Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore

Browse games Browse journalists Browse outlets Compare entities

Site

Dataset & methodology Publishing principles FAQ Terms of Service Privacy Policy

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Dylan Shirley - Review Scores & Disparity | ReviewDisparity

Home
Journalists
Dylan Shirley

Dylan Shirley

81.4

Avg Score Given

-4.5

Steam Disparity

+11.0

MC Disparity

+0.1

Combined Disparity

Reviews

1 early (14%)6 launch window (86%)0 late (0%)

Scoring Pattern

Lowest Score

Highest Score

12.2

Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

The journalist's average disparity score per outlet

Smash Jump

7 reviews

+0.1

Review summary

Updated

Reviews

Loading reviews...

Oct 18, 2026

Based on 7 scored reviews, Dylan Shirley gives games an average score of 81.4/100. Dylan Shirley scores games 4.5 points lower than Steam users and 11.0 points higher than Metacritic users.

How these comparisons are calculated

Sources behind this summary(5 recent of 7)+

Silver PinesviaSmash Jump
Oct 15, 2026Launch window
90/100View review
Steam 95.3/100 · -5.3 ptsMetacritic 84/100 · +6.0 pts
CICADAMATA"viaSmash Jump
Aug 29, 2026Launch window
90/100View review
Steam 96.7/100 · -6.7 pts
Halo: Campaign EvolvedviaSmash Jump
Aug 3, 2026Launch window
60/100View review
Steam 60.3/100 · -0.3 ptsMetacritic 58/100 · +2.0 pts
Truck-kun is Supporting Me from Another World?!viaSmash Jump
Jul 29, 2026Launch window
70/100View review
Steam 85.1/100 · -15.1 pts
ZERO PARADES: For Dead SpiesviaSmash Jump
May 19, 2026Early review
90/100View review
Steam 84.1/100 · +5.9 ptsMetacritic 59/100 · +31.0 pts