Menu
Theme
Joseph Pugh

Joseph Pugh

82.5
Avg Score Given
+0.8
Steam Disparity
+10.4
MC Disparity
+5.6
Combined Disparity
78
Reviews
10 early reviews (before release)|41 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|27 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

35
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
17.0
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

10/12/2021

Launch Window
Read Review

Pawnbarian is single-minded with a specific experience that it wants to offer. That experience is a challenging brain teaser using a classic and timeless game in new ways. Limitation is often king to innovation, and with that Pawnbarian calls checkmate.

Critic
100
Steam
90+10.4
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
90+10.4

10/9/2021

Launch Window
Read Review

The obstructive visual elements are bothersome, but the nostalgia factor made it up to me. Slayers Inc may not be the freshest demon slayer to take a risk on, but the fun rains down anyway as a solid rogue-lite shooter.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

9/23/2021

Late Review
Read Review

Embr manages to be a hectic, yet methodical co-op game about firefighters that can also be enjoyed solo. Its replayable nature through a variety of enjoyable modes keeps the game burning bright when many other party games would have long fizzled out on dead wood.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
66+34.0
Combined
66+34.0

9/20/2021

Early Review
Read Review

Sheltered 2 offers an apocalyptic survival experience that will put your planning and management skills to the test alongside nifty turn-based combat. Yet, the tedium of such excessive micromanagement might have you wishing for the world to end again.

Critic
100
Steam
45+54.5
Metacritic
24+76.0
Combined
35+65.3

Clever management mixed with highly tactical combat makes this band worth the price of admission. Just be aware the grim difficulty might make you sing the blues while you learn to accept its brotherly love.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
78+22.0
Combined
78+22.0

The simulation and management elements are almost non-existent. The few that are present tend to be obtuse and poorly explained. Yet, the game within a game is brilliant and will really test your ability to think about strategy in a different way. The fact that champions get nerfed and buffed based on how tournaments play out is clever beyond description. I just wish the rest of the game received the same loving attention.

Critic
68
Steam
87-18.9
Metacritic
680.0
Combined
77-9.4

To put it simply, I adore everything about the game. It’s variety between classes, the balance of resources, the meaningful meta-progression, and breadth of content. Slay the Spire and Monster Train are some of my favorite games, but they can have a seat at the round table and bow before the throne at which Tainted Grail: Conquest now sits.

Critic
100
Steam
90+9.8
Metacritic
73+27.0
Combined
82+18.4

Fuzz Force Spook Squad manages to be thrilling to play, strategically satisfying, and simple to learn. It’s a dice game all about randomness, but every step of the way it asks “How do you want to do this?”

Critic
92
Steam
90+1.8
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
90+1.8

Legend of Keepers nails the gamblers high of unpredictable randomness while putting the player’s agency at the forefront to actually use that randomness in a meaningful way, that’s the hallmark of a good rogue-lite game.

Critic
90
Steam
79+11.3
Metacritic
68+22.0
Combined
73+16.6

The reality is if Insurmountable were a real board game, I’d be interested in picking it up, and the price would be much steeper due to the physical pieces. The digital experience it offers is a unique one worth having for any fans of slower-paced strategy games, even if its freshness is shorter-lived than I would like.

Critic
80
Steam
80+0.4
Metacritic
56+24.0
Combined
68+12.2

3/22/2021

Launch Window
Read Review

For Sparta is a small but mighty game with a ferocity to honor its namesake. The gameplay is fantastic, and it very cleanly side steps the repetitive pitfalls the genre sometimes falls into. Its laser-focused direction does it a lot of favors. It’s not a long-term grinding game with a billion things to unlock, and it doesn’t try to be.

Critic
88
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

3/18/2021

Launch Window
Read Review

The phobias themselves have a fantastic aesthetic design and animation too. The rigid and puzzlelike nature gives the game a unique playstyle that’s a lot of fun to solve. The lack of polish is very apparent, however. Between the bugs, strange design choices, and lack of cohesion the game feels like it needed more time in the oven, and maybe some focused direction.

Critic
40
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
55-15.0
Combined
55-15.0

Space Otter Charlie is cute, fun, and easy to play with, clever but simple puzzles, enjoyable old-school boss fights, and plenty to explore, find, and craft. It’s a game aimed at a more casual demographic that I’m really not a part of, but that’s okay. I still found a lot to appreciate.

Critic
80
Steam
99-18.7
Metacritic
800.0
Combined
89-9.4

It retains the same charm, fun physics, and team coordination that made the base game great. It’s on the short side with just a couple of hours of content, a problem that often plagues many party games. The DLC is on the cheap side though, so it may just be worth moving in on.

Critic
78
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

1/13/2021

Late Review
Read Review

Ratropolis is an engaging real-time strategy and kingdom building game that successfully fuses with the thoughtful deliberation of deckbuilding, tactical card play, and resource management. I sometimes think cards can make any game better, Ratropolis certainly makes a strong case for it.

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

Tetrogue Dragons is clever, fun, and addictive, with an interesting take on the falling block style of puzzle game. The rogue-lite elements fit perfectly, and the way the variety of classes play is impressive.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

Regardless The Oathbound faction is incredibly cool, fun to play, and brings another unique playstyle to the game. Star Kings is a powerful final act for the elegant beast of a game that we call Age of Wonders: Planetfall. Previous fans would be doing themselves a disservice by missing out on it.

Critic
85
Steam
83+1.8
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
83+1.8

9/26/2020

Launch Window
Read Review

The core of Breakpoint is a fast-paced arcade experience, and the game absolutely nails it with addictive gameplay and eye-popping visual effects. I know people still like arcade games because they keep buying old ones repackaged. Breakpoint costs just under five dollars, so why not make some new nostalgia instead?

Critic
85
Steam
97-12.0
Metacritic
80+5.0
Combined
89-3.5

As it stands Against the Moon will likely fizzle out faster than the games that inspired it, with repetition setting in quicker than it really should. Yet, the brilliant upgrade system and solid tactical combat are worth experiencing, and I sincerely hope the game receives more content simply because I want to enjoy the game more.

Critic
40
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

If you’re a patient fan of puzzles and stealth, Party Hard 2 is an enjoyable experience with well-designed levels for you to master.

Critic
75
Steam
78-3.2
Metacritic
70+5.0
Combined
74+0.9
PreviousPage 2 of 4Next