ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
AboutFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Track critic scores against the player curve

Browse release-by-release disagreement between professional reviews and player response, then sort by recency, disparity, or title to find where the biggest score gaps live.

Noctuary

Noctuary

Release Date: Jul 31, 2025
-16.1

Latest Review

Carlos de Arruda at ProjectN

Sep 19, 2025 | Score 82

“Noctuary is a visual novel with a touch of action RPG that shines primarily through its story, art, and atmosphere. It’s ideal for patient players, fans of deep narratives, and anyone who enjoys that charming anime-style flair. Despite minor technical limitations on the Switch, the game delivers a memorable and engaging experience.”

Critics
78
Steam
94
Metacritic
—
Noctuary

Noctuary

Release Date: Jul 31, 2025

Latest review: Carlos de Arruda at ProjectN

Sep 19, 2025 | Score 82

“Noctuary is a visual novel with a touch of action RPG that shines primarily through its story, art, and atmosphere. It’s ideal for patient players, fans of deep narratives, and anyone who enjoys that charming anime-style flair. Despite minor technical limitations on the Switch, the game delivers a memorable and engaging experience.”

-16.1
Critics
78
Steam
94
Metacritic
—
Morgan: Metal Detective

Morgan: Metal Detective

Release Date: Jul 30, 2025
N/A

Latest Review

Matthew Pollesel at Gaming Age

Sep 10, 2025 | Score 70

“Weirdly, it’s not hard to imagine a world where Morgan: Metal Detective didn’t devolve into an endless trip of scanning and digging – it just would’ve taken a few less random items to come across, and you would’ve had a cute, relaxing game with fun characters and pleasant visuals. As it stands, though, anyone who picks it up hoping for a cozy respite will probably come to regret it.”

Critics
70
Steam
80
Metacritic
—
Morgan: Metal Detective

Morgan: Metal Detective

Release Date: Jul 30, 2025

Latest review: Matthew Pollesel at Gaming Age

Sep 10, 2025 | Score 70

Birdigo

Birdigo

Release Date: Jul 30, 2025
+3.8

Latest Review

Joshua Wyld at Gaming Furever

Jul 30, 2025 | Score 80

“Utilizing a healthy dose of Balatro-like elements to boost your scoring power as you guide your bird along a roguelike migration path to reach their final destination, Birdigo excels at providing a simple game concept with satisfying scoring devices and a “one more round” addictiveness that makes it hard to put down.”

Critics
88
Steam
85
Metacritic
—
Birdigo

Birdigo

Release Date: Jul 30, 2025

Latest review: Joshua Wyld at Gaming Furever

Jul 30, 2025 | Score 80

“Utilizing a healthy dose of Balatro-like elements to boost your scoring power as you guide your bird along a roguelike migration path to reach their final destination, Birdigo excels at providing a simple game concept with satisfying scoring devices and a “one more round” addictiveness that makes it hard to put down.”

Terminator: Dark Fate - Defiance: Uprising

Terminator: Dark Fate - Defiance: Uprising

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
+20.5

Latest Review

Marcos del Amo at TodoJuegos

Dec 18, 2025 | Score 81

“Terminator: Dark Fate - Defiance: Uprising expands the base game with two very solid campaigns, deeper strategy, fresh perspectives, and enough metal to forgive the future.”

Critics
81
Steam
61
Metacritic
—
Terminator: Dark Fate - Defiance: Uprising

Terminator: Dark Fate - Defiance: Uprising

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Marcos del Amo at TodoJuegos

Dec 18, 2025 | Score 81

“Terminator: Dark Fate - Defiance: Uprising expands the base game with two very solid campaigns, deeper strategy, fresh perspectives, and enough metal to forgive the future.”

The Qubit Factory

The Qubit Factory

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
-18.0

Latest Review

Mina Smith at LadiesGamers.com

Sep 21, 2025 | Score 80

“While The Qubit Factory is not for me, it could be perfect for you. If you enjoy these kinds of programming-style games, The Qubit Factory is a good game to choose. It’s free, it’s by an indie developer, and it has a simple premise that leads to great puzzles. I really liked my brief time with The Qubit Factory, and those with the correct kind of brain would probably really enjoy this one.”

Critics
80
Steam
98
Metacritic
—
The Qubit Factory

The Qubit Factory

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Mina Smith at LadiesGamers.com

Sep 21, 2025 | Score 80

Maiden Cops

Maiden Cops

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
-15.5

Latest Review

Cubed3 Staff at Cubed3

Aug 24, 2025 | Score 70

“Fans of the golden age of beat 'em ups (yup, that’s the '90s, alright!) are advised to try out Maiden Cops - the more than decent indie homage to the genre. It doesn’t really have enough to convince those who aren’t into brawlers and its “waifu” aesthetic might even deter those who are. If you don’t mind playing as a cute and curvy anime girl (and one not entirely human), Maiden Cops can actually offer plenty of fun.”

