ReviewDisparity Logo
ReviewDisparity

Critics, outlets, and games against player sentiment

HomeNewsGamesJournalistsOutletsLeaderboardsCompareAbout
Review Signal

Keep the data honest.

ReviewDisparity tracks how critics, outlets, and games compare with player opinion across Steam and Metacritic. The goal is simple: make disagreement visible instead of burying it in scattered scorecards.

Explore
Browse gamesBrowse journalistsBrowse outletsCompare entities
Site
AboutFAQTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 ReviewDisparity. Independent review disparity tracking.

Data sourced from publicly available information on OpenCritic, Steam, and Metacritic. ReviewDisparity is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of those services.

Track critic scores against the player curve

Browse release-by-release disagreement between professional reviews and player response, then sort by recency, disparity, or title to find where the biggest score gaps live.

The Midnight Walk

The Midnight Walk

Release Date: May 8, 2025
-7.3

Latest Review

The A.V. Club Staff at The A.V. Club

Dec 15, 2025 | Score 85

“Incredible visual presentation, an arresting atmosphere, and a charming travel partner make it worth taking a trip down The Midnight Walk.”

Critics
81
Steam
93
Metacritic
83
The Midnight Walk

The Midnight Walk

Release Date: May 8, 2025

Latest review: The A.V. Club Staff at The A.V. Club

Dec 15, 2025 | Score 85

“Incredible visual presentation, an arresting atmosphere, and a charming travel partner make it worth taking a trip down The Midnight Walk.”

-7.3
Critics
81
Steam
93
Metacritic
83
AFL 26

AFL 26

Release Date: May 7, 2025
+16.4

Latest Review

Impulsegamer Staff at Impulsegamer

May 29, 2025 | Score 69

“AFL 26 is a commendable iteration that refines its predecessors' foundation while introducing meaningful improvements. The enhanced marking system, deeper tactical options and more challenging goalkicking contribute to a more engaging experience, despite the persistence of some long-standing issues. While the PlayStation 5 version is fast for load times and performance, it doesn't represent a groundbreaking leap forward for next-gen hardware. Nevertheless, AFL 26 is a significant step in the right direction for Australian Rules Football gaming and fans of the sport will undoubtedly appreciate the considerable effort put into this title.”

Critics
74
Steam
57
Metacritic
—
AFL 26

AFL 26

Deck of Haunts

Deck of Haunts

Release Date: May 7, 2025
-12.2

Latest Review

Nathan Carter at Gaming Nexus

Jun 17, 2025 | Score 75

“Deck of Haunts is a quick and fun deck-building roguelike. Building out the haunted house is the most fun part. Just know that this is also one of those games where you will be at the mercy of the RNG, where failing to get a specific card you need to save your run may lead to your demise.”

Critics
74
Steam
86
Metacritic
—
Deck of Haunts

Deck of Haunts

Release Date: May 7, 2025

Latest review: Nathan Carter at Gaming Nexus

Jun 17, 2025 | Score 75

“Deck of Haunts is a quick and fun deck-building roguelike. Building out the haunted house is the most fun part. Just know that this is also one of those games where you will be at the mercy of the RNG, where failing to get a specific card you need to save your run may lead to your demise.”

T

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom Nintendo Switch 2 Edition

Release Date: May 6, 2025
+10.6

Latest Review

Saras Rajpal at Final Weapon

Dec 31, 2025 | Score 100

“The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom is a truly generational game. It improves on all aspects of its predecessor, Breath of the Wild. The narrative balances various tones and progresses the character arcs of its major protagonists, while introducing new and compelling NPCs. Further, the gameplay only enhances one of gaming's greatest sandboxes with a new fantastic line of abilities, activities, dungeons, and boss fights. Everything about Tears of the Kingdom is perfect, and as far as I'm concerned, it's one of the best games I've ever played in my entire life.”

