ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

N

Nicola Lecis

36 reviews

Latest: Security 51

STWGames ItaliaAug 18, 2026Score 80

“Security 51 turns the mundane routine of a security guard into a tense bureaucratic thriller, sitting halfway between Papers, Please and the horrors of the SCP Foundation. Backed by a claustrophobic atmosphere that still knows when not to take itself too seriously, polished pixel art, and oppressive, Carpenter-esque soundscapes, Alawar’s title surprises with its variety: beyond stamping paperwork, you'll manage elevators, conduct bizarre cell experiments, and contain an outbreak with devastatingly weighty choices. Despite occasionally punishing difficulty and a core gameplay loop that might not win over those outside this niche, it remains a cynical and thoroughly successful inspection simulator—highly recommended for fans of the genre.”

+3.9
D

Deyton Dykes

1 reviews

Latest: MineGeon: Renegades

Netto’s Game RoomAug 18, 2026Score 60

“MineGeon: Renegades is an attempt at a very popular genre, clearly made by developers who are familiar with it and genuinely love it. The game almost lands the spaceship, but it ultimately falls flat because of its weak onboarding. If mechanics were explained to the player directly, the overall experience might land better than it does. It is filled with beautiful pixel art, wonderful music, and fun characters. If you enjoy bullet-hell games, I could recommend giving it a shot—though perhaps wait until you have nothing else in your backlog to play!”

-9.1
A

Anthony Mann

134 reviews

Latest: Twisted Tower

ZTGDAug 18, 2026Score 95

“I don’t think anyone is going to find anything exactly new in Twisted Tower, but I think that’s the point. It’s a throwback to some of the best parts of the seventh generation first person shooters mixed with the some of the best parts of what is now called “boomer shooters” and Twisted Tower blends them well.”

-2.1
V

Varun Karunakar

43 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

GamingBoltAug 18, 2026Score 80

“The Sinking City 2 eschews its predecessor's investigative chops to present a more straightforward trek through a semi-open world flooded with things to discover and horrors to witness. This works well with a solid premise and compelling characters, making Arkham a Sinking City that feels dangerous while remaining mysterious enough to warrant further exploration.”

+3.3
S

SECTOR.sk Staff

112 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

SECTOR.skAug 18, 2026Score 80

“Arkham is sinking, and Frogwares is changing course. The Lovecraftian horror sequel significantly shifts direction while retaining its superb atmosphere and story.”

+1.2
John-Paul Jones

John-Paul Jones

646 reviews

Latest: The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - Legacy Edition

PlayStation UniverseAug 18, 2026Score 75

“Sure it's more than a bit janky, the combat is a touch simplistic and the visuals, despite Aspyr's generous sprinkling of 4K resolution and 60 frames per second goodness upon them, still feel rather dated. Yet despite all of that, Lord of the Rings: War in the North feels oddly refreshing with its straightforward sensibilities and design resulting in an action RPG that remains good, solid fun - especially with friends and represents good value at its budget, sub $20 price point. Overall, it's just nice to have a decent Lord of the Rings game doing the rounds again, don't you think?”

+4.0
S

Silvio Mazzitelli

77 reviews

Latest: Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls

IGN ItalyAug 18, 2026Score 90

“Marvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls is another masterpiece from Arc System Works. The Japanese developers, who specialize in fighting games, have created a title brimming with love for the Marvel universe, featuring meticulous attention to detail in the design of each hero and an incredibly layered combat system that adapts to any type of player-from beginners to experts, as well as those who prefer to fight with a single character or manage an entire team.”

+3.1
Leo Stevenson

Leo Stevenson

250 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

PowerUp!Aug 18, 2026Score 85

“It doesn't reinvent the genre, but The Sinking City 2 is an impressive example of artistry, gameplay, and atmosphere, and it should be on your list to play as soon as possible.”

+5.3
K

Kevin Dunsmore

141 reviews

Latest: The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - Legacy Edition

Hardcore GamerAug 18, 2026Score 50

“Has Aspyr managed to turned a mediocre title into a must-buy, or should the studio have focused its efforts on a different Lord of the Rings title?”

