Menu
Theme
J

James Billcliffe

78.0
Avg Score Given
-21.8
Steam Disparity
+20.5
MC Disparity
-0.6
Combined Disparity
20
Reviews
12 early reviews (before release)|6 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|2 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

60
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
14.4
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

So, while there are no less than five other versions of Metal Gear Solid 3, Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater is now the definitive place to play a bonafide classic in a way that feels both accessibly modern, but still authentic to the original experience.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
77+3.0
Combined
77+3.0

2/25/2025

Late Review
Read Review

The cliche with EA Sports games is that they’re always an iterative step. But, outside of the mid-console generation graphical similarity, there’s a lot that EA Sports FC 25 does which isn’t iterative. The big changes brought about by FC IQ, Cranium and Rush make for an interesting gameplay refresh which gives new impetus to both competitive online modes and long-underserved offline careers.

Critic
80
Steam
53+27.4
Metacritic
28+52.0
Combined
40+39.7

It’s a colourful, accessible epic that pushes its console to the limit, with all of the mechanical depth and invention, artistic design, whimsy, and spirit of adventure that you expect from a first-party Nintendo adventure.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
84-4.0
Combined
84-4.0

So, while the start of Shadow of the Erdtree can come off as a regression, really, the DLC as a whole is FromSoftware flexing all of its creative muscles - including some it hasn’t used in a while and others it might be building up for the future. The depth of storytelling in the Lands of Shadow, as well as the new weapons, spells and items (all of which add to the lore themselves, of course), only better your experience of the Lands Between, and make for a worthy upgrade to what is already an unforgettable adventure.

Critic
100
Steam
70+29.7
Metacritic
83+17.0
Combined
77+23.4

3/7/2024

Early Review
Read Review

Standing on its own, Unicorn Overlord is an excellent expansion of Vanillaware’s now-trademark visual style and its newer RTS mechanics, offering both gripping strategy and an atmospheric pulp fantasy world that you're going to want to sink hours and hours into.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
84-4.0
Combined
84-4.0

The Master Books are bursting with interesting tidbits that helped me to contextualise each game and the storyline as a whole better than ever before, but there’s relatively little within the games themselves to make this a real must-have if you still have access to previous collections and releases.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
64-4.0
Combined
64-4.0

9/29/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

EAFC 24 might go about achieving its goals in a slightly different way to the FIFA series, but it lands at the same end result. The same tempting sticker book collect-a-thon and absorbing gameplay carousel makes EAFC 24 a virtual footballing platform that demands your attention and is difficult to put down. Emulating the signature moves of your sporting heroes with box-office Playstyles is a highlight, but there will always be questions about whether the mechanic can stand up to the test of millions of players probing for overpowered exploits.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
27+53.0
Combined
27+53.0

Although it takes place on the same map as Breath of the Wild (with a few key changes owing to the time-skip and Upheaval, of course), Tears of the Kingdom feels different enough from its predecessor thanks to the new powers and mechanics to stand all on its own. It’s a massive open world that feels dense and exciting without getting clogged up with icon fatigue, since so much of the play is based around physics interactions with the core mechanics, rather than rigid systems

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
88+12.0
Combined
88+12.0

1/23/2023

Early Review
Read Review

Its stuttering start belies a combat system that’s worth investing the effort to learn, but takes so long to get up to full speed that it’s already on borrowed time.

Critic
60
Steam
62-2.4
Metacritic
43+17.0
Combined
53+7.3

11/3/2022

Early Review
Read Review

Although it starts out remarkably similar to the 2018 God of War both mechanically and graphically, God of War Ragnarok gradually builds into a meaningful evolution for the series, expanding the scope of gameplay both stealthily and overtly, while delivering a tense and twisty story that bends legend around its characters in exciting and endlessly interesting ways.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

10/14/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

But keeping things on the pitch, FIFA 23 is still utterly engrossing, wildly frustrating, uncannily realistic and very silly. It’s endlessly playable but, just like real football, the search for the perfect blueprint goes on.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
41+19.0
Combined
41+19.0

8/22/2022

Early Review
Read Review

Outside of the super set-piece main missions, it’s easy to bounce off the more repetitive elements of the open-world.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
33+27.0
Combined
33+27.0

6/30/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

It’s silly and nerdy and dark and takes no prisoners as it violently demands your attention from start to finish.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
57+3.0
Combined
57+3.0

Really, LEGO Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga is all the action from the Star Wars series, swaddled in the slapstick silliness LEGO has become known for in entertainment. While it’s not a 1-to-1 retelling and your favourite moment might have been left in the toy chest, it’s a knowing showcase of Star Wars’ place in pop culture – memes and all – in a deep, but accessible package.

Critic
80
Steam
90-10.3
Metacritic
77+3.0
Combined
84-3.7

Ultimately, the Assassin’s Creed Valhalla Siege of Paris DLC is a worthy add-on with a good story and great emphasis on more interactive gameplay. While its narrative stakes feel relatively low, Eivor has real impetus in how everything unfolds throughout the well-paced plot.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
61+19.0
Combined
61+19.0

4/29/2021

Early Review
Read Review

While Returnal’s marriage of rogue-like loops and serpentine story isn’t perfect, it’s a dark, engaging, and innovative experience which provides plenty of gameplay grunt to match its brain-teasing plot.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
74+6.0
Combined
74+6.0

3/23/2021

Early Review
Read Review

While it does feel like a smaller package in terms of grand story presentation, the new additions and quality-of-life fixes make it less grindy to play, with greater flexibility in exploration, navigation, and resource collection adding to the portable possibilities.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
84-4.0
Combined
84-4.0

12/7/2020

Early Review
Read Review

In the midst of such intense anticipation and scrutiny, it’s easy to get carried away with what Cyberpunk 2077 could have been. The final experience might be more familiar than many predicted, with plenty of elements that aren’t perfect, but it’s dripping with detail and engaging stories. With so much to see and do, Cyberpunk 2077 is the kind of RPG where you blink and hours go by, which is just what we need to finish off 2020.

Critic
100
Steam
86+13.9
Metacritic
73+27.0
Combined
80+20.4

But whether you’ve grown up with Goku and friends, or you’re a first timer who’s never fancied sitting through 300 episodes without getting to play a part in the action, this is still a great way to experience the classic story.

Critic
60
Steam
93-33.2
Metacritic
80-20.0
Combined
87-26.6

9/19/2019

Launch Window
Read Review

Without much cosmetic polish to fall back on, FIFA 20 needed to bring something new to the table. Although the core gameplay isn’t mind-blowingly different, it’s still the best football game, and the addition of VOLTA is a whole new way to play.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
15+65.0
Combined
15+65.0