ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

أ

أمجد سليم علي

1 reviews

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

Eternal GamesOct 15, 2026Score 60

“Toy Story: Retro Roundup is a good collection for fans of the series and classic games, but at the same time, it is a missed opportunity to present these games the way they truly deserve. Despite the improvements and additions included, they remain limited and fail to address the most prominent issues of the original experience, particularly regarding controls and the camera. It would have been better to deliver a proper remake or remaster that develops these aspects and makes the games smoother and more enjoyable, while preserving their original spirit that made them memorable in players' minds.”

-15.4
Dominic Leighton

Dominic Leighton

472 reviews

Latest: over the hill

TheSixthAxisOct 15, 2026Score 80

“The Runner series is amongst my favourite driving games of all time, and over the hill is a unique take in the same spirit as those games. Its cosy, calming outlook and laidback vibes could have felt out of place, but this is an adventure game, in the truest sense of the word.”

+3.4
P

PS4Blog.net Staff

1406 reviews

Latest: Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea

PS4Blog.netOct 15, 2026Score 85

“Are you ready to explore the enchanted world of Teradea and find true love?”

+2.9
J

Julio Pedroza

7 reviews

Latest: Castlevania: Belmont's Curse

Neutral GameOct 15, 2026Score 93

“Belmont’s Curse is the Castlevania we’ve been waiting for: fluid whip combat, bosses that push you to the limit, and a castle that feels like the real thing.”

+8.4
R

Rômulo de Araújo

4 reviews

Latest: Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival

SupernovasOct 15, 2026Score 71

“Hellraiser: Revival understands the type of horror it needs to portray, but it fails to support that identity with gameplay and polish of a matching caliber. The Genesis Configuration and the Labyrinth contain the adventure’s best ideas, though inconsistent combat and technical issues make it difficult to recommend a purchase without reservations.”

-1.4
Andrew Stretch

Andrew Stretch

144 reviews

Latest: The Jackbox Party Pack 12

TechRaptorOct 15, 2026Score 85

“The Jackbox Party Pack 12 supplies fans with five unique titles that range from completely off the wall humor to a focused and intense trivia game. Not all games will fit the vibe of a party, but at least one or two always will.”

+1.1
D

Dom Peppiatt

78 reviews

Latest: Castlevania: Belmont's Curse

EurogamerOct 15, 2026Score 60

“Ambitious, aggressive, and accomplished, Belmont's Curse whips out some of the best Castlevania highs you can experience - but technical issues and some awkward controls means it can all end in bloody tears if you're not careful.”

+3.8
C

Christiaan Ribbens

129 reviews

Latest: over the hill

EvilgamerzOct 15, 2026Score 69

“Over the Hill is a nice, cozy game where exploration, leisurely driving, and small terrain challenges blend well. The attractive design and excellent music make traversing nature a pleasant experience, while rewards and upgrades keep you occupied along the way. The stuttering music and unclear commentary are a shame, but they hardly got in the way of my enjoyment. However, it does feel like the world and vehicle customizations could offer even more possibilities, and that a major update could make this a more substantial game. Those who mainly drive from one mission to the next will therefore sometimes miss some variety. With friends, the game will be much more fun for chatting together. Give yourself the space to wander around and try a tricky slope, and Over the Hill truly shines. Just perhaps you shouldn't take that tempting shortcut through the trees.”

-4.4
Angelina Bonilla

Angelina Bonilla

31 reviews

Latest: Tenebris Somnia

CBROct 15, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“Tenebris Somniais a memorable survival horror experience that combines retro pixel art with unsettling live-action sequences to create a nightmare that feels both familiar and deeply disturbing.”

-4.5
S

Salal Awan

197 reviews

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

Twisted VoxelOct 15, 2026Score 70

“The real appeal of Toy Story: Retro Roundup is seeing how wildly the same games could differ across consoles, with useful rewind and save features making these old favourites easier to revisit. Some handheld releases feel dated, but Toy Story 2 and the bonus A Bug's Life make this a worthwhile trip back.”

+2.6
A

A.J. Maciejewski

3329 reviews

Latest: Order of the Sinking Star

Video ChumsOct 15, 2026Score 80

“As a culmination of many puzzle concepts and a deeply rewarding sense of progression, Order of the Sinking Star is a shining star indeed. 🌠”

-4.1
K

Kelvin Richards

6 reviews

Latest: Frosthaven

Analog Stick GamingOct 15, 2026Score 85

“Frosthaven has been a fun time to play, with no bugs to speak of. The visuals are clean from the simple map you see on the over world, to the isometric battle fields you fight on. You can tell the devs put a lot of time into making the world feel as real as possible. And the sounds are crisp, not to mention that the narration for the events and fights are beautiful.”

