ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

H

Hakim MOKHBI

5 reviews

Latest: Tales of Eternia Remastered

Just Play itOct 16, 2026Score 80

“Tales of Eternia Remastered brings back one of the most memorable adventures in the Tales of series, with its touching story, enjoyable combat system, and beautiful art direction. Despite some outdated design elements and improvements that don’t cover every aspect of the game, it manages to preserve the charm of the original while delivering a classic experience that is still worth discovering.”

-3.5
D

Daniel Boyd

7 reviews

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

GamingBoltOct 16, 2026Score 70

“A generous nostalgia trip with some lasting highlights, held back by weaker games, dated visuals and poor audio quality.”

-6.7
Krist Duro

Krist Duro

111 reviews

Latest: Odd Town

Duuro MagazineOct 16, 2026Score 65

“Odd Town is difficult to recommend broadly. Its unusual visuals, charming animations, and strange inhabitants give it an identity I appreciate, and there is fun here once its rules make sense. The onboarding and controller feel make reaching that point harder than it should be. If its particular brand of weirdness appeals to you, you might enjoy the visit. I would understand just as easily if you decided to leave early.”

-1.3
C

Coller Entragian

112 reviews

Latest: Spy Drops Gaiden

Cubed3Oct 16, 2026Score 70

“Spy Drops Gaiden is a competent and well made retro stealth action game. It's a bit of a lightweight compared to something like Ghost Babel, which was stuffed to the brim with content and interesting challenges, but it's also priced accordingly. The whole thing is over in a couple of hours and ends when things get interesting. With a solid foundation in place, adding more areas and puzzle-like environments could unlock great potential for similar games.”

-9.8
Justin Nation

Justin Nation

5067 reviews

Latest: SENTO SURVIVOR : Slip, Grab, and Bathe in Glory!

Nindie SpotlightOct 16, 2026Score 66

“While the single-player campaign is somewhat goofy and can be fun, a lack of direction, the very close camera, and confusion reign in multiplayer”

-7.2
Eduardo Rebouças

Eduardo Rebouças

135 reviews

Latest: over the hill

EntertainiumOct 16, 2026Score 100

“Funselektor Labs’ Over the Hill is yet another certified casual gaming masterpiece.”

+2.8
A

Alex Jung

22 reviews

Latest: Gears of War: E-Day

TestingBuddiesOct 16, 2026Score 90

“Gears of War: E-Day is a stunning comeback with fun, fast-paced cover shooting, smart enemies and the best visuals in the series, held back only slightly by stiff NPC animations and some ragdoll glitches.”

+3.0
M

Michelle See-Tho

22 reviews

Latest: The Witch's Bakery

Nintendo LifeOct 16, 2026Score 80

“On the surface, The Witch's Bakery is a simple cosy adventure sim about a young witch running a bakery. But bite into those flaky pastry layers and you'll find a creamy centre: a narratively strong game with mental health themes. The emotional issues are handled gently, never oversimplified, and feel universal.Between Lunne 'curing' customers' Regrets and the bigger, darker storylines, this 15-hour game acknowledges that emotions are tough, and that there is no magic fix. Still, it's a reminder that when everything seems terrible, sometimes all you need is a friend to listen – and a little sweet treat.”

-14.8
S

Simone Jung

4 reviews

Latest: HORSE CLUB Ride West

TestingBuddiesOct 16, 2026Score 65

“HORSE CLUB Ride West offers a charming Wild West setting and six different horses, but a thin story, frequent crashes and bugs that can block 100% completion keep it from matching its good predecessor.”

+14.0
A

Ali Haider

170 reviews

Latest: Tales of Eternia Remastered

Twisted VoxelOct 16, 2026Score 80

“The real-time combat and darker story still make Tales of Eternia a worthwhile RPG, and its generous quality-of-life options make revisiting it far less of a grind.”

-1.7
A

Antonio Benítez

31 reviews

Latest: Silver Pines

Chicas GamersOct 16, 2026Score 84

“Silver Pines is a fascinating blend of classic survival horror and Metroidvania that stands out for its intriguing narrative, extraordinary art direction, and an atmosphere evocative of the genre's greatest icons. Although its gameplay leaves room for improvement and its influences occasionally wear on its sleeve, Wych Elm succeeds in crafting an experience with a distinct identity that will thoroughly delight fans of psychological horror.”

