ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
AboutFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Track critic scores against the player curve

Browse release-by-release disagreement between professional reviews and player response, then sort by recency, disparity, or title to find where the biggest score gaps live.

The Trolley Solution

The Trolley Solution

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
-7.3

Latest Review

Will "FncWill" Hogeweide at Rectify Gaming

Sep 21, 2025 | Score 70

“It’s not exactly philosophy with horsepower, but it’s got enough steam to keep you entertained. Choo-choo-se this one if you like bad train puns, quick minigames, and watching thought experiments get crushed under steel wheels.”

Critics
70
Steam
77
Metacritic
—
The Trolley Solution

The Trolley Solution

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Will "FncWill" Hogeweide at Rectify Gaming

Sep 21, 2025 | Score 70

“It’s not exactly philosophy with horsepower, but it’s got enough steam to keep you entertained. Choo-choo-se this one if you like bad train puns, quick minigames, and watching thought experiments get crushed under steel wheels.”

-7.3
Critics
70
Steam
77
Metacritic
—
D

Donkey Kong Bananza: DK Island & Emerald Rush

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
+18.2

Latest Review

Roberto Moran at NextPlay

Jan 15, 2026 | Score 65

“Donkey Kong Bananza: DK Island & Emerald Rush is a beautiful and nostalgic piece of DLC, but one with fun that is short-lived and offers little depth to the 10/10 masterpiece that is the base game. Only the biggest of Bananza fans will find their money’s worth in this inessential experience.”

Critics
69
Steam
—
Metacritic
51
D

Donkey Kong Bananza: DK Island & Emerald Rush

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Roberto Moran at NextPlay

Jan 15, 2026 | Score 65

“Donkey Kong Bananza: DK Island & Emerald Rush is a beautiful and nostalgic piece of DLC, but one with fun that is short-lived and offers little depth to the 10/10 masterpiece that is the base game. Only the biggest of Bananza fans will find their money’s worth in this inessential experience.”

Storm Lancers

Storm Lancers

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
N/A

Latest Review

Lyle Pendle at Loot Level Chill

Dec 22, 2025 | Score 65

“There's not a whole lot wrong with Storm Lancers, but it really struggles to hang with its peers thanks to a lack of randomness and just okay combat.”

Critics
66
Steam
69
Metacritic
—
Storm Lancers

Storm Lancers

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Lyle Pendle at Loot Level Chill

Dec 22, 2025 | Score 65

“There's not a whole lot wrong with Storm Lancers, but it really struggles to hang with its peers thanks to a lack of randomness and just okay combat.”

Sips and Sonnets

Sips and Sonnets

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
-13.8

Latest Review

Zahra Ymer at Qualbert.com

Sep 13, 2025 | Score 80

“Ultimately, Sips and Sonnets is less about mechanics than mood. It asks players to slow down, to serve tea not just as a transaction but as a gesture of care, and to write poetry not for competition but for connection. It offers a gentle reminder that storytelling can be intimate and local, that games can find profundity in the everyday. If its final release matches the promise of its demo and previews, Sips and Sonnets may well become a small but memorable entry in the canon of cozy visual novels, a game best enjoyed with a warm cup of tea in hand. A quiet narrative that is the antidote to over-stimulation.”

Critics
86
Steam
100
Metacritic
—
Sips and Sonnets

Sips and Sonnets

Gloomy Eyes

Gloomy Eyes

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
-17.3

Latest Review

Matúš Štrba at SECTOR.sk

Dec 9, 2025 | Score 70

“Gloomy Eyes is a visually striking and atmospheric game featuring two cooperating characters and clever puzzles. Its story of outsiders finding their place in the world is charming and emotionally engaging, enhanced by Tim Burton'inspired design and music. However, technical issues and frequent bugs disrupt the experience, especially given the game's short length.”

