Edwin Evans-Thirlwell
Scoring Pattern
Low score spread detected. This reviewer may use a narrow scoring range or binary scoring system.
Disparity Over Time
Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
Reviews
“It's a sight for saur eyes, but not quite enough to make Exoprimal essential. There's real cleverness to the PvPvE balance, and to how Leviathan modifies that one, core mode as the game unfolds, but after 15 hours, it still feels like an exercise in reshuffling well-worn pieces. I don't think it earns that blockbuster price tag. As a subscription game, though, Exoprimal is dino-mite.”
“A beautifully written and illustrated tale of young people trying to change their world, which comes alive on replay.”
6/21/2023
Early Review“A smart combat system straining under the weight of a characterful but ponderous pseudo-medieval soap opera, with some of the grandest bosses and dullest sidequests in FF history.”
6/19/2023
Early Review“Aliens: Dark Descent is an occasionally wayward but on the whole, inspired movie adaptation, and a suspenseful real-time tactics game.”
5/11/2023
Early Review“A terrific Breath of the Wild follow-up with some brilliant new systems, amazing views and more dungeon-type spaces, plus a slightly deadening emphasis on gathering resources.”
5/8/2023
Launch Window“A copious and often brilliant, if not quite unmissable reworking of a powerfully grim fantasy.”
4/18/2023
Early Review“A straightforwardly accomplished zombie action-RPG that doesn't quite make the most of its Californian setting.”
3/23/2023
Launch Window“This brief, raw and unsettling reimagining of a celebrated environmentalist's campaign against pesticides presents a sickly vision of nature contaminated by humans”
“Blending fishing with Gothic horror and Lovecraft is a fine hook, but Dredge is too defined by simple loot-and-upgrade rhythms to reel you in.”
2/14/2023
Launch Window“All the confusing yet irresistible energy of early-noughties double-A gaming, marred by awful writing and a core gimmick that doesn't ignite.”
1/26/2023
Early Review“While a fine piece of craft and a sumptuous reworking of the setting, EA Motive's Dead Space remake sheds a little of the 2008 game's enchantment.”
“Oppressive lo-fi visuals and brutalist architecture somehow create a game of laidback curiosity and exploration”
12/6/2022
Launch Window“A graphical overhaul offers a gentler way of playing this vast, strange strategy game of staggering intricacy”
11/10/2022
Early Review“An exhaustive reworking of a foundational dark fantasy epic, with some quietly radical new ideas.”
10/14/2022
Launch Window“An aimless-feeling revamp of 2016's best multiplayer game, slightly coarsened by free-to-play grinding.”
9/13/2022
Launch Window“A beautifully structured, rich and thoughtful adventure with gentle but decisive RPG elements.”
8/31/2022
Launch Window“An exhilarating, fluid, incredibly broken mage-'em-up set in tortured procedural worlds.”
7/21/2022
Early Review“While component tales and battles can be hit-and-miss, this elderly Squaresoft anthology is a wonderful testament to its genre's flexibility and range.”
6/2/2022
Launch Window“An entertaining celebration of sleight of hand from the makers of Reigns”
5/4/2022
Early Review“A brutal but graceful and comprehensible mix of ideas from Warhammer, XCOM and Gears Tactics.”
