Ed Nightingale
Scoring Pattern
Disparity by Outlet
Disparity Over Time
Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
Reviews
9/1/2025
Early Review“Hell is Us is an absorbing, nightmarish meditation on the horror of war, but divisive design choices prove tedious.”
5/28/2025
Early Review“FromSoftware's multiplayer spin-off is an exhilarating rush and a celebration of the studio's prior achievements Souls veterans will devour.”
4/23/2025
Early Review“Outstanding artwork and glorious combat bring Clair Obscur: Expedition 33's bold, painterly world to life.”
12/4/2024
Early Review“The cult classic mobile RPG finally gets its due, for lovers of mechanics over story who can rise to the demands of its extreme challenge.”
10/21/2024
Early Review“Shadow's campaign provides some of the best 3D levels of the series, but it's coupled with a dated and unnecessary remaster. If only Sega went all-in on the future.”
10/7/2024
Early Review“Persona veteran Atlus flexes its expertise with a fresh take on high fantasy. What it lacks in subtlety, it makes up for in grandeur and heart.”
4/22/2024
Early Review“What Tales of Kenzera lacks in creative game design it makes up for in vital, passionate storytelling.”
2/22/2024
Early Review“Rebirth is a playful take on an emo classic that's bloated but full of character in a bid to justify its own existence.”
10/17/2023
Launch Window“Respectable platforming and classic Sonic elements are undermined by inconsistent new ideas.”
10/12/2023
Early Review“Missing the elegance of FromSoftware, Lords of the Fallen is let down by Soulslike clichés and performance woes.”
8/9/2023
Early Review“A fascinating but flawed experimental musical game that fails to live up to some heavenly potential.”
7/27/2023
Early Review“An expressive, characterful entry point for metroidvanias.”
2/2/2023
Launch Window“Vibrant and self-assured, Hi-Fi rush happily embraces the 00s' cheese - and is all the better for it.”
12/6/2022
Early Review“A sensitive remaster of the PSP prequel that's recontextualised in the wake of Remake.”
8/17/2022
Early Review“Teen angst, a diverse cast, and simplistic interactivity accompany a real life music EP.”
8/4/2022
Early Review“Just as it did with Two Point Hospital, Two Point Studios has combined neatly overlapping managmenet systems with an irrepressably oddball charm.”
6/16/2022
Launch Window“It's a small gripe, though. Please Fix The Road isn't really trying to taunt you, it's trying to teach you its mannerisms. It's arguably a meditation on humans and nature, destroying environments only to rebuild them in organic and inorganic ways. But mostly it's just a wholesome and gratifying puzzle game that's impossible to be frustrated with. Even the title is polite.”
“Soundfall plays like an extended pop album, each level a three minute burst of music that initially fizzes and delights. Yet playing on repeat proves shallow. The music is killer, but the gameplay is filler.”
8/26/2018
Late Review“Flood of Light has an evocative mood, but its narrative is ultimately as lifeless as its central character. The gameplay centres on a single concept that’s mundane, fiddly and gets tiresome quickly. It’s not a bad game per se – it’s just not very exciting.”
