Menu
Theme
D

Dom Peppiatt

82.0
Avg Score Given
+0.6
Steam Disparity
-2.7
MC Disparity
-1.1
Combined Disparity
33
Reviews
20 early reviews (before release)|12 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|1 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

30
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
18.9
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

2/4/2026

Early Review
Read Review

Innovation is the ki to success for Team Ninja and Koei Tecmo, as Nioh 3 iterates on the formula once more to take an already great 'masocore' series to new heights.

Critic
80
Steam
83-2.9
Metacritic
85-5.0
Combined
84-3.9

9/24/2025

Early Review
Read Review

Maybe it's witchcraft. Maybe it's magic. Either way, Supergiant manages to draw down the moon with its Herculean action and epic narrative in Hades 2.

Critic
100
Steam
96+4.3
Metacritic
86+14.0
Combined
91+9.2

The politically-charged 1997 PlayStation original is one of the finest tactics games of all time. This remaster offers a brilliant new reading of what was already a classic text.

Critic
100
Steam
91+9.5
Metacritic
75+25.0
Combined
83+17.2

They say art is all about eliciting an emotional reaction; if you can do that, all the effort expended in creating it was worth it. I think Clair Obscur does that with aplomb. If you have ever loved role-playing games, ever, you owe it to yourself to play this. It has the capacity to touch you.

Critic
100
Steam
96+4.4
Metacritic
95+5.0
Combined
95+4.7

I’m actually at the point where I’m enjoying finding little problems with the game, because - most of the time - I know that means there’ll be something interesting on the other end of it. That is high praise for any work of art, but in a video game… it really feels like something special.

Critic
100
Steam
77+23.0
Metacritic
61+39.0
Combined
69+31.0

If you’ve the acquired taste for RPGs that want to bully you, humiliate you, and laugh at the fact you call yourself a gaming masochist (we're not judging), SMT5 Vengeance is for you.

Critic
100
Steam
93+7.4
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
93+7.4

2/25/2025

Early Review
Read Review

I am already 50 hours in, and I can’t wait to double - triple, quadruple! - that number in the coming weeks and months. This one’s a classic, as far as I'm concerned.

Critic
100
Steam
47+53.3
Metacritic
71+29.0
Combined
59+41.1

10/7/2024

Early Review
Read Review

Every individual strand weaves together to form something utterly exceptional in Metaphor. It may well be Atlus’ masterpiece; well-presented, well-realised, and totally unashamed to be a big, silly, fantastical piece of role-playing genius.

Critic
100
Steam
90+9.9
Metacritic
85+15.0
Combined
88+12.5

Though Hellblade 2 has the power to force your jaw open and give you goosebumps, too often the whole project ends up feeling like a very expensive tech demo – an absolute tour de force of technical achievement bogged down in its own sense of gravitas and mystery. Keeping you off the stick for so many of its most impactful moments, and not giving you enough to play with when you do have control, hobbles the potential of this visual and aural masterpiece enough to make the whole experience feel like it was constantly trying to find a foothold on that dread Icelandic scree, and never really getting to its feet until you come staggering over the finish line.

Critic
60
Steam
87-26.9
Metacritic
74-14.0
Combined
80-20.4

Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown is a smart game that makes you feel even smarter. It’s a Metroidvania that’s learned from the best, but without sacrificing any element of its own personality – for better and for worse.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
84-4.0
Combined
84-4.0

10/16/2023

Early Review
Read Review

Spider-Man 2 is exceptional. In your hands, it’s the best a superhero game has ever felt. On your eyes, it’s a pure tour de force of what the PlayStation 5 can do. On your heart, it’s heavy, enticing, exciting. The open world is a tonic, the characters are a riot, the villains are unbelievable in the best way. Suspend your disbelief in a neat little web above your head, dive in with your mask pulled tight over your face, and prepare yourself for the daftest, most earnest action game of 2023. It’s a 20-or-so hour hoot you’re not going to be able to put down until the post-credits scene has rolled.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
86+14.0
Combined
86+14.0

Mirage represents the past, present, and future of everything Assassin’s Creed stands for – and you can feel it in the game’s bones.

