Menu
Theme
J

Jon Bailes

68.0
Avg Score Given
-14.6
Steam Disparity
-3.5
MC Disparity
-9.0
Combined Disparity
46
Reviews
19 early reviews (before release)|26 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|1 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

40
Lowest Score
90
Highest Score
15.1
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

5/9/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

Without giving anything away, it suffices to say that this rabbit hole goes a long way down, and if Animal Well is a Metroidvania, it's so much more besides.

Critic
90
Steam
96-5.8
Metacritic
80+10.0
Combined
88+2.1

Tight design and compelling mythology compensate for a few too many borrowed ideas.

Critic
73
Steam
83-9.7
Metacritic
49+24.0
Combined
66+7.2

4/10/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

"Many of the mechanics aren't quite developed enough to feel meaningful"

Critic
50
Steam
54-3.6
Metacritic
54-4.0
Combined
54-3.8

3/27/2024

Early Review
Read Review

Pleasant but rarely compelling characters undermine this spiritual sequel to Gone Home.

Critic
56
Steam
77-20.7
Metacritic
63-7.0
Combined
70-13.8

Like the original game, Dragon's Dogma 2 excels when you're out in its open world with your pawn allies – finding hidden caves and treasure, fighting monsters, and generally losing track of time. Also like the original, it falls short in terms of quest design, convenience, and general polish. A somewhat conservative sequel, then, but one that retains the charm of its predecessor.

Critic
70
Steam
61+8.9
Metacritic
65+5.0
Combined
63+7.0

2/15/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

Server issues aside, Helldivers 2 is a bombastic, strategically engaging and funny squad shooter.

Critic
86
Steam
77+8.7
Metacritic
75+11.0
Combined
76+9.9

Some gripping ghost stories justify gathering around Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden's campfire, but an open world full of routine skirmishes and mindless repetition might just scare you off again. As Dontnod's longest game yet, Banishers underlines the value of a tighter focus.

Critic
60
Steam
85-24.7
Metacritic
77-17.0
Combined
81-20.9

11/15/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

American Arcadia is a sharp, snappy production that could make for an entertaining film if it wasn't peppered with ingenious puzzles and platforming challenges. The dual character scenario is exploited brilliantly, adding variety, originality and humour, and even if some sections lack a real sense of participation, the visual design of Arcadia, along with some smart turns in the plot, ensure momentum through to the end.

Critic
80
Steam
94-14.2
Metacritic
85-5.0
Combined
90-9.6

11/2/2023

Early Review
Read Review

An admirable adaptation of a classic sci-fi story, despite a few stumbles.

Critic
77
Steam
89-11.7
Metacritic
78-1.0
Combined
83-6.3

Robocop: Rogue City reflects its protagonist's qualities. It's well-built and robust, a few glitches aside, and capable of triggering explosive action. Yet it's also mechanical in its design, its dialogue slow and plodding, and limited in its forms of interaction. Short on engaging mission design and the film's punchy satire, Detroit's finest needs better backup to enliven this drawn out adventure.

Critic
50
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
78-28.0
Combined
78-28.0

10/16/2023

Early Review
Read Review

Endless Dungeon is an entertaining, polished, and finely-tuned roguelike, expertly blending action and tactics to fill each trip with dozens of impactful micro-decisions. While visibility can be an issue during packed battles, presentation overall is bright and clean, and supported by some classy character design. Co-op play is the icing on an already tasty cake.

Critic
80
Steam
65+15.1
Metacritic
76+4.0
Combined
70+9.5

10/2/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

A puzzle adventure of rare ingenuity that thrives on its tactility as much as its design.

Critic
90
Steam
95-4.8
Metacritic
80+10.0
Combined
87+2.6

An over-ambitious and technically flawed tactics game that can't live up to its more accomplished influences.

Critic
62
Steam
69-7.2
Metacritic
63-1.0
Combined
66-4.1

8/28/2023

Early Review
Read Review

It's a joy and a relief to realise that Sabotage hasn't merely mimicked classic '90s JRPG, but committed to understanding what makes them tick. Its nostalgia is neither gratuitous nor cynical, instead working disparate references together with original ideas into a coherent whole. While it's a little disappointing to discover that there's isn't great depth to the turn-based battles and other systems, the immense quality and detail in the pixel art, soundtrack, location design, characters and plot ensure that Sea of Stars remains a stunning achievement to the end.

Critic
90
Steam
89+0.9
Metacritic
80+10.0
Combined
85+5.4

8/22/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

If Fort Solis really was a Netflix series, it wouldn't get a second season.

Critic
40
Steam
67-26.8
Metacritic
64-24.0
Combined
65-25.4

8/16/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

En Garde! flares brightly with its slick, slapstick combat, for a while at least.

Critic
71
Steam
91-20.1
Metacritic
66+5.0
Combined
79-7.5

8/9/2023

Early Review
Read Review

It's proficient in some respects, adequate in others, and manageable at worst. But that leaves a creative void in its world and the way you interact with it that calls into question the value of the whole endeavour.

Critic
50
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
63-13.0
Combined
63-13.0

"The upside of treading old ground is that the Oxenfree 2 story gets to link back to the original in some fun ways"

Critic
40
Steam
88-48.2
Metacritic
72-32.0
Combined
80-40.1

5/23/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

After Us combines stunning vistas of environmental decay with a dreamlike flow to its light platforming challenges. Despite some missteps, such as ill-fitting combat, exploring and affecting its world is a gratifying process that comes with a wave of emotional ups and downs.

Critic
70
Steam
85-14.9
Metacritic
68+2.0
Combined
76-6.5

Intriguing puzzles aside, this metroidvania is plagued with systems that seem designed to frustrate.

Critic
54
Steam
74-20.2
Metacritic
69-15.0
Combined
72-17.6
Page 1 of 3Next