Menu
Theme
J

Jeremy Peel

71.9
Avg Score Given
+4.2
Steam Disparity
+15.5
MC Disparity
+9.8
Combined Disparity
25
Reviews
7 early reviews (before release)|17 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|1 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

50
Lowest Score
91
Highest Score
12.8
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

A shift away from single-player leaves Call of Duty with its most lopsided and homogenous entry in decades, though what it does offer is consistently good fun when accepted on its own terms.

Critic
60
Steam
40+20.5
Metacritic
16+44.0
Combined
28+32.2

7/23/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

This flippant, friendly air serves Wheel World well.

Critic
70
Steam
90-19.9
Metacritic
57+13.0
Combined
73-3.4

A typically snappy entry in the best series that action tower defence has to offer, held back by a repeating roguelite structure that's only partially successful.

Critic
70
Steam
72-1.9
Metacritic
57+13.0
Combined
64+5.6

9/12/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

The roguelike and FPS genres haven't been spliced so successfully since Deathloop-and Wild Bastards deserves just as much acclaim.

Critic
91
Steam
75+16.1
Metacritic
68+23.0
Combined
71+19.5

5/2/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

An echo of Arkane’s past glories - one in which the studio’s unique voice can still be heard, but more faintly than we’ve come to expect.

Critic
60
Steam
38+22.2
Metacritic
36+24.0
Combined
37+23.1

1/18/2023

Early Review
Read Review

Only for nostalgists and those who love getting lost on spelunking holidays.

Critic
55
Steam
91-35.6
Metacritic
82-27.0
Combined
86-31.3

Who knew Sid Meier's protégés had a secret, and completely brilliant, Persona game in them?

Critic
88
Steam
82+6.5
Metacritic
72+16.0
Combined
77+11.2

4/6/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

Even Abermore's cult of beetle worshippers would draw the line at this many bugs.

Critic
54
Steam
19+35.5
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
19+35.5

A conservative but confident return to form from the masters of a much-loved genre.

Critic
81
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
70+11.0
Combined
70+11.0

A frankly terrifying exercise in pushing Doom as far as it can go.

Critic
89
Steam
67+22.3
Metacritic
72+17.0
Combined
69+19.6

5/26/2020

Launch Window
Read Review

Like Diablo, this is a game designed for multiple playthroughs on increasing difficulties, but few players will feel compelled to return to a seam that’s all dried up after a single day’s exploration.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
67-7.0
Combined
67-7.0

4/27/2020

Early Review
Read Review

Despite the necessary rules and stricture of turn-based strategy, the action feels just as chaotic and unpredictable as any trophy match Cole played in his sporting days.

Critic
60
Steam
75-15.0
Metacritic
78-18.0
Combined
77-16.5

As any Trekkie will tell you, discovery is addictive, and Journey to the Savage Planet is almost all discovery.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
70+10.0
Combined
70+10.0

Another Call of Duty that doesn’t really change anyone’s mind about Call of Duty. Whatever’s there that I thought might actually be making a leap was seemingly just good marketing. In that sense, I suppose, it’s been pretty successful. [OpenCritic note: Jeremy Peel and Sherif Saad separately reviewed the campaign (4/5) and multiplayer (3/5). The scores have been averaged.]

Critic
70
Steam
93-23.3
Metacritic
38+32.0
Combined
66+4.4

There’s a lot lifted from other games in A Plague Tale, but somehow there’s nothing cynical about it. This is a full-hearted reach for the big time of AAA storytelling that succeeds in the most important departments, thanks to its sparkling polish and subtle characterisation. It’s one of a handful of games for which I could tell you the personality traits and motivations of not just the protagonists, but four or five secondary characters. Consider this review a carrier: Asobo Studio is a name that’s going to spread.

Critic
80
Steam
93-13.4
Metacritic
82-2.0
Combined
88-7.7

2/28/2019

Launch Window
Read Review

This hack-and-slash wears its simplicity like a lovely Scandinavian jumper, but is scarcely substantial enough for its handful of hours and drenched by awful aesthetic choices.Jeremy Peel

Critic
50
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
26+24.0
Combined
26+24.0

2/5/2019

Launch Window
Read Review

Failbetter continues to revolutionise the RPG - not by burning it all down, but by slipping pages of prose into every crevice it can.Jeremy Peel

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
67+23.0
Combined
67+23.0

8/14/2018

Launch Window
Read Review

You might well find the evocative, smoke-damaged backdrop of ‘80s espionage fresh enough to carry you through a satisfying playthrough. But even with the plates changed and the serial number filed off, there's no mistaking XCOM 2.

Critic
70
Steam
74-4.0
Metacritic
75-5.0
Combined
74-4.5

Although the series naturally lends itself to scale, it has often been observed that Total War is at its worst when bloat sets in. So perhaps it should have been no surprise that Arena finds victory in focus, accentuating just a handful of tactical elements so that they become the totality of the game. Then again, that is exactly what makes Arena so much fun: surprise.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

In its new expansion, XCOM 2 makes people of its soldiers and turns its aliens into personalities. It cares about the individual. But that's only so you feel the loss of your bonds more keenly, and hate the enemy more personally. In War of the Chosen, Firaxis are being kind to be cruel.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
82-2.0
Combined
82-2.0
Page 1 of 2Next