
Jonathan Bolding
Scoring Pattern
Disparity by Outlet
Disparity Over Time
Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
Reviews
10/31/2025
Early Review“A new bar for complexity in the historical grand strategy genre that sometimes buckles under the weight of its ambition.”
12/5/2024
Launch Window“Caves of Qud is a genre-defining achievement in play, story, and roleplaying freedom.”
11/22/2024
Launch Window“Empire of the Ants features a lavish rendering of the world from a few millimeters high, but fails at the basics of interesting RTS play.”
10/16/2024
Early Review“MechWarrior 5: Clans delivers a strong story of struggling young warriors alongside the best-ever version its iconic, lumbering mech combat.”
9/10/2024
Launch Window“Satisfactory is a masterfully made game for crafters, builders, and factory managers of all kinds.”
12/12/2023
Launch Window“A rich, interesting, and honest experiment in history-as-game: If you're interested, play it.”
10/24/2022
Early Review“Victoria 3's attractive historical sandbox is filled with potential, but it's on you to unlock it.”
8/4/2022
Launch Window“Hard West 2 has plenty of little annoyances, but it's a supernatural western tactics game with a lot of style and the substance to back it.”
7/18/2022
Launch Window“Novel tactical mechanics make this indie a contender for the best strategy RPG this year.”
5/20/2022
Launch Window“King Arthur: Knight's Tale is a strategy RPG that gets the fantasy of playing as a heavily armored knight exactly right, but it would've been a better game if it didn't pad itself out with so many repetitive battles.”
11/5/2021
Launch Window“It's still one of the best dungeon crawlers ever made, but now it's on PC.”
10/29/2021
Launch Window“Disciples: Liberation is a promising RPG with rich stories and compelling tactical combat, but nothing quite makes it a must-play.”
10/1/2021
Launch Window“Diablo 2: Resurrected brings a beloved classic up today's graphical standards, but it overlooks 20 years of obvious flaws. It's still a very satisfying action RPG, but you couldn't get away with these problems a decade ago, much less today.”
“Eastward is a post-apocalyptic picaresque as charming as it is pretty, with simple action combat and puzzles that are accessible to everyone.”
8/23/2021
Early Review“King's Bounty 2 is a unique game, but it's uniquely mediocre.”
7/16/2021
Late Review“Warhammer 40,000: Battlesector is a jolly, blood-spattered tactical romp through the grim, dark future.”
“Roguebook stands out from the pack on a few qualities, but it's not a must-play.”
“Loop Hero's cleverly stripped-down RPG concept demands attention for as long as it takes you to work out the clear "best" way to guide each hero class, and its fantastically dark story setup stands out as one of the best in years.”
3/2/2021
Late Review“Try not to suffocate… or die of boredom. Breathedge's concept of survival crafting in space may be good, but it just isn't fun.”
2/5/2021
Launch Window“Field of Glory 2: Medieval is the closest to a tabletop miniatures experience you'll get on PC.”
