darkness that will consume your soul”

-7.5
C

Chris "Atom" DeAngelus

641 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

Worth PlayingAug 28, 2026Score 85

“Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition is arguably the weakest version of an incredible game, but the compromises aren't enough to undermine the experience. It's difficult to think of another Switch 2 game that matches its scale and sheer amount of content. If you enjoy Souls-style games and haven't yet played Elden Ring, you owe it to yourself to try it. As long as you can accept the technical compromises, Tarnished Edition is an excellent way to experience the game for the first time.”

+2.4
Spencer Legacy

Spencer Legacy

464 reviews

Latest: Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters

MonsterVineAug 28, 2026Score 80

“Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters is a flashy and extreme soccer game that anyone can enjoy. Though the pacing of matches in the story mode can be a little bit bumpy, the narrative itself, in addition to the satisfying gameplay and solid visuals, makes this an accessible and highly enjoyable sports title – even if you’ve never interacted with the source material.”

+3.9
C

Cosmin Vasile

595 reviews

Latest: Feed the Scorchpot

SoftpediaAug 28, 2026Score 90

“Feed the Scorchpot is an intricate experience that delivers an engaging and addictive core loop. The sequence of dice rolling, harvest gathering, adding as much flavor as possible, and then spending resources to deliver an even better result is more complex than it first appears.”

+2.9
T

Thiago da Silva

32 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

GameBlastAug 28, 2026Score 85

“Mortal Shell II is an excellent soulslike that delivers simple yet brutal gameplay, featuring unique shells that alter playstyles and a dark open world with stunning landscapes. However, there is a lack of variety in melee and ranged weapons; furthermore, the fact that mini-bosses also appear as common enemies slightly detracts from the experience.”

+0.1
J

James Clarkson

29 reviews

Latest: NBA 2K27

The Outerhaven ProductionsAug 28, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“NBA 2K27 improves where it matters most, delivering smoother gameplay, better defence, more responsive movement, and an impressive overall presentation. MyCAREER Eras adds something genuinely fresh to the experience, while MyNBA and MyTEAM provide plenty of reasons to keep playing. Familiar frustrations surrounding VC, microtransactions, and The City remain, but the excellent on-court action makes NBA 2K27 one of the strongest entries in the series in recent years.”

+17.2
James Berich

James Berich

265 reviews

Latest: Star Wars Zero Company

Press StartAug 27, 2026Score 90

“Star Wars Zero Company is an incredible debut title from Bit Reactor. A tightly paced 30 hour tactics game with some of the best Star Wars storytelling in recent years. Star Wars and tactics fans alike would be remiss to not check out Zero Company.”

+2.6
PreviousPage 1 of 508Next