Critics
95
Steam
—
Metacritic
84
T

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom Nintendo Switch 2 Edition

Release Date: May 6, 2025
Captain Blood

Captain Blood

Release Date: May 6, 2025
-25.2

Latest Review

Isabella Alves at PSX Brasil

Jul 6, 2025 | Score 55

“Captain Blood tries to recapture the charm of the PS2's golden era, but unfortunately ends up being a rather mediocre title that misses where it should have hit the mark. There's some merit to its release, partly due to its troubled development, but if you're hoping to find a game that emanates the same energy and does justice to that era, Captain Blood is far from it.”

Critics
53
Steam
79
Metacritic
—
Captain Blood

Captain Blood

Release Date: May 6, 2025

Latest review: Isabella Alves at PSX Brasil

Jul 6, 2025 | Score 55

“Captain Blood tries to recapture the charm of the PS2's golden era, but unfortunately ends up being a rather mediocre title that misses where it should have hit the mark. There's some merit to its release, partly due to its troubled development, but if you're hoping to find a game that emanates the same energy and does justice to that era, Captain Blood is far from it.”

Among Us 3D

Among Us 3D

Release Date: May 6, 2025
-16.1

Latest Review

Uriel Rodriguez at Game8

May 14, 2025 | Score 62

“Among Us 3D wears the mask of its 2D predecessor, stepping into first-person with big ambitions. There’s still chaos and charm beneath the surface, but clunky mechanics and odd design choices ruin the overall experience. In the end, it’s more impostor than upgrade—you’re better off sticking with the classic.”

Critics
56
Steam
72
Metacritic
—
Among Us 3D

Among Us 3D

Release Date: May 6, 2025

Latest review: Uriel Rodriguez at Game8

May 14, 2025 | Score 62

“Among Us 3D wears the mask of its 2D predecessor, stepping into first-person with big ambitions. There’s still chaos and charm beneath the surface, but clunky mechanics and odd design choices ruin the overall experience. In the end, it’s more impostor than upgrade—you’re better off sticking with the classic.”

Metal Eden

Metal Eden

Release Date: May 6, 2025
-2.6

Latest Review

AJ Small at Xbox Tavern

Oct 14, 2025 | Score 83

“Metal Eden is a great first-person shooter with tons of great moments. A must buy for those that like a lot of cyber-punk themed violence.”

Critics
76
Steam
85
Metacritic
73
Metal Eden

Metal Eden

Release Date: May 6, 2025

Latest review: AJ Small at Xbox Tavern

Oct 14, 2025 | Score 83

“Metal Eden is a great first-person shooter with tons of great moments. A must buy for those that like a lot of cyber-punk themed violence.”

Best Served Cold

Best Served Cold

Release Date: May 5, 2025
-6.0

Latest Review

PS3Blog.net Staff at PS3Blog.net

Aug 1, 2025 | Score 85

“Solid murder mystery adventure set in a lively speakeasy in an alternate history Europe”

Critics
82
Steam
88
Metacritic
—
Best Served Cold

Best Served Cold

Release Date: May 5, 2025

Latest review: PS3Blog.net Staff at PS3Blog.net

Aug 1, 2025 | Score 85

“Solid murder mystery adventure set in a lively speakeasy in an alternate history Europe”

Drop Duchy

Drop Duchy

Release Date: May 5, 2025
-5.5

Latest Review

A.J. Maciejewski at Video Chums

Jan 29, 2026 | Score 80

“There are so many puzzle and strategy elements in Drop Duchy - Complete Edition yet it ties them all together into one super-fun formula. 🏹”

Critics
84
Steam
90
Metacritic
—
Drop Duchy

Drop Duchy

Release Date: May 5, 2025

Latest review: A.J. Maciejewski at Video Chums

Jan 29, 2026 | Score 80

“There are so many puzzle and strategy elements in Drop Duchy - Complete Edition yet it ties them all together into one super-fun formula. 🏹”

Two Falls: Nishu Takuatshina

Two Falls: Nishu Takuatshina

Release Date: May 3, 2025
-16.2

Latest Review

Antonio Russo at STWGames Italia

Jan 2, 2026 | Score 75

“Two Falls (Nishu Takuatshina) is not a video game for everyone, nor does it want to be. It is an experience that requires patience and a willingness to be transported to an era of cultural and spiritual clashes. This development studio's debut offers an honest and never banal look at colonial history and the roots of the Innu people. Despite some technical uncertainties, the title manages to impress with its enchanting atmosphere and profound message.”

