Menu
Theme
R

Ryan Thompson-Bamsey

79.5
Avg Score Given
-15.0
Steam Disparity
+5.9
MC Disparity
-4.5
Combined Disparity
34
Reviews
24 early reviews (before release)|8 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|2 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

44
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
14.4
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

1/23/2023

Early Review
Read Review

Forspoken is a clunky game with awkward dialogue and characterisation, but the gameplay shines bright.

Critic
70
Steam
62+7.6
Metacritic
43+27.0
Combined
53+17.3

While Treasures has high points, the low points outweigh them and leave the game a middling experience.

Critic
44
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
73-29.0
Combined
73-29.0

Despite its quirks, this is the best version of Tactics Ogre. Gone are frustrating class-based levels and the overabundance of secrecy. Replacing them are new frustrations that are less experience-breaking. Reborn makes the grandaddy of strategy RPGs the most accessible it's ever been, and it’s not one to miss. According to Steam, I have already played 62 hours, and I already know that number will triple at a minimum by the time I’m done with it.

Critic
80
Steam
74+6.5
Metacritic
76+4.0
Combined
75+5.2

10/24/2022

Early Review
Read Review

Victoria 3 is a grand strategy game with perhaps too much depth and complexity for genre newbies, and genre veterans might find the simplified warfare a turn-off. That said, I am wholly invested. It’s the most sandboxy of the Paradox lineup so far and I’ve been enjoying my time with it immensely. It is gorgeous, impressive, and absolutely worth the time it takes to learn. Now onto my fourth playthrough. The World Welsh Order will rise, mark my words.

Critic
80
Steam
70+9.6
Metacritic
62+18.0
Combined
66+13.8

10/18/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

Lucy Dreaming tells a compelling, concise story filled with wit and hilarity, kept me invested with a juicy mystery, and hooked me with its fantastic execution of the sarcastic adventure game protagonist trope. It never feels like a one-trick pony, and it’s a masterclass in knowing when to surprise with a sudden change in mood or shocking reveal. I went in thinking I was in for a charming point & click adventure with some gimmicks and enough jokes to keep me going, but I’m coming away convinced it’s going on my GOTY list. I wish I could forget everything about it and experience it all over again.

Critic
90
Steam
98-8.4
Metacritic
62+28.0
Combined
80+9.8

No Place for Bravery surprised me in many ways. When I first started, I was ready for a gory festival of combat with a good story to go along with it. What I got was a beautiful, dark narrative that pushed me to reach the end credits far more than the promise of combat would have. The things I loved most are things I can’t talk about in this review for fear of spoiling the experience - No Place for Bravery feels fantastic to play, and Glitch Factory has created a story that will stick with me for years.

Critic
70
Steam
72-2.4
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
72-2.4

9/19/2022

Early Review
Read Review

Sunday Gold is a game with a lot to say, says it eloquently, and has an aesthetic and artistic direction that I’ve fallen in love with. However, it must be said that the execution leaves something to be desired - the game excels in set pieces, confrontations, and dialogues, but getting from one highlight to another is a bit of a slog. I’d play another game following Frank, Sally, and Gavin in a heartbeat, but I’d hope it flows much better than Sunday Gold.

Critic
70
Steam
79-9.3
Metacritic
61+9.0
Combined
70-0.1

9/16/2022

Early Review
Read Review

There’s a lot to love about Potion Permit. It’s a game that, as mentioned, gives you a purpose, and does a great job of letting you experience the journey from total newcomer to heart of the community. It’s a perfect game for those seeking a relaxing, chilled-out experience - a tonic for a market filled with life sims that emphasise profit and efficiency. The only things lacking are a little difficulty to keep things interesting and some bug fixing to keep things running smoothly.

Critic
70
Steam
80-9.8
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
80-9.8

8/24/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

At this point in time, it takes a lot to stand out in a sea of Metroidvania action platformers. With its gorgeous presentation and memorable boss fights, Islets does just that. It has some of the tightest platforming I’ve ever experienced, but I felt that the unbalanced combat design drags it down. I really enjoyed my time with Islets - it took me around 12 hours to beat the game, and it certainly doesn’t feel like time wasted - and I’d recommend it to any fan of Metroidvanias, but I don’t think it has universal appeal.

Critic
60
Steam
96-35.9
Metacritic
80-20.0
Combined
88-27.9

8/10/2022

Early Review
Read Review

I can easily see Cult of the Lamb becoming one of the next indie darlings, and it would be utterly deserving of the epithet.

Critic
100
Steam
96+4.2
Metacritic
79+21.0
Combined
87+12.6

With all of that said, it cannot be understated how compelling this game feels. It takes all the best things from its inspirations and blends them together in a way that works. It’s a game with the combat of a Soulslike, the gameplay loop of a Monster Hunter, and the exploration of a Metroidvania, all set against a beautiful backdrop - conflicting flavours that come together to form a delicious experience. It’s greater than the sum of its parts, and it’s a game I won’t be putting down for a very long time.

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

Bringing this game to consoles turned it into the most beginner-friendly and fastest-loading version of Crusader Kings yet. It falls only slightly short of the PC version’s greatness simply through the game being built from the ground up for desktop gameplay. As it stands, Crusader Kings 3: Console Edition is the platonic ideal for console ports when it comes to strategy games.

Critic
90
Steam
91-0.6
Metacritic
83+7.0
Combined
87+3.2

3/22/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

When comparing it to its predecessors, the game feels like a sorely needed update. Yes, it treads old ground, with the same crops, monsters, items, and mechanics to deal with, but you can’t really mess with a winning formula, and the game has plenty of worthwhile additions of its own. To sum it up, playing Rune Factory 5 is a compelling, joyous experience that its fans will devour heartily as if it were a plate full of Supreme Curry.

Critic
70
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
62+8.0
Combined
62+8.0

As the first expansion of what I’ll assume will be many, Royal Court has impressed me.

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
64+26.0
Combined
64+26.0
PreviousPage 2 of 2