ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
Dataset & methodologyPublishing principlesFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Find the critics closest to players and the ones furthest away

Browse individual journalists, inspect their latest review activity, and sort by recency, review volume, or disparity to surface the voices that track closest to audience sentiment.

S

Seth Hay

201 reviews

Latest: Brigandine Abyss

Cat with MonocleAug 27, 2026Score 75

“Brigandine Abyss is a pawsitively deep strategy RPG with plenty of content, fantastic music, and deep army customization. Its dated visuals, lengthy battles, and questionable battle decisions make the road to conquest a bit bumpy, but there’s still plenty of strategic fun to sink your claws into.”

+2.2
G

Gameblog Staff

359 reviews

Latest: Star Wars Zero Company

GameblogAug 27, 2026Score 90

“Quote not yet available”

-0.6
S

Steve Whiting

3 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

SwitchabooAug 27, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“This was always going to be a tricky review, and it was mostly going to be about how it ports across to the Switch 2. I had no complaints about the performance and of course Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition itself was voted Game of the Year for a reason. To that end, if you haven’t played the original and you like adventure games that you can sink hours of your time into, Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition is one of those games that you MUST play in your lifetime. Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition has to be seen to be believed, and at times it took my breath away.”

-5.9
P

Pramath

219 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

GamingBoltAug 27, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“The price aside, however, there is little to complain about with Elden Ring Tarnished Edition. This is one of the best games of this generation, if not of all time.”

+1.7
Florian Prache

Florian Prache

11 reviews

Latest: Lou's Lagoon

INFINITY AREAAug 27, 2026Score 90

“Lou’s Lagoon is a wonderful surprise: a cozy, colorful, and relaxing adventure that offers plenty of activities without ever putting you under pressure. Beautiful, well-optimized, and enjoyable to explore, it’s a game we highly recommend to fans of exploration and stress-free gaming experiences.”

+11.9
S

Soojin Kim

29 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

INVENAug 27, 2026Score 85

“Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy changes many things while still retaining the series’ distinctive atmosphere and gameplay. At the same time, it works well as an action-adventure game. It puts an original spin on the myth of the Minotaur, while strong visuals and direction make its two intertwined stories engaging from start to finish.”

-0.7
C

Cody Medellin

801 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

Worth PlayingAug 27, 2026Score 85

“Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy is a very good addition to the series, provided you don't mind how much it differs from its predecessors. Exploration is rewarding, particularly with the new grappling hook, while the puzzles remain clever without becoming obtuse. Stealth has been heavily reduced, but the expanded combat more than makes up for it, creating an experience that feels faster and more satisfying. As before, though, the story is the real star. It's exciting and gut-wrenching even when you already know its ultimate outcome. Series fans should find plenty to enjoy, while adventure game fans have another compelling reason to give it a look.”

-1.0
G

Gareth Newnham

114 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

ImpulsegamerAug 27, 2026Score 96Pre-release Review

“A technically proficient port that is easily the best way to touch grace on the go.”

+1.3
M

Matt Sainsbury

1645 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

Digitally DownloadedAug 27, 2026Score 100Pre-release Review

“But also, in acknowledging that the Switch 2 port of Elden Ring isn’t quite up to the standard of the game playing on the PlayStation 5, this review sounds more negative than it should. The differences are a rounding error, and what is important is that this masterpiece runs perfectly well on a very portable console.”

+2.3
Stacie Cotton

Stacie Cotton

38 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

MKAU GamingAug 27, 2026Score 90

“As someone who is a more story-based enthusiast when it comes to gaming, this is one of my favourite games I have played so far in 2026. They really took a risk by diverting from the previous stealth-based gameplay by taking a more action-combative gameplay that really brings out the treasure hunter in the player. The uniquely captivating and exhilarating story, the beautiful and grotesque environments and expertly curated musical pieces collectively make for just such a great experience.”