+7.7
Bahram Bigharaz

Bahram Bigharaz

121 reviews

Latest: Gears of War: E-Day

BazimagOct 15, 2026Score 85

“Gears of War: E-Day is precisely the turning point this storied franchise needed after years of trial and error—a glorious, dark, and visceral return to the authentic roots of a series defined by raw brutality and grueling combat. By reviving the heavy, terrifying weight of warfare, seamlessly blending modern movement with a dynamic, destructible cover system, and delivering one of this generation's most breathtaking visual showcases via Unreal Engine 5, The Coalition once again elevates the standard for third-person shooters. While underdeveloped chemistry between young Marcus and Dom, repetitive side quests, and a slight dip in late-game enemy variety hold it back from absolute perfection, the harrowing fall of Kalona alongside addictive gunplay, exceptional pacing, and a rich multiplayer suite make E-Day a gripping, bone-chilling triumph. It is a masterclass in gunpowder and gore that proves the Gears name still demands absolute reverence”

+1.8
D

Domenico Musicò

296 reviews

Latest: Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival

Everyeye.itOct 15, 2026Score 65

“Hellraiser: Revival is a worthy return, but not a definitive rebirth: it certainly deserves attention for what it attempts to preserve in a landscape where many horror productions tend to homogenize languages ​​and mechanics.”

-1.3
M

Matheus Jenevain

114 reviews

Latest: Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea

Pizza FriaOct 15, 2026Score 79

“Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea is a really cool game within a saga and genre, excellent for moments of relaxation and those in which we just want to connect with nature. Virtually, of course, because I'm running from mosquitoes, ticks, and other things of that nature.”

+5.8
J

Jason Coles

242 reviews

Latest: The Jackbox Party Pack 12

TheSixthAxisOct 15, 2026Score 80

“Jackbox Party Pack 12 is a really good party game bundle, and if you've been hoping for some new and genuinely fresh games to drag your mates into, it's definitely going to get the job done. The fact that both Hyperface and Megapals feel actually new is also an accomplishment when we're so many years into the series.”

+0.4
J

Jake Mounsey

5 reviews

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

SwitchabooOct 15, 2026Score 60

“While I enjoyed my time with Toy Story: Retro Roundup, I don’t expect this will be for everyone. I see this more as a museum display rather than a game collection and I feel Digital Eclipse feels the same way since that was clearly their intention. If you want to learn a thing or two about the early days of Traveller’s Tales before they became the go-to dev team for Lego games, then I’d suggest picking this up but if you’re more interested in the games on offer, I think you should just pick up an old PS1 copy of Toy Story 2 if you can find one and leave it at that.”

-3.8
M

Matt Masem

35 reviews

Latest: Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea

RPGamerOct 15, 2026Score 80

“Echoes of Teradea executes open-world exploration brilliantly without sacrificing core farming and relationship-building mechanics. While the occasional wolf or polar bear might trigger a quick urge to swing a sword, the overall experience proves deeply rewarding without one.”

-6.9
B

Bruno de Souza Bom

17 reviews

Latest: Tenebris Somnia

Press AttackOct 15, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“Some investigation sequences can interrupt the pacing when we cannot immediately identify which item we need to use or combine. Although most puzzles are intuitive, I found myself stuck at certain points, trying to figure out what the game expected from me and revisiting areas that had nothing to do with the situation at hand. It is also difficult not to question some of the protagonist's decisions, especially given Ivan's disappearance and the lack of answers. Overall, these are minor limitations, accompanied by an additional consideration for those seeking to complete everything: missable achievements require careful attention to save files and campaign progression. These aspects could have been handled better, but they do not compromise the experience. On the other hand, Tenebris Somnia makes excellent use of its investigation mechanics. The ability to collect and combine items, discover new ways to interact with the environments, and tackle specific situations, such as the battle in the dark room, provides enough variety to maintain interest throughout the campaign. The narrative also gains momentum as we descend through the building's floors and learn more about Ivan's memories. Although combat plays a secondary role, boss encounters introduce distinct moments into the progression, while exploration and puzzles sustain most of the experience. The biggest highlight is the integration of gameplay and cinematic sequences. The live-action actors, practical effects, scene direction, and sound design contribute to an atmosphere that also works in the 2D sections, where the game demonstrates its ability to inspire fear without relying on filmed footage. The story, which revolves around a troubled relationship, cults, and disturbing events, gains strength by presenting conflicts that feel tangible. This is a testament to a script that sustains curiosity until the most unsettling moments, even across its multiple endings. Tenebris Somnia is an exceptionally competent production that delivers on its vision, featuring a distinctive visual identity, well-executed investigation mechanics, and a cinematic presentation that makes the experience particularly memorable.”

M

Mary Billington

260 reviews

Latest: Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea

Video ChumsOct 15, 2026Score 83

“Harvest Moon: Echoes of Teradea is a step up from its predecessor, introducing more vertical terrain and dense maps that make for rewarding exploration. Seeing the series continue to focus less on farming is an interesting pivot but I'm having a ton of fun with it. 🐄”

+0.1
PreviousPage 3 of 512Next
+11.8