See how publications score against the audience baseline

Track which gaming outlets consistently move with players, which ones diverge, and where review volume might be amplifying a pattern instead of representing consensus.

GamingBolt

2069 reviews | 42 journalists

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

Daniel BoydOct 16, 2026Score 70

“A generous nostalgia trip with some lasting highlights, held back by weaker games, dated visuals and poor audio quality.”

+2.6

Pizza Fria

469 reviews | 16 journalists

Latest: Aion 2

Álvaro Saluan da CunhaOct 16, 2026Score 62

“I see AION 2 as an MMORPG full of hidden quality beneath a series of frustrating decisions.”

+4.9

Loot Level Chill

507 reviews | 11 journalists

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

Lyle PendleOct 16, 2026Score 80

“The old games featured in Toy Story: Retro Roundup! may not be all timers, but this wonderful package showcases them beautifully.”

+2.3

NookGaming

809 reviews | 19 journalists

Latest: Silver Pines

Andrew CamacOct 16, 2026Score 90

“Silver Pines is an excellent addition to the horror genre and a great choice for Halloween 2026. It’s quirky, immersive, terrifying, and thought-provoking. It succeeds where many games with larger budgets fail, earning its place among the best recent survival horror titles. The only horrifying aspect of the game is that it doesn’t have a more distinct identity and chooses to lean a little too strongly on its inspirations. The upside, however, is that it serves as a fantastic gateway drug into the surreal world of David Lynch’s brand of horror. The owls may not be what they seem, but Silver Pines absolutely is: it could be the next great horror game in your collection.”

-6.1

PlayStation Universe

2711 reviews | 75 journalists

Latest: Tales of Eternia Remastered

PlayStation Universe StaffOct 16, 2026Score 80

“Absolutely, fans of the franchise must play Tales of Eternia, especially if they never got a chance to. This remaster includes some great quality of life improvements that help blend the old with the new without tarnishing the original vision. The game's age still comes through in many aspects, but the new additions help pave the way for a new audience to experience a long-sought franchise entry in the Tales of franchise.”

+2.2

Just Play it

226 reviews | 30 journalists

Latest: Tales of Eternia Remastered

Hakim MOKHBIOct 16, 2026Score 80

“Tales of Eternia Remastered brings back one of the most memorable adventures in the Tales of series, with its touching story, enjoyable combat system, and beautiful art direction. Despite some outdated design elements and improvements that don’t cover every aspect of the game, it manages to preserve the charm of the original while delivering a classic experience that is still worth discovering.”

+4.3

Duuro Magazine

111 reviews | 1 journalists

Latest: Odd Town

Krist DuroOct 16, 2026Score 65

“Odd Town is difficult to recommend broadly. Its unusual visuals, charming animations, and strange inhabitants give it an identity I appreciate, and there is fun here once its rules make sense. The onboarding and controller feel make reaching that point harder than it should be. If its particular brand of weirdness appeals to you, you might enjoy the visit. I would understand just as easily if you decided to leave early.”

-1.3

Everyeye.it

1800 reviews | 95 journalists

Latest: Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival

Domenico MusicòOct 15, 2026Score 65

“Hellraiser: Revival is a worthy return, but not a definitive rebirth: it certainly deserves attention for what it attempts to preserve in a landscape where many horror productions tend to homogenize languages and mechanics.”

+3.0

Smash Jump

169 reviews | 25 journalists

Latest: Silver Pines

Dylan ShirleyOct 15, 2026Score 90

“I loved my time with this game and even amongst an impressive crop of horror titles I feel confident that Silver Pines can go toe to toe with the best of them. Silver Pines is well worth a visit.”

-1.5

Switchaboo

20 reviews | 8 journalists

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

Jake MounseyOct 15, 2026Score 60

“While I enjoyed my time with Toy Story: Retro Roundup, I don’t expect this will be for everyone. I see this more as a museum display rather than a game collection and I feel Digital Eclipse feels the same way since that was clearly their intention. If you want to learn a thing or two about the early days of Traveller’s Tales before they became the go-to dev team for Lego games, then I’d suggest picking this up but if you’re more interested in the games on offer, I think you should just pick up an old PS1 copy of Toy Story 2 if you can find one and leave it at that.”

-6.3

TheSixthAxis

3309 reviews | 48 journalists

Latest: The Jackbox Party Pack 12

Jason ColesOct 15, 2026Score 80

“Jackbox Party Pack 12 is a really good party game bundle, and if you've been hoping for some new and genuinely fresh games to drag your mates into, it's definitely going to get the job done. The fact that both Hyperface and Megapals feel actually new is also an accomplishment when we're so many years into the series.”