Critics
78
Steam
95
Metacritic
—
Gloomy Eyes

Gloomy Eyes

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Matúš Štrba at SECTOR.sk

Dec 9, 2025 | Score 70

“Gloomy Eyes is a visually striking and atmospheric game featuring two cooperating characters and clever puzzles. Its story of outsiders finding their place in the world is charming and emotionally engaging, enhanced by Tim Burton'inspired design and music. However, technical issues and frequent bugs disrupt the experience, especially given the game's short length.”

The Devil is in the Details

The Devil is in the Details

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
-21.9

Latest Review

Travis Bruno at Capsule Computers

Oct 16, 2025 | Score 80

“The Devil is in the Details blends eerie design with anomaly spotting and hidden puzzles, offering freedom of play and tons of scares and variety for replay, though not every trick lands.”

Critics
77
Steam
99
Metacritic
—
The Devil is in the Details

The Devil is in the Details

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Travis Bruno at Capsule Computers

Oct 16, 2025 | Score 80

“The Devil is in the Details blends eerie design with anomaly spotting and hidden puzzles, offering freedom of play and tons of scares and variety for replay, though not every trick lands.”

Dinotica

Dinotica

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
-8.5

Latest Review

Blake Wilcox at Screen Hype

Aug 20, 2025 | Score 78 | Pre-release Review

“Dinotica splits your time between two distinct environments: your home base and the outer world of Dinotica. Your home base acts as a hub for crafting, resource management, and preparing for adventures, while Dinotica is where the actual exploration happens. A land filled with dinosaurs, enemies, mysteries and loot. There’s a good balance between building and maintaining your base and venturing into the unknown. ...the downside is that the system is a little too basic. Crafting often comes down to just gathering the right number of raw materials – need fibre? Collect x amount and you’re set. While functional, it feels like the game could have benefited from an extra layer of resource management or complexity. Like requiring players to spin fibre into rope or string before using it for some recipes. It’s enjoyable for what it is, but players who love deep crafting systems may find it a bit barebones.”

Critics
78
Steam
86
Metacritic
—
Dinotica
N

NHL 26

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
+44.3

Latest Review

Marcel Dee at A Gaming Network

Nov 9, 2025 | Score 80

“With ICE-Q 2.0 at its core, NHL 26 delivers smarter AI, more authentic skating, and a Be A Pro mode that finally feels meaningful. While a few visual shortcomings remain, the combination of realism, depth, and pure hockey excitement makes this one of the best entries in the series’ modern era.”

Critics
74
Steam
—
Metacritic
30
N

NHL 26

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Marcel Dee at A Gaming Network

Nov 9, 2025 | Score 80

“With ICE-Q 2.0 at its core, NHL 26 delivers smarter AI, more authentic skating, and a Be A Pro mode that finally feels meaningful. While a few visual shortcomings remain, the combination of realism, depth, and pure hockey excitement makes this one of the best entries in the series’ modern era.”

Borderlands 4

Borderlands 4

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025
+28.8

Latest Review

Britt Roberts at Games Freezer

Dec 10, 2025 | Score 80

“All in all, if you are a fan of the basics of the series, this is very much more of the same with a few tweaks. The music may click with a lot of folks, and perhaps there are some that will relish the sheer amount of items and loadouts that you can wangle, but whilst there are thousand of weapons and a huge open world to explore, I can’t help but feel that this is quantity over quality in some areas.”

Critics
82
Steam
59
Metacritic
47
Borderlands 4

Borderlands 4

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Britt Roberts at Games Freezer

Dec 10, 2025 | Score 80

Bananitro

Bananitro

Release Date: Sep 11, 2025
-30.0

Latest Review

Darren Edwards at TheXboxHub

Sep 30, 2025 | Score 70

“There's a lot to like about Bananitro and it would be good to see more in the future. The components are all there, but the execution falters at times, resulting in an experience which regularly swings from being good fun, to feeling like a chore.”

