ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

م

مصطفى عرجون

4 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

Saudi GamerAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“The game leans more on survival than pure horror, with environments that grow richer as you progress. Its engaging story and strong environmental storytelling make it one of the finest adaptations of H.P. Lovecraft’s unsettling world. Fans of survival horror, especially titles like Silent Hill, will find much to enjoy—despite a few flaws.”

+11.7
A

Anton Semchenko

18 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

Oyungezer OnlineAug 17, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“A fantastic survival horror game that applies the Resident Evil formula brilliantly and manages to stand toe-to-toe with the genre's best. A must-play for fans of the genre and Lovecraft enthusiasts alike!”

-3.2
K

Kai Tatsumoto

23 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

WccftechAug 17, 2026Score 75Pre-release Review

“Both frustrating and intriguing all the same, Mortal Shell II vastly improves on the original title with a world filled with secret dungeons about while routinely kicking the player's teeth in without mercy.”

+3.3
A

Aden Carter

22 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Game SandwichAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell 2 is a great step forward from the original; one that takes extra brutality, a more scenic world, and magnificently designed enemies and puts them in the forefront. The world is full of life, and every inch of it is worth exploring - from the poisoned swamp to the snowy alcoves. The brutal gameplay, combined with a plethora of items to create a build makes this one of the best soulslike titles I have played. Unfortunately, it still has a little ways to go when it comes to the mechanical aspects, as glitchy bosses, a world you can and will fall through, and broken weapons make it difficult to fully love the title. If you can get past that, it is a game that is worth coming back to.”

-4.0
Pam K. Ferdinand

Pam K. Ferdinand

30 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

GameRantAug 17, 2026Score 85Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell 2 is an impressive Soulslike that improves on its predecessor in nearly every way, even with a few rough edges to work around.”

-5.2
A

Alessandro Zingariello

15 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

CrazyGameCommunity.itAug 17, 2026Score 85Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell II marks a successful comeback for the studio, refining and evolving its predecessor's formula to deliver a polished and enjoyable experience.”

-2.7
D

Dagmara Kottke

15 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

WayTooManyGamesAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“The Sinking City 2 will pull you in like quicksand. It may not be a technical marvel, but it has that “something” that can keep you entertained for many hours.”

-2.1
C

Cory Wells

197 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Hardcore GamerAug 17, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell II tries some new things while looking and running beautiful.”

+14.4
D

DualShockers Staff

76 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

DualShockersAug 17, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“The Sinking City 2 is an absolute triumph, not only due to its harrowing real-world origins, but because of how Frogwares masterfully crafted a survival horror game as their first product in the genre.”

-0.6
A

Arman Zarmehr

57 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

GamefaAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“The Sinking City 2 is a commendable Lovecraftian survival-horror title that successfully preserves the identity of its predecessor while seamlessly weaving it with the core tenets of the survival genre. Its narrative is gripping, and the environmental storytelling flourishes through atmospheric world-building, evocative sound design, and a fittingly haunting soundtrack. The survival mechanics are well-balanced, and exploring the city of Arkham serves as a superb conduit to engage with them. Nevertheless, The Sinking City 2 remains plagued by various technical and artistic shortcomings that ultimately keep it from ascending to higher echelons”

+5.6
C

CGMagazine Staff

64 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

CGMagazineAug 17, 2026Score 85Pre-release Review

“The Sinking City 2 offers a solid survival horror experience that feels both different and similar to its predecessor.”

+0.7
T

The Outerhaven Productions Staff

45 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

The Outerhaven ProductionsAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“The Sinking City 2 may fall shy of becoming the definitive Lovecraftian video game, but it’s definitely an evocative love letter to cosmic horror. Combat works well enough, but it’s the puzzles, narrative, and submerged world that shine from the depths, beckoning survival horror fans to give this game a go.”

-0.1
G

Gaming Boulevard Staff

50 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Gaming BoulevardAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell II isn’t trying to prove that it can make a better Dark Souls. It’s trying to prove that a Soulslike can evolve without losing what made the genre special in the first place. And after playing it, I think Cold Symmetry has made a pretty convincing argument.”

+8.4
G

Gareth Chadwick

164 reviews

Latest: Sephiria

TheSixthAxisAug 17, 2026Score 90

“Sephiria is great, I can't stop thinking about my next run if that's any indication to you. Whilst the bosses could be better, they're not a dealbreaker as the rest of the combat is excellent. Whilst there are a lot of roguelites around these days, this is definitely one of the better ones.”

-6.1
M

Marcus Kenneth

18 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

CGMagazineAug 17, 2026Score 85Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell II is easily one of the biggest improvements from one entry to the next that I've seen in this space.”

-1.3
A

Arthur Tayt-Sohn

27 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Game Lodge Aug 17, 2026Score 95Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell 2 is the definitive experience in the Cold Symmetry series. It’s a massive leap forward from the first game and, for me, one of the most interesting action games of the year so far.”

+6.3
C

Chuck Zimmerheld

5 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Giant BombAug 17, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell II is a 'fun-forward' souls-like, one that values flexibility and variety over sheer difficulty. It grabs you and plies you with a plethora of options for tackling its monsters, dungeons, and bosses, handing you shiny toys and trusts you to work out what to do with them.”

+2.0
J

Jarrett Green

65 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

IGNAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell 2’s expansion into a large scale action-RPG is mostly successful, and all of its new ideas are great ones.”

-2.7
L

Luis Avilés

31 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Seasoned GamingAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Taking all the right lessons, Mortal Shell II is a relentless soulslike and an unrecognizably better sequel.”

+4.5
R

Richard Wakeling

154 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

GameSpotAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Mortal Shell 2 constantly surprised me, whether it was the mechanics behind a newly discovered Shell, the layered improvements to combat, a bulbous monstrosity of a boss fight that was more mouth than anything else, or the ways you can tinker with a build and make it wholly your own.”

+3.6
PreviousPage 18 of 509Next