-2.4

Analog Stick Gaming

295 reviews | 6 journalists

Latest: Frosthaven

Kelvin RichardsOct 15, 2026Score 85

“Frosthaven has been a fun time to play, with no bugs to speak of. The visuals are clean from the simple map you see on the over world, to the isometric battle fields you fight on. You can tell the devs put a lot of time into making the world feel as real as possible. And the sounds are crisp, not to mention that the narration for the events and fights are beautiful.”

+1.5

Video Chums

3822 reviews | 10 journalists

Latest: Order of the Sinking Star

A.J. MaciejewskiOct 15, 2026Score 80

“As a culmination of many puzzle concepts and a deeply rewarding sense of progression, Order of the Sinking Star is a shining star indeed. 🌠”

-3.8

Eternal Games

25 reviews | 13 journalists

Latest: Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup!

أمجد سليم عليOct 15, 2026Score 60

“Toy Story: Retro Roundup is a good collection for fans of the series and classic games, but at the same time, it is a missed opportunity to present these games the way they truly deserve. Despite the improvements and additions included, they remain limited and fail to address the most prominent issues of the original experience, particularly regarding controls and the camera. It would have been better to deliver a proper remake or remaster that develops these aspects and makes the games smoother and more enjoyable, while preserving their original spirit that made them memorable in players' minds.”

-1.6

Press Attack

24 reviews | 3 journalists

Latest: Tenebris Somnia

Bruno de Souza BomOct 15, 2026Score 90Pre-release Review

“Some investigation sequences can interrupt the pacing when we cannot immediately identify which item we need to use or combine. Although most puzzles are intuitive, I found myself stuck at certain points, trying to figure out what the game expected from me and revisiting areas that had nothing to do with the situation at hand. It is also difficult not to question some of the protagonist's decisions, especially given Ivan's disappearance and the lack of answers. Overall, these are minor limitations, accompanied by an additional consideration for those seeking to complete everything: missable achievements require careful attention to save files and campaign progression. These aspects could have been handled better, but they do not compromise the experience. On the other hand, Tenebris Somnia makes excellent use of its investigation mechanics. The ability to collect and combine items, discover new ways to interact with the environments, and tackle specific situations, such as the battle in the dark room, provides enough variety to maintain interest throughout the campaign. The narrative also gains momentum as we descend through the building's floors and learn more about Ivan's memories. Although combat plays a secondary role, boss encounters introduce distinct moments into the progression, while exploration and puzzles sustain most of the experience. The biggest highlight is the integration of gameplay and cinematic sequences. The live-action actors, practical effects, scene direction, and sound design contribute to an atmosphere that also works in the 2D sections, where the game demonstrates its ability to inspire fear without relying on filmed footage. The story, which revolves around a troubled relationship, cults, and disturbing events, gains strength by presenting conflicts that feel tangible. This is a testament to a script that sustains curiosity until the most unsettling moments, even across its multiple endings. Tenebris Somnia is an exceptionally competent production that delivers on its vision, featuring a distinctive visual identity, well-executed investigation mechanics, and a cinematic presentation that makes the experience particularly memorable.”

Neutral Game

22 reviews | 12 journalists

Latest: Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival

Claudio VelazcoOct 15, 2026Score 83

“Hellraiser: Revival doesn’t try to be gentle or light: it wants to leave a mark. Its atmosphere, creature design and the Genesis Configuration box make for a brutal, unsettling slasher horror ride that could become a cult favorite, even if the combat can feel unfair at times.”

+1.9

GameSpew

3052 reviews | 53 journalists

Latest: Warhammer 40,000: Boltgun 2

GameSpew StaffOct 15, 2026Score 80

“Its old-school formula can mean it feels a little repetitive at times, but Warhammer 40,000: Boltgun 2 is a sequel that's undoubtedly bigger and better, with more replayability thanks to its two playable characters and branching paths in its campaign.”

-1.9

DualShockers

1774 reviews | 126 journalists

Latest: The Jackbox Party Pack 12

Jake ValentineOct 15, 2026Score 90

“Despite one of the games being a complete dud, Jackbox Party Pack 12 proves that the team still has it, especially as they're working on other projects.”

+2.3

DarkZero

757 reviews | 30 journalists

Latest: Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival

Daniel CairnsOct 15, 2026Score 80

“Right, I'm quite impressed I've got through this review without any quotes or references from the films, so I guess I'll cram them into the conclusion.”

-4.5

Prima Games

320 reviews | 33 journalists

Latest: Tenebris Somnia

Kyle FerreiraOct 15, 2026Score 95Pre-release Review

“In my humble opinion, Tenebris Somnia is a masterpiece. It won't be everyone's cup of tea, but anyone who enjoys a strong, dark story and doesn't mind a bit of horror will feel right at home. It may not be the most technically brilliant game, but it's certainly the most memorable game I've played all year.”

+5.7