Matt Donahue

84.0

Avg Score Given

+14.0

Steam Disparity

+20.6

MC Disparity

+16.8

Combined Disparity

Reviews

5 early (24%)16 launch window (76%)0 late (0%)

Scoring Pattern

Lowest Score

100

Highest Score

9.4

Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Low score spread detected. This reviewer may use a narrow scoring range or binary scoring system.

Disparity by Outlet

The journalist's average disparity score per outlet

But Why Tho?

21 reviews

+16.8

Review summary

Updated

Reviews

Loading reviews...

Based on 21 scored reviews, Matt Donahue gives games an average score of 84.0/100. Matt Donahue scores games 14.0 points higher than Steam users and 20.6 points higher than Metacritic users.

How these comparisons are calculated

Sources behind this summary(5 recent of 21)

EA Sports College Football 27viaBut Why Tho?
Jul 10, 2026Launch window
75/100View review
Steam 39.9/100 · +35.1 ptsMetacritic 24/100 · +51.0 pts
Europa Universalis V: Fate Of The PhoenixviaBut Why Tho?
May 6, 2026Launch window
70/100View review
Steam 32.7/100 · +37.3 pts
Anno 117: Pax RomanaviaBut Why Tho?
Nov 10, 2025Early review
95/100View review
Steam 69.5/100 · +25.5 ptsMetacritic 72/100 · +23.0 pts
Surviving Mars: RelaunchedviaBut Why Tho?
Nov 7, 2025Early review
90/100View review
Steam 54.4/100 · +35.6 pts
Europa Universalis VviaBut Why Tho?
Oct 31, 2025Early review
80/100View review
Steam 66.7/100 · +13.3 ptsMetacritic 83/100 · -3.0 pts