+5.7
W

Windsor Santos

11 reviews

Latest: Capy Castaway

GameBlastAug 18, 2026Score 85

“With the visual style of a children's book, Capy Castaway is a great experience that evokes emotions and reflections that are very common to find in independent games.”

+5.6
Mark Delaney

Mark Delaney

332 reviews

Latest: Madden NFL 27

GameSpotAug 18, 2026Score 70

“Madden 27 is the fifth consecutive year in which the on-field experience has been foundationally sound and improves on its predecessor. It’s a heartening trajectory for a series I’ve spent my life playing, through both good and bad eras.”

+0.6
Omi Koulas

Omi Koulas

112 reviews

Latest: Feed It

Checkpoint GamingAug 18, 2026Score 75

“FEED IT takes something painfully complex and distils it into a surreal horror experience without losing sight of the disturbing realities. It focuses on psychological abuse, control and survival then lets the low-fi visual atmosphere do the work. It’s quick, but branching endings and its meaningful themes make its hour-long runtime worthwhile. Short, nasty and very uneasy but sometimes that's exactly what horror needs to be.”

+2.3
R

Ryan Pretorius

46 reviews

Latest: Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls

Nexus HubAug 18, 2026Score 90

“Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls' ultra-vibrant presentation, relentlessly satisfying combat and impressive degree of depth easily make it one of the best fighting games of the generation.”

+6.5
M

Michiel Vonck

6 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

Gaming BoulevardAug 18, 2026Score 70

“Visually, the game is one of its strongest aspects. Unreal Engine 5 creates a convincing, drowning Lovecraftian city, although technical issues, performance drops, and occasional visual problems prevent it from feeling completely polished.”

+7.9
S

Stephanie Watel

13 reviews

Latest: Twisted Tower

DualShockersAug 18, 2026Score 90

“The world of Twisted Tower is impressively vast, with so much to explore from one playthrough to the next. Its thematic and narrative depth is commendable too, though it could have pushed the envelope just a bit further on that front.”

-1.3
Anthony Culinas

Anthony Culinas

150 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

The Beta NetworkAug 18, 2026Score 90

“The Sinking City 2 is a huge improvement over its predecessor. It trades much of its detective-focused identity for a tense and atmospheric survival-horror experience that wears its Resident Evil, Silent Hill and Dead Space influences proudly. While the story ultimately fails to leave much of an impression, the excellent combat, clever exploration and suitably creepy rendition of Arkham make this one hell of a good time. Frogwares may have sacrificed some of the original’s unique personality, but in return they’ve created a much better survival-horror game. And honestly, who can argue with that?”

+2.0
C

Carlos França Junior

303 reviews

Latest: Wild Blue Skies

GameBlastAug 18, 2026Score 65

“Wild Blue Skies was a bittersweet experience for me. While I am a fan of shooters and enjoyed the adventure, its inspiration from Star Fox goes beyond mere homage; it features moments that replicate patterns so closely they stifle the game's potential originality, from the narrative to the level design. That said, if you have never played the Nintendo title, it is worth taking a chance on these blue skies.”

-1.5
Adam S. D. Stewart

Adam S. D. Stewart

18 reviews

Latest: Twisted Tower

Gamer Social ClubAug 18, 2026Score 90

“From the title screen, I knew I was going to like Twisted Tower. Drawing on a clear love of Bioshock, it tells its own twisted story in a fun and creepy way. Satisfying, brutal combat will take you on a compelling, and gory, adventure to save the damsel in distress through a well-crafted carnival of madness.”

+7.6
J

Jordan Swift

12 reviews

Latest: Anomaly President

MKAU GamingAug 18, 2026Score 80

“While gaming is a huge part of this world, and side-scrollers aren’t particularly my favourite, I found myself wanting to try over and over and over again to get better. I think Anomaly President has an excellent team behind it and is a massively fun game to play, and I am excited to see how they expand from where it is now.”

-4.0
L

Leandro Felippe de Paiva Gomes

28 reviews

Latest: Twisted Tower

Pizza FriaAug 18, 2026Score 78

“Twisted Tower features a theme that kept me extremely immersed from beginning to end. The puzzles scattered throughout the environments were also a great success and kept me interested in discovering what awaited me in each new room at all times.”

-4.3
PreviousPage 15 of 509Next