Critics
71
Steam
87
Metacritic
—
Maiden Cops

Maiden Cops

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Cubed3 Staff at Cubed3

Aug 24, 2025 | Score 70

“Fans of the golden age of beat 'em ups (yup, that’s the '90s, alright!) are advised to try out Maiden Cops - the more than decent indie homage to the genre. It doesn’t really have enough to convince those who aren’t into brawlers and its “waifu” aesthetic might even deter those who are. If you don’t mind playing as a cute and curvy anime girl (and one not entirely human), Maiden Cops can actually offer plenty of fun.”

Grounded 2

Grounded 2

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
-0.0

Latest Review

Jon Scarr at Cloud Dosage

Aug 11, 2025 | Score 76

“Grounded 2 builds on the first game with a larger map, faster travel, and smarter tools that make survival more streamlined. Brookhollow Park feels alive with new creatures and biomes, while buggies and the Omni-Tool keep you moving and gathering without the grind. The story is clearer, and mutations give you more ways to play. Early Access bugs are there, but the improvements already make this a stronger, more focused sequel.”

Critics
79
Steam
81
Metacritic
78
Grounded 2

Grounded 2

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Jon Scarr at Cloud Dosage

Aug 11, 2025 | Score 76

Achilles: Survivor

Achilles: Survivor

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
-3.9

Latest Review

Impulsegamer Staff at Impulsegamer

Nov 19, 2025 | Score 46

“For a game priced at $6.99 USD, Achilles: Survivor absolutely offers some lightweight fun. There's a generous roster of characters, a serviceable progression system, and a clever idea in its structure-building mechanics. Combined with run-based auto-combat, it can be a pleasant enough background game, something to play while listening to a podcast or unwinding for a few minutes. But as a full package, it struggles. The grind sets in too quickly, the objectives often feel arbitrarily punishing, and the presentation leans heavily toward bland. Its mythological theme could've elevated the entire experience, yet it never meaningfully interacts with the gameplay. On Switch specifically, the performance hiccups hold the game back even more. Achilles: Survivor isn't a disaster, but it's also far from realizing the potential of its concept. If you're curious about Greek mythology or want a low-cost survivor-like with a small twist, you might find a few hours of entertainment here. If you're on the fence, though, you're probably better off choosing a more polished entry in the genre.”

Critics
79
Steam
83
Metacritic
—
Mado Monogatari: Fia and the Wondrous Academy

Mado Monogatari: Fia and the Wondrous Academy

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
-22.8

Latest Review

Tyler Treese at ComingSoon.net

Sep 26, 2025 | Score 70

“Filled with likable characters and a silly magical school storyline, there's a lot to like about Mado Monogatari: Fia and the Wondrous Academy.”

Critics
70
Steam
92
Metacritic
—
Mado Monogatari: Fia and the Wondrous Academy

Mado Monogatari: Fia and the Wondrous Academy

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Tyler Treese at ComingSoon.net

Sep 26, 2025 | Score 70

“Filled with likable characters and a silly magical school storyline, there's a lot to like about Mado Monogatari: Fia and the Wondrous Academy.”

Day of the Shell

Day of the Shell

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
-9.4

Latest Review

A.J. Maciejewski at Video Chums

Aug 5, 2025 | Score 60

“Playing Day of the Shell is super-exciting at first but after an hour or so, you'll start to realise that it's quite shallow despite its cleverness. 🔫”

Critics
60
Steam
69
Metacritic
—
Day of the Shell

Day of the Shell

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: A.J. Maciejewski at Video Chums

Aug 5, 2025 | Score 60

“Playing Day of the Shell is super-exciting at first but after an hour or so, you'll start to realise that it's quite shallow despite its cleverness. 🔫”

Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game

Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025
+0.8

Latest Review

Paul Stuart at Impulsegamer

Aug 17, 2025 | Score 76

“Tales of the Shire is a Hobbit lifestyle cozy game Tolkien would be proud of and WETA Workshop clearly loved. Hardcore gamers may be confused by the seemingly inane life of Hobbits, also its limited presentation aspects. Still, if you're a Lord of the Rings fan wanting something truly different, this is a welcome change of pace. Note I experienced zero performance/glitch issues on the PS5 Pro (as other platforms weren't so lucky).”

