ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

م

مصطفى عرجون

4 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

Saudi GamerAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“The game leans more on survival than pure horror, with environments that grow richer as you progress. Its engaging story and strong environmental storytelling make it one of the finest adaptations of H.P. Lovecraft’s unsettling world. Fans of survival horror, especially titles like Silent Hill, will find much to enjoy—despite a few flaws.”

+11.7
Chris Wray

Chris Wray

272 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

WccftechAug 17, 2026Score 85Pre-release Review

“The Sinking City 2 is a far tighter, story-driven game - still with exploration and investigations, albeit more limited - than the original. Only really let down by the smallest of niggles, the game features excellent world-building, supported by challenging survival-horror combat and gameplay, decent exploration and puzzles, and a story that is genuinely interesting until the end, with a small but strong cast of characters. Fans of the original may be missing the open-world and detective focus, but the trade-off and direction of this stand-alone sequel feels right, and performs brilliantly.”

+1.7
Daniel Kucner

Daniel Kucner

61 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

GameOnlyAug 17, 2026Score 70Pre-release Review

“It's a fine game… and that’s about it. It’s enjoyable and I had fun reviewing, but it's still miles away from Resident Evil series. Unfortunately It's also a a case of blatantly unused potential, mostly due to horribly weak most of the storyline.”

-1.2
A

Aidan O'Brien

17 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

ShacknewsAug 17, 2026Score 70Pre-release Review

“Mostly, it’s a solid evolution for Frogwares, and it makes me very curious about their next game. I hope it’s a survival horror, and they find the opportunity and inspiration to really push at the boundaries of the genre, as all the signs point to them having a lot more to offer here.”

+5.4
Z

Zbigniew Woźnicki

16 reviews

Latest: The Sinking City 2

GRYOnline.plAug 17, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“In the new The Sinking City, developers at Frogwares have swapped the detective-occultist gameplay for a survival horror experience. It’s a truly successful step into the genre: the combat is satisfying, and the environmental puzzles are highly inventive and engaging. Fans of the genre should keep The Sinking City 2 in mind. Those who enjoyed the first game may feel a slight disappointment, and although I initially had mixed feelings too, I ended up having a lot of fun with the game. Frogwares took a risk by ditching the detective elements, but it’s worked out very well.”

-0.5
M

MariaRosaria Cozzolino

12 reviews

Latest: Agent 64: Spies Never Die

STWGames ItaliaAug 17, 2026Score 70

“Agent 64: Spies Never Die is an excellent tribute to the unforgettable Goldeneye 007, especially thanks to the sheer volume of content available, but it fails to rise to the level of a good game in its own right and ends up feeling overly derivative. Furthermore, although the project boasts exquisite art and level design, the issues plaguing both end up dragging down the entire experience.”

-10.4
D

Dustin Spencer

139 reviews

Latest: Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls

Capsule ComputersAug 16, 2026Score 80

“Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls is different in the best ways possible, blending Arc System Works' stylistic approach to a beloved roster of characters. It may be smaller than most offerings, but it absolutely makes up for that with originality and gorgeous visuals within.”

+3.4
M

Mike Bridge

27 reviews

Latest: Grain Rot

MKAU GamingAug 16, 2026Score 90

“Overall, Grain Rot was a good, fun, yet scary extraction shooter; I didn’t expect to enjoy it as much as I did. The light humour above ground, the dark, corrupted underground, and elements of base building, survival, and inventory management had me hooked. Grain Rot is also multiplayer, which I unfortunately didn’t get to test, but I think it would be a lot of fun. This is definitely a title you want to pick up if you are on the fence or if the extraction shooter is your genre.”

-0.5
L

Lyssa Greywood

65 reviews

Latest: Servant of the Lake

Screen HypeAug 16, 2026Score 80

“Servant of the Lake is a strange little puzzle game that sits somewhere between dark, cosy, and quietly unsettling. You play as a newly hired housekeeper at the Vanderboom estate, spending a weekend completing tasks for the man who lives there and his visiting family members. At first, it all sounds rather ordinary. Then the house reveals things a normal housekeeper probably wouldn't expect. Servant of the Lake is weird, creepy, and occasionally downright disgusting, but it has a wonderfully distinctive identity. Its puzzles can be genuinely difficult to crack, and the game loves hiding its clues in places you might never think to look. I found myself frustrated more than once, but I enjoyed the challenge even when I was smacking my head off my keyboard. It's a particularly good fit for players who enjoy dark, atmospheric puzzle games and don't mind getting a little gross along the way. I wouldn't call it my perfect puzzle game, but there's something really compelling about how confidently Servant of the Lake commits to its strange little world.”