Critics
70
Steam
100
Metacritic
—
Bananitro

Bananitro

Release Date: Sep 11, 2025

Latest review: Darren Edwards at TheXboxHub

Sep 30, 2025 | Score 70

“There's a lot to like about Bananitro and it would be good to see more in the future. The components are all there, but the execution falters at times, resulting in an experience which regularly swings from being good fun, to feeling like a chore.”

Dead Reset

Dead Reset

Release Date: Sep 11, 2025
-13.6

Latest Review

GameMAG Staff at GameMAG

Oct 16, 2025 | Score 70

“The initial concept of Dead Reset envisioned a choice system with far-reaching and partially irreversible consequences, even after «resetting». In practice, the game turns out to be an overly linear FMV adventure, the outcome of which feels predetermined.”

Critics
70
Steam
88
Metacritic
79
Dead Reset

Dead Reset

Release Date: Sep 11, 2025

Latest review: GameMAG Staff at GameMAG

Oct 16, 2025 | Score 70

“The initial concept of Dead Reset envisioned a choice system with far-reaching and partially irreversible consequences, even after «resetting». In practice, the game turns out to be an overly linear FMV adventure, the outcome of which feels predetermined.”

Baki Hanma: Blood Arena

Baki Hanma: Blood Arena

Release Date: Sep 11, 2025
-16.2

Latest Review

PS4Blog.net Staff at PS4Blog.net

Dec 17, 2025 | Score 80

“A fun Punch-Out!! take on the Baki Hanma anime”

Critics
60
Steam
76
Metacritic
—
Baki Hanma: Blood Arena

Baki Hanma: Blood Arena

Release Date: Sep 11, 2025

Latest review: PS4Blog.net Staff at PS4Blog.net

Dec 17, 2025 | Score 80

“A fun Punch-Out!! take on the Baki Hanma anime”

-16.2
Machick 2

Machick 2

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025
-7.3

Latest Review

Ryadh Rezig at Just Play it

Dec 3, 2025 | Score 85

“Machick 2 doesn’t reinvent the Bullet Heaven genre, but it adds its own charm—whether through weapon customization, humor, or diverse content. It’s a fun, light-hearted experience that isn’t shallow, and if you enjoy this type of game, you’ll have a great time and challenge yourself for hours.”

Critics
83
Steam
90
Metacritic
—
Machick 2

Machick 2

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025

Latest review: Ryadh Rezig at Just Play it

Dec 3, 2025 | Score 85

“Machick 2 doesn’t reinvent the Bullet Heaven genre, but it adds its own charm—whether through weapon customization, humor, or diverse content. It’s a fun, light-hearted experience that isn’t shallow, and if you enjoy this type of game, you’ll have a great time and challenge yourself for hours.”

Shape of Dreams

Shape of Dreams

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025
-8.2

Latest Review

Softpedia Staff at Softpedia

Oct 29, 2025 | Score 90

“Sure, it can get rather hectic at times, but that’s the nature of the beast, after all. Yes, it can take a bit to learn all of its elements and figure out how to create an excellent build. But once you do, you’ll become unstoppable, as you rush through enemies. Shape of Dreams feels very satisfying to play, there’s never a dull moment, and you’ll always feel the itch for one more run.”

Critics
82
Steam
90
Metacritic
—
Shape of Dreams

Shape of Dreams

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025

Latest review: Softpedia Staff at Softpedia

Katanaut

Katanaut

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025
-14.0

Latest Review

Mick Fraser at Loot Level Chill

Oct 10, 2025 | Score 70

“Katanaut is fast-paced, good-looking, and pretty fun despite its overall sci-fi horror tone.”

Critics
76
Steam
90
Metacritic
—
Katanaut

Katanaut

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025

Latest review: Mick Fraser at Loot Level Chill

Oct 10, 2025 | Score 70

“Katanaut is fast-paced, good-looking, and pretty fun despite its overall sci-fi horror tone.”