Critics
61
Steam
82
Metacritic
39
Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game

Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Paul Stuart at Impulsegamer

One-Eyed Likho

One-Eyed Likho

Release Date: Jul 28, 2025
-15.7

Latest Review

Ray Tarara at Seasoned Gaming

Sep 5, 2025 | Score 75

“If you’re looking for something action-packed or traditionally scary, this isn’t it. But if you like games that feel like falling into a dark, ancient fairytale, something strange, cerebral, and a little off-kilter, then there’s a lot here to love.”

Critics
78
Steam
94
Metacritic
—
One-Eyed Likho

One-Eyed Likho

Release Date: Jul 28, 2025

Latest review: Ray Tarara at Seasoned Gaming

Sep 5, 2025 | Score 75

“If you’re looking for something action-packed or traditionally scary, this isn’t it. But if you like games that feel like falling into a dark, ancient fairytale, something strange, cerebral, and a little off-kilter, then there’s a lot here to love.”

Primal Planet

Primal Planet

Release Date: Jul 28, 2025
-8.0

Latest Review

Franco Borgogna at La Orden del Pixel

Oct 19, 2025 | Score 100

“Seethingswarm's Metroidvania stands out for offering an adventure with survival mechanics, charming pixel art, and an emotional story that dispenses with dialogue. It's a great addition to the genre's catalog. It's a game that relies on its atmosphere, gameplay, and dialogue-free narrative, resulting in a thoroughly entertaining experience made with an obvious love for the craft.”

Critics
81
Steam
89
Metacritic
—
Primal Planet

Primal Planet

Release Date: Jul 28, 2025

Latest review: Franco Borgogna at La Orden del Pixel

Oct 19, 2025 | Score 100

“Seethingswarm's Metroidvania stands out for offering an adventure with survival mechanics, charming pixel art, and an emotional story that dispenses with dialogue. It's a great addition to the genre's catalog. It's a game that relies on its atmosphere, gameplay, and dialogue-free narrative, resulting in a thoroughly entertaining experience made with an obvious love for the craft.”

Futamata Ren'ai: Two Times the Trouble

Futamata Ren'ai: Two Times the Trouble

Release Date: Jul 26, 2025
-19.1

Latest Review

Thomas Knight at NookGaming

Jul 26, 2025 | Score 70

“Futamata Ren'ai: Two Times the Trouble starts strong with an amusing premise, heroines with unique personalities, plenty of comedy, and an interesting if minimal plot hidden in the background to reveal. It does however start to fall down when it comes to romance or developments beyond the common route. It's worth giving it a read, but much like the other ASa Project titles, it looks great when it comes to visuals, but the balance and style of comedy won't be to everyone's tastes.”

Critics
70
Steam
89
Metacritic
—
Futamata Ren'ai: Two Times the Trouble

Futamata Ren'ai: Two Times the Trouble

Release Date: Jul 26, 2025

Latest review: Thomas Knight at NookGaming

W

Wild Hearts S

Release Date: Jul 25, 2025
N/A

Latest Review

Veerender Jubbal at MonsterVine

Dec 10, 2025 | Score 90

“Wild Hearts S’ Karakuri system is intricately and excitingly crafted with player experimentation abound. The Giant Kenomo feature breathtaking designs to rival Monster Hunter’s creatures in complexity and ferocity, especially from the art portraits each Kemono has in the game’s Cyclopedia. If you’ve done everything there is to do in Monster Hunter Wilds and are looking to dive into an exclusive on Nintendo Switch 2 with mates, Wild Hearts S delivers a tough challenge for experienced monster hunters.”

Critics
77
Steam
—
Metacritic
—
W

Wild Hearts S

Release Date: Jul 25, 2025

Latest review: Veerender Jubbal at MonsterVine

Dec 10, 2025 | Score 90

“Wild Hearts S’ Karakuri system is intricately and excitingly crafted with player experimentation abound. The Giant Kenomo feature breathtaking designs to rival Monster Hunter’s creatures in complexity and ferocity, especially from the art portraits each Kemono has in the game’s Cyclopedia. If you’ve done everything there is to do in Monster Hunter Wilds and are looking to dive into an exclusive on Nintendo Switch 2 with mates, Wild Hearts S delivers a tough challenge for experienced monster hunters.”

Death Relives

Death Relives

Release Date: Jul 25, 2025
-27.9

Latest Review

Mateusz Kasperski at GameOnly

Oct 12, 2025 | Score 65

“Death Relives is a solid choice for those looking for a short, atmospheric horror game with an Aztec twist. It has mood and character, but also, unfortunately quite a few flaws. Still, if you’re a fan of horrors, it plays quite decently, as long as you can forgive its many rough edges and untapped potential. It’s clear the developers ran out of money or time. Or both.”

