ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

  1. Home/
  2. Games/
  3. MLB The Show 23
M

MLB The Show 23

Released: 3/28/2023

MLB® The Show™ 23 gets you closer than ever to living your Baseball dreams on the diamond. Shock The Game and Own The Show™ with your favorite players, your favorite rivalries, and all your favorite MLB® moments. -In partnership with the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, play through and celebrate the careers of Negro Leagues Baseball legends like Satchel Paige, Jackie Robinson, Hank Thompson, Hilton Smith, Rube Foster, Buck O’Neil, John Donaldson, and Martin Dihigo in a video game experience unlike any other. MLB® The Show™ Storylines immerses and introduces you to the stories and careers of some of the greatest and most important players in sports history.* -Live out your Baseball dreams with expanded commentary and in-game presentation updates that bring updated broadcast themes, realistic 3D environments including new external views of your favorite MLB® stadiums, and more detail to uniforms and equipment. -Diamond Dynasty gives you new ways to play, earn, and develop your squad!* Live out your Baseball dreams with over 25 new MLB® Legends, bringing the total to over 180 available in game, to collect from and build your team. Diamond Dynasty gives you new ways to play, earn, and develop your squad:* --Continue earning rewards after completing a featured program— spin the wheel whenever you complete a threshold to claim a reward. The more you play, the more you’ll earn! --Use Captain Cards to designate a position player and a pitching captain for your lineup for the first time ever and unlock powerful in-game boosts by meeting criteria unique to these players. -Franchise Mode now includes the new MLB Postseason™ format, schedule, and more CBA updates. The MLB® Draft experience has been revamped to add strategy and depth in managing your organization.

MLB® The Show™ 23 gets you closer than ever to living your Baseball dreams on the diamond. Shock The Game and Own The Show™ with your favorite players, your favorite rivalries, and all your favorite MLB® moments. -In partnership with the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, play through and celebrate the careers of Negro Leagues Baseball legends like Satchel Paige, Jackie Robinson, Hank Thompson, Hilton Smith, Rube Foster, Buck O’Neil, John Donaldson, and Martin Dihigo in a video game experience unlike any other. MLB® The Show™ Storylines immerses and introduces you to the stories and careers of some of the greatest and most important players in sports history.* -Live out your Baseball dreams with expanded commentary and in-game presentation updates that bring updated broadcast themes, realistic 3D environments including new external views of your favorite MLB® stadiums, and more detail to uniforms and equipment. -Diamond Dynasty gives you new ways to play, earn, and develop your squad!* Live out your Baseball dreams with over 25 new MLB® Legends, bringing the total to over 180 available in game, to collect from and build your team. Diamond Dynasty gives you new ways to play, earn, and develop your squad:* --Continue earning rewards after completing a featured program— spin the wheel whenever you complete a threshold to claim a reward. The more you play, the more you’ll earn! --Use Captain Cards to designate a position player and a pitching captain for your lineup for the first time ever and unlock powerful in-game boosts by meeting criteria unique to these players. -Franchise Mode now includes the new MLB Postseason™ format, schedule, and more CBA updates. The MLB® Draft experience has been revamped to add strategy and depth in managing your organization.

MLB® The Show™ 23 gets you closer than ever to living your Baseball dreams on the diamond. Shock The Game and Own The Show™ with your favorite players, your favorite rivalries, and all your favorite MLB® moments. -In partnership with the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, play through and celebrate the careers of Negro Leagues Baseball legends like Satchel Paige, Jackie Robinson, Hank Thompson, Hilton Smith, Rube Foster, Buck O’Neil, John Donaldson, and Martin Dihigo in a video game experience unlike any other. MLB® The Show™ Storylines immerses and introduces you to the stories and careers of some of the greatest and most important players in sports history.* -Live out your Baseball dreams with expanded commentary and in-game presentation updates that bring updated broadcast themes, realistic 3D environments including new external views of your favorite MLB® stadiums, and more detail to uniforms and equipment. -Diamond Dynasty gives you new ways to play, earn, and develop your squad!* Live out your Baseball dreams with over 25 new MLB® Legends, bringing the total to over 180 available in game, to collect from and build your team. Diamond Dynasty gives you new ways to play, earn, and develop your squad:* --Continue earning rewards after completing a featured program— spin the wheel whenever you complete a threshold to claim a reward. The more you play, the more you’ll earn! --Use Captain Cards to designate a position player and a pitching captain for your lineup for the first time ever and unlock powerful in-game boosts by meeting criteria unique to these players. -Franchise Mode now includes the new MLB Postseason™ format, schedule, and more CBA updates. The MLB® Draft experience has been revamped to add strategy and depth in managing your organization.

Critics
82
Metacritic
62

Score Breakdown

81.9

Critic Average

42 reviews

N/A

Steam User Score

Less than 50 reviews

62

Metacritic User Score

72 reviews

Disparity Breakdown

Steam Disparity
N/A
Metacritic Disparity
+19.9
Combined Disparity
+19.9

Average of both sources

Review Timing

6 early (14%)36 launch window (86%)0 late (0%)

Review summary

Updated May 23, 2023

Based on 42 scored critic reviews, critics give this game an average score of 81.9/100. Critics score this game 19.9 points higher than Metacritic users.

How these comparisons are calculated
Sources behind this summary(5 recent of 42)+
  1. Dimitris VourdasviaEnternity.gr
    May 23, 2023·Launch window
    80/100View review
    Metacritic 62/100 · +18.0 pts
  2. Matúš ŠtrbaviaSECTOR.sk
    Apr 20, 2023·Launch window
    80/100View review
    Metacritic 62/100 · +18.0 pts
  3. Nicolò BicegoviaSpaziogames
    Apr 17, 2023·Launch window
    73/100View review
    Metacritic 62/100 · +11.0 pts
  4. Riccardo Amalfitanovia4News.it
    Apr 14, 2023·Launch window
    85/100View review
    Metacritic 62/100 · +23.0 pts
  5. Jake SuviaGeek Culture
    Apr 14, 2023·Launch window
    90/100View review
    Metacritic 62/100 · +28.0 pts