-14.0
Garfield Kart 2: All You Can Drift

Garfield Kart 2: All You Can Drift

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025
+19.3

Latest Review

Győző Baki at DayOne

Sep 13, 2025 | Score 65

“Garfield Kart 2 is a fun kart racer, in some ways better than its predecessor – but everything it does better is because it shamelessly copied another, much better game. With so many quality mascot kart racers out there, you can probably opt for something a little more remarkable.”

Critics
65
Steam
46
Metacritic
—
Garfield Kart 2: All You Can Drift

Garfield Kart 2: All You Can Drift

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025

Latest review: Győző Baki at DayOne

Sep 13, 2025 | Score 65

The Search

The Search

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025
-10.3

Latest Review

Olly Smith at GameGrin

Oct 4, 2017 | Score 45 | Pre-release Review

“For an hour-long experience, the main thing I took away from The Search were cheap puzzle mechanics and quotes by American lecturer Joseph Campbell. If the game's main themes were not as openly sermonising, then I could see the narrative being less tedious and players would get more out of it. But sadly, the extent of the story would have been much better suited as an essay, short film, or poem.”

Critics
63
Steam
73
Metacritic
—
The Search

The Search

Release Date: Sep 10, 2025

Latest review: Olly Smith at GameGrin

Oct 4, 2017 | Score 45 | Pre-release Review

Road to Empress

Road to Empress

Release Date: Sep 9, 2025
-17.8

Latest Review

Adiba Manha at GamesCreed

Feb 4, 2026 | Score 60

“Road to Empress I is a well-made FMV game that knows exactly what it wants to be. It’s a palace drama with betrayal, ambition, and perpetual danger that comes to life through great acting and high production qualities. The option structure can sometimes feel limiting and unjust, but the story is still interesting enough to keep you going, even when you die a lot.”

Critics
70
Steam
87
Metacritic
89
Road to Empress

Road to Empress

Release Date: Sep 9, 2025

Latest review: Adiba Manha at GamesCreed

Feb 4, 2026 | Score 60

Dragon Ball Gekishin Squadra

Dragon Ball Gekishin Squadra

Release Date: Sep 9, 2025
+16.9

Latest Review

Spaziogames Staff at Spaziogames

Oct 9, 2025 | Score 83

“Dragon Ball Gekishin Squadra is Bandai Namco's answer to the stagnation of the MOBA genre, a title that forgoes the extreme complexity typical of League of Legends and Dota 2 in favor of a more immediate, dynamic, and accessible approach.”

Critics
81
Steam
65
Metacritic
62
Dragon Ball Gekishin Squadra

Dragon Ball Gekishin Squadra

Release Date: Sep 9, 2025

Latest review: Spaziogames Staff at Spaziogames

Oct 9, 2025 | Score 83

“Dragon Ball Gekishin Squadra is Bandai Namco's answer to the stagnation of the MOBA genre, a title that forgoes the extreme complexity typical of League of Legends and Dota 2 in favor of a more immediate, dynamic, and accessible approach.”

Little Problems: A Cozy Detective Game

Little Problems: A Cozy Detective Game

Release Date: Sep 9, 2025
-9.9

Latest Review

Vladimír Rusnák at SomHráč.sk

Sep 21, 2025 | Score 80

“Little Problems: A Cozy Detective Game is a charming little detective adventure where even ordinary events from your life may be worth a deeper investigation.”

Critics
81
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
Little Problems: A Cozy Detective Game

Little Problems: A Cozy Detective Game

Release Date: Sep 9, 2025

Latest review: Vladimír Rusnák at SomHráč.sk

Sep 21, 2025 | Score 80

“Little Problems: A Cozy Detective Game is a charming little detective adventure where even ordinary events from your life may be worth a deeper investigation.”