Critic
80
Steam
76+3.8
Metacritic
70+10.0
Combined
73+6.9

Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is an excellent action game, and a tightly-focused, well-executed example of why Team Ninja is often mentioned in the same breath as FromSoftware. Razor-sharp combat that wields the power of momentum with deft ease, supported by intricate and well-designed levels, against the backdrop of an over-the-top historical fantasy? It’s just a shame about the quality-of-life aberrations that constantly chip away at your morale.

Critic
80
Steam
49+30.7
Metacritic
67+13.0
Combined
58+21.8

2/16/2023

Early Review
Read Review

Wild Hearts often feels like a game that doesn’t want to be played. It’s fussy, it’s janky, and it constantly trips itself up. An erratic gameplay loop, an absolute bastard of a camera, and some ill-conceived weapon gimmicks prevent Koei Tecmo and EA’s experimental hunting joint from ever really succeeding where its genre rivals have. It’s ironic that building is such a core part of this game: if this is the start of a series, Omega Force has laid down some important groundwork, but it needs to make some serious structural revisions from the foundations up if it ever wants to look eye-to-eye with Capcom’s imposing juggernaut.

Critic
60
Steam
47+13.3
Metacritic
66-6.0
Combined
56+3.7

This is a top-tier rhythm action game that’s pitched as a love letter to the Final Fantasy series, brimming with content and packed with love and care. But – like some of the more ambitious double-albums out there – it sometimes feels like quantity over quality, as you trudge through some of the less well thought-out note maps in order to get to the ones you know will inspire you. Some will have more patience for that than others. Given that I’ve already played through Blue Fields about 20 times, I’ll leave you to figure out where I land on that.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
88-8.0
Combined
88-8.0

12/2/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

This isn’t to say there isn’t a good game oozing within the sticky flesh of this Frankenstein, though; it just feels like it’s not what Striking Distance wanted it to be. It’s not the next step in horror gaming, the evolution of Dead Space, or a proposition unlike anything you’ve seen before – it’s the opposite. An amalgam, less than the sum of its parts, whose main focus becomes overwrought and frustrating by the time you’re halfway through its short run-time. The scariest thing about The Callisto Protocol, sadly, is all the potential that’s been wasted on a small moon in Jupiter’s orbit.

Critic
60
Steam
65-5.2
Metacritic
68-8.0
Combined
67-6.6

11/10/2022

Early Review
Read Review

In a world where we've seen Square Enix fall down with remasters (examples include the lacklustre Final Fantasy Pixel Remasters and the egregious Kingdom Hearts on Switch), Tactics Ogre: Reborn highlights something special – a change of the guard, so to speak, that bodes remarkably well for the rest of the publisher's classic RPG oeuvre.

Critic
100
Steam
74+26.5
Metacritic
76+24.0
Combined
75+25.2

10/25/2022

Early Review
Read Review

Bigger levels, bigger fights, bigger hair – Bayonetta 3 somehow manages to edge the Platinum formula even harder to deliver one hell of a climax.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
78+22.0
Combined
78+22.0

9/12/2022

Early Review
Read Review

Metal: Hellsinger is a good time, if not a short time. Hard as nails, rewarding as they come, and fuelled by some of the best names in heavy music, The Outsider and Funcom have made a game that’s worth every second of your time it takes up – even if that’s only about the length of one of the more epic prog albums out there. A knowing and fun take on the rhythm shooter genre, plagued with some calibration and UI issues, this romp through Hell is as satisfying as it is frustrating – and not even hearing the dulcet tones and throaty growls of Trivium’s Matt Heafy can offset that.

Critic
80
Steam
96-15.9
Metacritic
75+5.0
Combined
85-5.4

9/2/2022

Launch Window
Read Review

I promise you, it’ll leave you charmed and hungry for more.

Critic
80
Steam
96-15.9
Metacritic
800.0
Combined
88-7.9
Page 1 of 2Next