Menu
Theme
A

Andy Johnson

72.0
Avg Score Given
-7.0
Steam Disparity
+3.1
MC Disparity
-1.9
Combined Disparity
15
Reviews
13 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|2 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

50
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
14.6
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

With this remaster, Firefly Studios have added a competent new sheen to their most popular game, Stronghold: Crusader. This is likely to be enough for those nostalgic for the 2002 original, but the game’s aged, frustrating mechanics may be uninviting for newcomers.

Critic
60
Steam
92-31.8
Metacritic
88-28.0
Combined
90-29.9

5/6/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Drop Duchy, with its inspired, refined combination of genres, has the makings of a breakout hit.

Critic
100
Steam
90+10.0
Metacritic
65+35.0
Combined
78+22.5

2/11/2025

Late Review
Read Review

Robobeat meets the basic expectations for a game of its type. Its weapons, enemies, soundtrack, and level design are all adequate but it falls short due to its lack of a unique hook, or compelling reason to exist.

Critic
80
Steam
95-14.6
Metacritic
76+4.0
Combined
85-5.3

With frustrating combat and linear yet opaque progression, this samurai fails his mission.

Critic
50
Steam
61-11.3
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
61-11.3

9/23/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

While it does little that is genuinely new, and exists firmly in the shadow of its forebears, Sumerian Six is a thoroughly competent addition to the small canon of real-time stealth tactics games. It is a must-play for any fan of the genre. While Artificer were sadly subjected to job losses this year by their owner-publishers Devolver, hopefully they will have the chance to make an even stronger contribution to stealth tactics in the future.

Critic
80
Steam
94-14.4
Metacritic
84-4.0
Combined
89-9.2

5/15/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

Leaving aside its connection with its survival horror forebear, Sker Ritual is a very conventional and competent multiplayer zombie shooter. It is at its best with a full team of friends who are prepared for its relentless pace and transparently “gamey” nature. Those looking for a more cerebral experience, or one that satisfies narratively, ought to look elsewhere.

Critic
75
Steam
82-6.9
Metacritic
66+9.0
Combined
74+1.0

Classified: France ‘44 transplants familiar turn-based tactics to World War II, to merely adequate effect.

Critic
65
Steam
73-8.4
Metacritic
78-13.0
Combined
76-10.7

12/20/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

Despite these shortcomings of the original game, Kingpin Reloaded could have been a useful historical exercise. It could still get closer to that goal, as Slipgate Ironworks continue to work on the remaster. The studio’s attention is divided, however, as they are surely overburdened with seven other in-development projects. As things stand, this version is very difficult to recommend and will do 3D Realms’ reputation no favours.

Critic
50
Steam
37+12.9
Metacritic
40+10.0
Combined
39+11.5

9/22/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

The automap at least keeps backtracking to a minimum in the maze-like levels of Gastro Force.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

7/31/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

While it pays homage to tactical RPG classics of the ‘90s, Arcadian Atlas does little that is new.

Critic
65
Steam
54+10.7
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
54+10.7

7/10/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

“Vandalism sim” Sludge Life 2 doesn’t reinvent the spray can, but the vibes are impeccable.

Critic
80
Steam
97-16.9
Metacritic
63+17.0
Combined
80+0.1

4/26/2023

Late Review
Read Review

This lacklustre take on the sub-genre disappoints with its boring shooting and poor handling of custom tracks.

Critic
65
Steam
56+9.3
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
56+9.3

10/30/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

Today’s glut of “boomer shooters” is largely inspired by just a handful of classics from the original golden age of roughly 1993 to 1997. Any new game runs the risk of seeming too similar to one of these icons, of lacking its own identity. At first glance, Cultic seems sure to fall into this trap, given its evident similarities to Blood. In fact, Jason Smith’s fantastic first project uses Monolith’s 1997 game as a jumping-off point – and ultimately delivers one of the best retro shooters in years.

Critic
95
Steam
97-2.4
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
97-2.4

10/4/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

Dome Keeper is a labour of love for developer Bippinbits, a two-person team based in Dresden who are also a couple. According to publisher Raw Fury, it was in profit from day one and it is easy to see why – this is a simple game, but one made to a high standard. Its pixel art, wealth of upgrades, and clever sound design are all praiseworthy. Those looking for a deeper roguelike experience should look elsewhere, but ironically Dome Keeper is ideal for players in the hunt for something a bit more surface-level.

Critic
75
Steam
92-17.3
Metacritic
76-1.0
Combined
84-9.1

4/12/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

Games which work to revive the glory days of ‘80s platformers are a fairly common sight these days, and are a logical choice of project for developers like Small Bros. B.I.O.T.A. has the special qualities that are needed to stand out from the crowd. It summons up the memory of the run-and-gun games of yesteryear, but never becomes repetitive or frustrating as they did. Its modern conveniences, like save-anywhere and a flexible character system, turn the game into something more than just a retro revival. Games with a philosophy this obviously nostalgic aren’t for everyone, but anyone who digs this retro look is sure to enjoy a trip to Frontier Horizon.

Critic
80
Steam
88-8.1
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
88-8.1