PreviousPage 54 of 739Next
+18.2
Critics
69
Steam
—
Metacritic
51
N/A
Critics
66
Steam
69
Metacritic
—
Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Zahra Ymer at Qualbert.com

Sep 13, 2025 | Score 80

“Ultimately, Sips and Sonnets is less about mechanics than mood. It asks players to slow down, to serve tea not just as a transaction but as a gesture of care, and to write poetry not for competition but for connection. It offers a gentle reminder that storytelling can be intimate and local, that games can find profundity in the everyday. If its final release matches the promise of its demo and previews, Sips and Sonnets may well become a small but memorable entry in the canon of cozy visual novels, a game best enjoyed with a warm cup of tea in hand. A quiet narrative that is the antidote to over-stimulation.”

-13.8
Critics
86
Steam
100
Metacritic
—
-17.3
Critics
78
Steam
95
Metacritic
—
-21.9
Critics
77
Steam
99
Metacritic
—

Dinotica

Release Date: Sep 12, 2025

Latest review: Blake Wilcox at Screen Hype

Aug 20, 2025 | Score 78 | Pre-release Review

“Dinotica splits your time between two distinct environments: your home base and the outer world of Dinotica. Your home base acts as a hub for crafting, resource management, and preparing for adventures, while Dinotica is where the actual exploration happens. A land filled with dinosaurs, enemies, mysteries and loot. There’s a good balance between building and maintaining your base and venturing into the unknown. ...the downside is that the system is a little too basic. Crafting often comes down to just gathering the right number of raw materials – need fibre? Collect x amount and you’re set. While functional, it feels like the game could have benefited from an extra layer of resource management or complexity. Like requiring players to spin fibre into rope or string before using it for some recipes. It’s enjoyable for what it is, but players who love deep crafting systems may find it a bit barebones.”

-8.5
Critics
78
Steam
86
Metacritic
—
+44.3
Critics
74
Steam
—
Metacritic
30

“All in all, if you are a fan of the basics of the series, this is very much more of the same with a few tweaks. The music may click with a lot of folks, and perhaps there are some that will relish the sheer amount of items and loadouts that you can wangle, but whilst there are thousand of weapons and a huge open world to explore, I can’t help but feel that this is quantity over quality in some areas.”

+28.8
Critics
82
Steam
59
Metacritic
47
-30.0
Critics
70
Steam
100
Metacritic
—
-13.6
Critics
70
Steam
88
Metacritic
79
Critics
60
Steam
76
Metacritic
—
-7.3
Critics
83
Steam
90
Metacritic
—

Oct 29, 2025 | Score 90

“Sure, it can get rather hectic at times, but that’s the nature of the beast, after all. Yes, it can take a bit to learn all of its elements and figure out how to create an excellent build. But once you do, you’ll become unstoppable, as you rush through enemies. Shape of Dreams feels very satisfying to play, there’s never a dull moment, and you’ll always feel the itch for one more run.”

-8.2
Critics
82
Steam
90
Metacritic
—
Critics
76
Steam
90
Metacritic
—

“Garfield Kart 2 is a fun kart racer, in some ways better than its predecessor – but everything it does better is because it shamelessly copied another, much better game. With so many quality mascot kart racers out there, you can probably opt for something a little more remarkable.”

+19.3
Critics
65
Steam
46
Metacritic
—

“For an hour-long experience, the main thing I took away from The Search were cheap puzzle mechanics and quotes by American lecturer Joseph Campbell. If the game's main themes were not as openly sermonising, then I could see the narrative being less tedious and players would get more out of it. But sadly, the extent of the story would have been much better suited as an essay, short film, or poem.”

-10.3
Critics
63
Steam
73
Metacritic
—

“Road to Empress I is a well-made FMV game that knows exactly what it wants to be. It’s a palace drama with betrayal, ambition, and perpetual danger that comes to life through great acting and high production qualities. The option structure can sometimes feel limiting and unjust, but the story is still interesting enough to keep you going, even when you die a lot.”

-17.8
Critics
70
Steam
87
Metacritic
89
+16.9
Critics
81
Steam
65
Metacritic
62
-9.9
Critics
81
Steam
91
Metacritic
—