Critics
58
Steam
86
Metacritic
—
Death Relives

Death Relives

Release Date: Jul 25, 2025

Latest review: Mateusz Kasperski at GameOnly

Oct 12, 2025 | Score 65

No Sleep For Kaname Date - From AI: The Somnium Files

No Sleep For Kaname Date - From AI: The Somnium Files

Release Date: Jul 25, 2025
+6.0

Latest Review

Jim Smale at Gert Lush Gaming

Feb 23, 2026 | Score 74

“No Sleep For Kaname Date becomes a rewarding and engaging experience once you settle into its rhythm. The puzzles feel satisfying, the story pulls you in, and the mix of investigation, escape rooms, and exploration creates a memorable journey. It takes time to get your head around, but when it clicks, it delivers a strong and immersive adventure that keeps you wanting to see what comes next.”

Critics
79
Steam
82
Metacritic
63
No Sleep For Kaname Date - From AI: The Somnium Files

No Sleep For Kaname Date - From AI: The Somnium Files

Release Date: Jul 25, 2025

Latest review: Jim Smale at Gert Lush Gaming

Endzone 2

Endzone 2

Release Date: Jul 24, 2025
-8.6

Latest Review

Davide Fanelli at CrazyGameCommunity.it

Jul 28, 2025 | Score 60

“Endzone 2 is an ambitious management game, which tries to expand the formula of the first chapter with more settlements, mechanics and logistics, but which often barely mentions them in a repetitive system.”

Critics
60
Steam
69
Metacritic
—
Endzone 2

Endzone 2

Release Date: Jul 24, 2025

Latest review: Davide Fanelli at CrazyGameCommunity.it

Jul 28, 2025 | Score 60

“Endzone 2 is an ambitious management game, which tries to expand the formula of the first chapter with more settlements, mechanics and logistics, but which often barely mentions them in a repetitive system.”

Mage Arena

Mage Arena

Release Date: Jul 24, 2025
N/A
Critics
—
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
Mage Arena

Mage Arena

Release Date: Jul 24, 2025
N/A
Critics
—
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
Let Them Trade

Let Them Trade

Release Date: Jul 24, 2025
-3.3

Latest Review

Felix Mager at TestingBuddies

Sep 18, 2025 | Score 75

“I had an entertaining time with Let Them Trade, even though the game currently has its limitations. The endgame is reached quickly and the motivation to continue playing noticeably wanes. The campaign is usually only played once, and even though different cards and the card editor provide variety, the gameplay lacks the necessary depth in the long run. A multiplayer mode in particular could add enormous value here, allowing players to trade together, support each other, or compete for points. Nevertheless, Let Them Trade impresses with some charming details: the soundtrack is varied and picturesque, even if it doesn't seem to be orchestrated, and the idea that the soundtrack blares from the radio on the windowsill when you zoom out is simply brilliant and shows attention to detail. A little more medieval language would certainly have added to the flair, but this is compensated for by little details such as the cat, which you can even stroke. Overall, Let Them Trade remains a solid building and trading game with great potential that still has room for further development.”

Critics
83
Steam
86
Metacritic
—
PreviousPage 63 of 740Next

“Weirdly, it’s not hard to imagine a world where Morgan: Metal Detective didn’t devolve into an endless trip of scanning and digging – it just would’ve taken a few less random items to come across, and you would’ve had a cute, relaxing game with fun characters and pleasant visuals. As it stands, though, anyone who picks it up hoping for a cozy respite will probably come to regret it.”

N/A
Critics
70
Steam
80
Metacritic
—
+3.8
Critics
88
Steam
85
Metacritic
—
+20.5
Critics
81
Steam
61
Metacritic
—

“While The Qubit Factory is not for me, it could be perfect for you. If you enjoy these kinds of programming-style games, The Qubit Factory is a good game to choose. It’s free, it’s by an indie developer, and it has a simple premise that leads to great puzzles. I really liked my brief time with The Qubit Factory, and those with the correct kind of brain would probably really enjoy this one.”

-18.0
Critics
80
Steam
98
Metacritic
—
-15.5
Critics
71
Steam
87
Metacritic
—

“Grounded 2 builds on the first game with a larger map, faster travel, and smarter tools that make survival more streamlined. Brookhollow Park feels alive with new creatures and biomes, while buggies and the Omni-Tool keep you moving and gathering without the grind. The story is clearer, and mutations give you more ways to play. Early Access bugs are there, but the improvements already make this a stronger, more focused sequel.”