+2.5
D

Dom Peppiatt

78 reviews

Latest: Castlevania: Belmont's Curse

EurogamerOct 15, 2026Score 60

“Ambitious, aggressive, and accomplished, Belmont's Curse whips out some of the best Castlevania highs you can experience - but technical issues and some awkward controls means it can all end in bloody tears if you're not careful.”

+3.8
C

Christiaan Ribbens

129 reviews

Latest: over the hill

EvilgamerzOct 15, 2026Score 69

“Over the Hill is a nice, cozy game where exploration, leisurely driving, and small terrain challenges blend well. The attractive design and excellent music make traversing nature a pleasant experience, while rewards and upgrades keep you occupied along the way. The stuttering music and unclear commentary are a shame, but they hardly got in the way of my enjoyment. However, it does feel like the world and vehicle customizations could offer even more possibilities, and that a major update could make this a more substantial game. Those who mainly drive from one mission to the next will therefore sometimes miss some variety. With friends, the game will be much more fun for chatting together. Give yourself the space to wander around and try a tricky slope, and Over the Hill truly shines. Just perhaps you shouldn't take that tempting shortcut through the trees.”

-4.4
Bahram Bigharaz

Bahram Bigharaz

121 reviews

Latest: Gears of War: E-Day

BazimagOct 15, 2026Score 85

“Gears of War: E-Day is precisely the turning point this storied franchise needed after years of trial and error—a glorious, dark, and visceral return to the authentic roots of a series defined by raw brutality and grueling combat. By reviving the heavy, terrifying weight of warfare, seamlessly blending modern movement with a dynamic, destructible cover system, and delivering one of this generation's most breathtaking visual showcases via Unreal Engine 5, The Coalition once again elevates the standard for third-person shooters. While underdeveloped chemistry between young Marcus and Dom, repetitive side quests, and a slight dip in late-game enemy variety hold it back from absolute perfection, the harrowing fall of Kalona alongside addictive gunplay, exceptional pacing, and a rich multiplayer suite make E-Day a gripping, bone-chilling triumph. It is a masterclass in gunpowder and gore that proves the Gears name still demands absolute reverence”

+1.8
K

Kelvin Richards

6 reviews

Latest: Frosthaven

Analog Stick GamingOct 15, 2026Score 85

“Frosthaven has been a fun time to play, with no bugs to speak of. The visuals are clean from the simple map you see on the over world, to the isometric battle fields you fight on. You can tell the devs put a lot of time into making the world feel as real as possible. And the sounds are crisp, not to mention that the narration for the events and fights are beautiful.”

+7.7
M

Matheus Jenevain

114 reviews

Latest: Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea

Pizza FriaOct 15, 2026Score 79

“Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea is a really cool game within a saga and genre, excellent for moments of relaxation and those in which we just want to connect with nature. Virtually, of course, because I'm running from mosquitoes, ticks, and other things of that nature.”

+5.8
Andrew Stretch

Andrew Stretch

144 reviews

Latest: The Jackbox Party Pack 12

TechRaptorOct 15, 2026Score 85

“The Jackbox Party Pack 12 supplies fans with five unique titles that range from completely off the wall humor to a focused and intense trivia game. Not all games will fit the vibe of a party, but at least one or two always will.”

+1.1
C

CHANJOONG, LEE

5 reviews

Latest: Dragon's Dogma 2: Dark Arisen

PNNOct 15, 2026Score 80

“While the base game offered the fun of slowly exploring a vast world, it was bound to be divisive due to its slow progression and convenience issues. It seems this expansion pack chose to increase gameplay density with richer content rather than altering the unique characteristics of the base game. In that it more clearly demonstrated the charm of combat and exploration that 'Dragon's Dogma 2' possesses.”

-8.0
L

Lucas White

376 reviews

Latest: Tales of Eternia Remastered

ShacknewsOct 15, 2026Score 50

“From destroying a legendary piece of animation to scattershotting sprite filtering to no useful end, this is a fumble that makes my heart hurt. The restored skits are nice, but that’s like pouring a glass of water on a fire.”

-0.3
D

Daniel Cairns

3 reviews

Latest: Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival

DarkZeroOct 15, 2026Score 80

“Right, I'm quite impressed I've got through this review without any quotes or references from the films, so I guess I'll cram them into the conclusion.”

-5.2
PreviousPage 2 of 512Next