-7.9
Zoey Handley

Zoey Handley

197 reviews

Latest: Happy's Humble Burger Cult

Maximum UtmostAug 16, 2026Score 60

“While I can’t be sure how everything fits together when played with others, even the solo play of Happy’s Humble Burger Cult is an enjoyable slice of job. It’s definitely not Overcooked in terms of depth, and the horror is pushed out of the way to make room for hijinks, but the care that Scythe Studios always put into the small details elevates it. Really, it’s not made from the freshest ingredients, but it’s a tasty sandwich that gives you what you paid for.”

-12.4
F

Fran J. Ruiz

39 reviews

Latest: Pokémon Pokopia Expansion Pass - Part 1: Bubbly Basin

SavePoint GamingAug 16, 2026Score 80

“Bubbly Basin is a charming, densely packed extension of Pokémon Pokopia that rewards returning players with more room to create. Its biggest limitation is that many of the game’s most meaningful improvements arrive through the free update instead.”

+2.8
Jeremy Schepper

Jeremy Schepper

9 reviews

Latest: The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - Legacy Edition

Netto’s Game RoomAug 16, 2026Score 80

“If you're a fan of fantasy games, especially Lord of the Rings, I think War in the North - Legacy Edition is easy to recommend. You'll get a great story, plenty of solid action and some genuinely challenging combat that might push you to your limits. Get some friends to play with you, and you'll be set for a wonderful journey. If you play it solo, you can certainly still have some fun, but the game's rougher edges will certainly be made more apparent, and might hamper your overall experience.”

-2.8
Sammy Hanson

Sammy Hanson

105 reviews

Latest: Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls

MKAU GamingAug 16, 2026Score 90

“Capcom’s Marvel games will always be all-time classics, but Arc System Works and Marvel have made something truly special with the first-ever 4v4 tag fighter and more characters soon to join the fray. MARVEL Tōkon: Fighting Souls has finally arrived and is ready to rock this universe!”

+5.0
M

Michał Marasek

40 reviews

Latest: The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - Legacy Edition

GameOnlyAug 16, 2026Score 60

“Although I had a good time with it, I doubt new The Lord of the Rings: War in the North will win over players experiencing War in the North for the first time. It’s great that the game has returned to stores and can be easily played on modern hardware, but lack of certain features like 21:9 ultrawide support simply aren’t acceptable for a modern release.”

-7.4
М

Михаил Пономарев

91 reviews

Latest: Big Walk

3DNewsAug 16, 2026Score 100

“One of the best games for spending time with friends. Big Walk doesn't try to limit you, doesn't force you to rush, and doesn't stress you out, but creates all the conditions for a fun and soulful time.”

+3.0
G

Greg Wheeler

177 reviews

Latest: Servant of the Lake

TheReviewGeekAug 15, 2026Score 70

“Servant of the Lake is a creepy and enjoyable point-and-click adventure packed with bizarre charm and varied puzzles, even if some design choices keep it from reaching greater heights”

-9.6
Adrian Oprea

Adrian Oprea

1 reviews

Latest: Security 51

Raider KingAug 15, 2026Score 68

“Security 51 nails the checkpoint gameplay and backs it up with genuinely gorgeous pixel art. But it forgets the other half of what makes this genre work: there's no one to actually care about, no moral weight to your decisions, and almost nothing tying your daily grind to the story. Worth playing for the loop and the visuals, just don't go in expecting a narrative to match.”

-3.7
I

István Szabó

14 reviews

Latest: Tukoni: Forest Keepers

AdventureGames.huAug 15, 2026Score 60Pre-release Review

“It’s a shame that Tukoni received so little attention from its developers, because it could have been a truly great game. Aside from its graphics and music, players were left with something rather formulaic, despite the considerable anticipation surrounding it even as an indie title.”

-14.3
J

Jordan Wood

2 reviews

Latest: Montabi

JetsonPlaysGamesAug 15, 2026Score 80

“Mankibo has threaded the needle to make Montabi competent in its worst moments and very nearly great in its best.”

+0.3
P

Peter Derks

50 reviews

Latest: Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls

EvilgamerzAug 15, 2026Score 90

“It should be clear that 'Marvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls' is a successful tag team fighter. Casuals can hold spectacular battles perfectly well with auto combos, and the Tony Starks can go wild with all the bizarrely named mechanics. The game looks great, sounds good, feels good, and plays wonderfully. Fortunately, developer Arc System Works is not averse to supporting games for a long time, so there will likely be enough unique characters to make the current roster of “only” 21 even stronger.”

+0.1
PreviousPage 19 of 509Next