-0.0
Critics
79
Steam
81
Metacritic
78
Achilles: Survivor

Achilles: Survivor

Release Date: Jul 29, 2025

Latest review: Impulsegamer Staff at Impulsegamer

Nov 19, 2025 | Score 46

“For a game priced at $6.99 USD, Achilles: Survivor absolutely offers some lightweight fun. There's a generous roster of characters, a serviceable progression system, and a clever idea in its structure-building mechanics. Combined with run-based auto-combat, it can be a pleasant enough background game, something to play while listening to a podcast or unwinding for a few minutes. But as a full package, it struggles. The grind sets in too quickly, the objectives often feel arbitrarily punishing, and the presentation leans heavily toward bland. Its mythological theme could've elevated the entire experience, yet it never meaningfully interacts with the gameplay. On Switch specifically, the performance hiccups hold the game back even more. Achilles: Survivor isn't a disaster, but it's also far from realizing the potential of its concept. If you're curious about Greek mythology or want a low-cost survivor-like with a small twist, you might find a few hours of entertainment here. If you're on the fence, though, you're probably better off choosing a more polished entry in the genre.”

-3.9
Critics
79
Steam
83
Metacritic
—
-22.8
Critics
70
Steam
92
Metacritic
—
-9.4
Critics
60
Steam
69
Metacritic
—

Aug 17, 2025 | Score 76

“Tales of the Shire is a Hobbit lifestyle cozy game Tolkien would be proud of and WETA Workshop clearly loved. Hardcore gamers may be confused by the seemingly inane life of Hobbits, also its limited presentation aspects. Still, if you're a Lord of the Rings fan wanting something truly different, this is a welcome change of pace. Note I experienced zero performance/glitch issues on the PS5 Pro (as other platforms weren't so lucky).”

+0.8
Critics
61
Steam
82
Metacritic
39
-15.7
Critics
78
Steam
94
Metacritic
—
-8.0
Critics
81
Steam
89
Metacritic
—

Jul 26, 2025 | Score 70

“Futamata Ren'ai: Two Times the Trouble starts strong with an amusing premise, heroines with unique personalities, plenty of comedy, and an interesting if minimal plot hidden in the background to reveal. It does however start to fall down when it comes to romance or developments beyond the common route. It's worth giving it a read, but much like the other ASa Project titles, it looks great when it comes to visuals, but the balance and style of comedy won't be to everyone's tastes.”

-19.1
Critics
70
Steam
89
Metacritic
—
N/A
Critics
77
Steam
—
Metacritic
—

“Death Relives is a solid choice for those looking for a short, atmospheric horror game with an Aztec twist. It has mood and character, but also, unfortunately quite a few flaws. Still, if you’re a fan of horrors, it plays quite decently, as long as you can forgive its many rough edges and untapped potential. It’s clear the developers ran out of money or time. Or both.”

-27.9
Critics
58
Steam
86
Metacritic
—

Feb 23, 2026 | Score 74

“No Sleep For Kaname Date becomes a rewarding and engaging experience once you settle into its rhythm. The puzzles feel satisfying, the story pulls you in, and the mix of investigation, escape rooms, and exploration creates a memorable journey. It takes time to get your head around, but when it clicks, it delivers a strong and immersive adventure that keeps you wanting to see what comes next.”

+6.0
Critics
79
Steam
82
Metacritic
63
-8.6
Critics
60
Steam
69
Metacritic
—
Let Them Trade

Let Them Trade

Release Date: Jul 24, 2025

Latest review: Felix Mager at TestingBuddies

Sep 18, 2025 | Score 75

“I had an entertaining time with Let Them Trade, even though the game currently has its limitations. The endgame is reached quickly and the motivation to continue playing noticeably wanes. The campaign is usually only played once, and even though different cards and the card editor provide variety, the gameplay lacks the necessary depth in the long run. A multiplayer mode in particular could add enormous value here, allowing players to trade together, support each other, or compete for points. Nevertheless, Let Them Trade impresses with some charming details: the soundtrack is varied and picturesque, even if it doesn't seem to be orchestrated, and the idea that the soundtrack blares from the radio on the windowsill when you zoom out is simply brilliant and shows attention to detail. A little more medieval language would certainly have added to the flair, but this is compensated for by little details such as the cat, which you can even stroke. Overall, Let Them Trade remains a solid building and trading game with great potential that still has room for further development.”

-3.3
Critics
83
Steam
86
Metacritic
—