Menu
Theme
J

Jonathan Logan

84.8
Avg Score Given
-6.5
Steam Disparity
+5.7
MC Disparity
-0.4
Combined Disparity
16
Reviews
6 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|10 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

72
Lowest Score
95
Highest Score
6.7
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Low score spread detected. This reviewer may use a narrow scoring range or binary scoring system.

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

Throes of the Watchmaker is a solid piece of DLC for Sea of Stars. If you enjoyed the main game, you will enjoy this too! If the original wasn't your bottle of seltzer, maybe pass on it.

Critic
85
Steam
94-9.3
Metacritic
78+7.0
Combined
86-1.1

3/12/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

With exceptional writing, beautiful art, a compelling environment, and a captivating central gameplay mechanic, Expelled! is a video game work of art. If you have any interest in visual novels, adventure games, whodunits, or time loops, I can’t recommend it enough. Believe me, you will want to play this one again and again!

Critic
92
Steam
96-4.1
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
96-4.1

The Crimson Diamond is a retro-style game done right, pulling everything that worked from the text parser games of the late 80s while making it much more accessible for audiences today.

Critic
90
Steam
97-7.1
Metacritic
72+18.0
Combined
85+5.4

This expertly remastered outing for Sam & Max is an adventure game to remember and a spectacular conclusion to their Telltale adventures!

Critic
85
Steam
99-13.9
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
99-13.9

5/12/2022

Late Review
Read Review

Overboard! is an outstanding time-loop game that challenges you to think like a crafty murderer out of an Agatha Christie novel!

Critic
88
Steam
90-2.3
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
90-2.3

The Castlevania Advance Collection offers fantastic value with three excellent Metroidvania games (and one heck of a challenging side scroller).

Critic
87
Steam
91-4.5
Metacritic
86+1.0
Combined
89-1.7

10/26/2021

Late Review
Read Review

Kathy Rain: Director's Cut adds in some interesting additional content, but is fundamentally the same overall experience as its original release.

Critic
78
Steam
92-14.0
Metacritic
77+1.0
Combined
85-6.5

8/10/2021

Late Review
Read Review

Dreamscaper has been in early access for about a year, and based on my time with it, I can say that time was well spent by Afterburner. They’ve created a well-balanced and engaging roguelike Action RPG that perfectly pairs with its social simulator mechanics. I continued to play long after I conquered Cassidy’s dreams and enjoyed every run, whether it was all the way to the end of the game or stupidly dying in the first level. This is a super impressive debut for the studio, and I hope that Afterburner is already working on its follow-up title! If Dreamscaper is any indication, we will be in for some sweet dreams ahead!

Critic
88
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
67+21.0
Combined
67+21.0

6/13/2021

Late Review
Read Review

With stunning pixel-art graphics, solid combat, and a considerable amount of character customization, you can easily sink a few hours into Foregone, maybe more if you delve into more challenging difficulty levels. However, if you’re looking for a complex Metroidvania full of backtracking and deep lore, I would look elsewhere. Foregone may have left me feeling a bit cold, but if you’re looking for some straightforward side-scrolling action, I suspect it will nicely scratch that itch!

Critic
75
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
77-2.0
Combined
77-2.0

Between the minigames, side quests, substories, idol simulator, and main story, Yakuza 5 offers a truly stunning value for your money.

Critic
83
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
79+4.0
Combined
79+4.0

With Yakuza 4, we start to see the modern vision of the series take shape, while also serving as an enjoyable entry on its own!

Critic
74
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
740.0
Combined
740.0

Despite occasionally feeling dated, Yakuza 3 still offers a fun experience for fans of the series.

Critic
72
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
71+1.0
Combined
71+1.0

Cthulhu Saves Christmas is a stocking stuffer you'll want to open!

Critic
90
Steam
91-1.0
Metacritic
81+9.0
Combined
86+4.0

Already the best game in the Mario & Luigi series, the new graphics and presentation raise it to new heights on the 3DS!

Critic
88
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

One of the funniest RPGs ever made, West of Loathing combines a unique visual presentation with outstanding roleplaying.

Critic
95
Steam
98-2.7
Metacritic
80+15.0
Combined
89+6.2

1/23/2019

Late Review
Read Review

One of the most engaging and original adventure games released in years. You owe it to yourself to give it a play.

Critic
87
Steam
96-8.6
Metacritic
74+13.0
Combined
85+2.2