+3.5
A

Adam Mathew

54 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

PowerUp!Aug 27, 2026Score 80

“Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy doesn’t reinvent the action-adventure genre, and it doesn’t completely preserve the things that made the previous Plague Tale games distinctive. Instead, it takes the series somewhere genuinely new and, for the most part, sticks the landing.”

+5.4
L

Lombardo Gaetano

1 reviews

Latest: Mortal Shell II

Side ProjectAug 27, 2026Score 84

“Cold Symmetry took Mortal Shell and tackled the heavy problems of the first chapter, creating a second entry that hybridizes Dark Souls and Sekiro that genuinely surprised us. Regardless of everything, the bold gameplay and the strong artistic component make it a game not to be underestimated, one genre fans should recover as soon as possible.”

+5.0
Dylan Kocins

Dylan Kocins

36 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

MKAU GamingAug 27, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition is a fantastic new way to play the game. Exceptional performance on the Nintendo Switch 2 means you can play on the go without a hiccup, and with Shadow of the Erdtree included, it’s a great way to play, especially if you have never experienced this masterpiece before.”

+1.1
S

Steve Watts

156 reviews

Latest: Star Wars Zero Company

GameSpotAug 27, 2026Score 80

“Star Wars is a rich playground for games, with loads of differentiated hero and enemy types and powers baked in, and Zero Company takes full advantage of that to make an excellent tactics game in its own right. In doing so, it has made the next great evolution of the genre.”

-1.5
Krist Duro

Krist Duro

99 reviews

Latest: Lou's Lagoon

Duuro MagazineAug 27, 2026Score 75

“Lou's Lagoon knows what makes a cozy crafting game compelling. Gathering with the Swirler feels good, upgrades have a purpose, the islands are fun to explore, and building gives every load of materials somewhere useful to go. The missing-uncle mystery may not linger in my mind, but the pleasure of completing another project does. The tiny inventory is a persistent annoyance, yet it did not spoil a bright, relaxing adventure that I had a genuinely good time playing.”

-0.7
K

Kelvin Richards

5 reviews

Latest: Lou's Lagoon

Analog Stick GamingAug 27, 2026Score 80

“Lou's Lagoon was a fun and engaging crafting adventure that I had a lot of fun playing. Yes, there were a few hiccups here and there. but when dealing with the open sea and a magic storm, nothing will really be smooth flying.”

+7.5
Pascal Kaap

Pascal Kaap

92 reviews

Latest: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

HinsustaAug 26, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy isn't meant to be just a sequel, but rather a standalone action-adventure set in the familiar universe. The shift from helpless tension to aggressive sword-fighting is risky, but it fits Sophia as the protagonist in a way that makes sense. Resonance is a fantastic action-adventure that tells an emotional and compelling story.”

+4.3
Erick Figueiredo

Erick Figueiredo

86 reviews

Latest: Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters

NintendoBoyAug 26, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters is a fun title that successfully captures the anime's action and excitement on the virtual pitch. Gameplay additions make the experience even more strategic, and customizing your own athlete is enjoyable—especially with the introduction of the new position. The narrative is another major highlight, particularly because this marks the first time this specific arc has been adapted for another medium.”

+2.5
Pietro Iacullo

Pietro Iacullo

43 reviews

Latest: Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters

The Games MachineAug 26, 2026Score 80Pre-release Review

“It almost feels like, rather than comparing Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters to an EA FC game, you'd be better off thinking of it as Tekken played 11-a-side. The only thing I'm holding off on judging is the online mode; otherwise, it's genuinely hard not to recommend it to anyone looking to scratch that arcade-style football itch.”

+7.5
N

Nathaniel Stevens

630 reviews

Latest: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition

Digital ChumpsAug 26, 2026Score 85Pre-release Review

“Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition is surprisingly solid on the Nintendo Switch 2. While it won’t match the resolution or frame rate of bigger, more powerful platforms, it still delivers fantastic gameplay with plenty of extra content.”

+7.9
PreviousPage 3 of 509Next