Menu
Theme
B

Brian Arnoldi

83.4
Avg Score Given
+3.3
Steam Disparity
+40.1
MC Disparity
+21.7
Combined Disparity*
7
Reviews
2 early reviews (before release)|0 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|5 late reviews*No launch window reviews - showing overall disparity

Scoring Pattern

60
Lowest Score
95
Highest Score
12.0
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

Shadow Labyrinth is undoubtedly an interesting experiment, starting from an idea we'd like to see explored more often: thoughtfully modernizing a past title, reviving the key ideas that led to its creation but incorporating them into a modern framework. It's a shame the execution isn't the best: beneath the pleasant nods to Bandai Namco's history lies a derivative Metroidvania, reminiscent of a bygone era. Navigating the labyrinths is simple, the combat lacks creative flair, the protagonist's power-ups lack impact, and even the original ideas haven't been perfectly implemented.

Critic
60
Steam
57+3.3
Metacritic
71-11.0
Combined
64-3.9

5/20/2025

Early Review
Read Review

The combat system and crafting mechanics thus come together in a unicum that makes the gameplay of Blades of Fire innovative and truly original. At the beginning, such an impressive amount of choices to make might seem overwhelming. But it still remains a much-needed breath of fresh air in a stagnant sector .

Critic
75
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
77-2.0
Combined
77-2.0

Outlaws Of Thunder Junction is certainly one of the most interesting sets in Magic: The Gathering that has come out recently, as well as one of those with a clearer artistic identity.

Critic
88
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
31+57.0
Combined
31+57.0

Magic: Eldraine's Wildlands is a great first step. The set, which has the thankless task of opening a new narrative cycle after the Phyrexian climax of the 30th anniversary, is not almost perfect as was The Advance of the Machines, but it is still a solid production from every point of view.

Critic
88
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
31+57.0
Combined
31+57.0

The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth is a mammoth product, which challenges the very concept of cardgame in scope and size.

Critic
88
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
31+57.0
Combined
31+57.0

The Advance of the Machines represents the apotheosis of card collecting and fanservice for longtime fans of Magic: The Gathering.

Critic
95
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
31+64.0
Combined
31+64.0

Phyrexia: Everything Will Become One is an incredibly solid and coherent set. The cards are artistically ambitious and playfully satisfying; the mechanics are deep and lend themselves to a variety of interpretations and situations that, provided you do not claim to climb the classics of world tournaments, guarantee the Wizards of The Coast Trading Card Game an enviable freshness, which at the moment is not found in the main competitors on the market.

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
31+59.0
Combined
31+59.0