Critics
75
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
Two Falls: Nishu Takuatshina

Two Falls: Nishu Takuatshina

Release Date: May 3, 2025

Latest review: Antonio Russo at STWGames Italia

Duet

Duet

Release Date: May 2, 2025
-14.8

Latest Review

Tommy Daniels at DarkZero

May 26, 2016 | Score 90 | Pre-release Review

“For better or worse we live in a world where endless arcade games are a hot commodity and a vice even the most casual gamer has indulged in for hours more than expected.”

Critics
80
Steam
95
Metacritic
—
Duet

Duet

Release Date: May 2, 2025

Latest review: Tommy Daniels at DarkZero

May 26, 2016 | Score 90 | Pre-release Review

“For better or worse we live in a world where endless arcade games are a hot commodity and a vice even the most casual gamer has indulged in for hours more than expected.”

Sub-Verge

Sub-Verge

Release Date: May 1, 2025
-3.2

Latest Review

Chiara Roscini at Indie Games Devel

Aug 11, 2025 | Score 75

“Sub-Verge speaks to a precise audience: players who enjoy interactive storytelling, moral dilemmas, and narratives unafraid of dark outcomes. It demands patience, attention to detail, and a willingness to move forward through words rather than constant action. For others, it might feel more like an illustrated tale than a “traditional” game. But for those drawn to experiences blending psychology, science fiction, and underwater tension, Sub-Verge offers a short yet intense dive — with a final sequence that will hold your breath for you. And not just because of the oxygen. Recommended for anyone ready to immerse themselves in a tense, atmospheric tale where survival depends on the trust you earn.”

Critics
68
Steam
71
Metacritic
—
Sub-Verge

Sub-Verge

Skating Rink Story

Skating Rink Story

Release Date: May 1, 2025
-15.3

Latest Review

Lynne Newey at LadiesGamers.com

May 12, 2025 | Score 80

“Skating Rink Story is one of the more chilled Kairosoft games. With the on-screen help and structured requests, Skating Rink Story is a great introduction to this type of management simulation game.”

Critics
80
Steam
95
Metacritic
—
Skating Rink Story

Skating Rink Story

Release Date: May 1, 2025

Latest review: Lynne Newey at LadiesGamers.com

May 12, 2025 | Score 80

“Skating Rink Story is one of the more chilled Kairosoft games. With the on-screen help and structured requests, Skating Rink Story is a great introduction to this type of management simulation game.”

Freeride

Freeride

Release Date: May 1, 2025
-7.7

Latest Review

Kurosh Jozavi at So Many Games

May 16, 2025 | Score 60

“FREERIDE is a heartfelt and imaginative journey that prioritises emotion and introspection over traditional gameplay. Its dreamlike world and memorable characters leave a lasting impression, even when clunky mechanics momentarily break the spell.”

Critics
80
Steam
88
Metacritic
—
Freeride

Freeride

Release Date: May 1, 2025

Latest review: Kurosh Jozavi at So Many Games

May 16, 2025 | Score 60

“FREERIDE is a heartfelt and imaginative journey that prioritises emotion and introspection over traditional gameplay. Its dreamlike world and memorable characters leave a lasting impression, even when clunky mechanics momentarily break the spell.”

The Horror at Highrook

The Horror at Highrook

Release Date: May 1, 2025
-9.1

Latest Review

Greg Giddens at Cubed3

Jun 14, 2025 | Score 80

“With an intriguing story, classic horror and mystery tropes that align with the style and concepts behind its inspiration, in particular HP Lovecraft, The Horror at Highrook is a compelling and enjoyable investigation digital board game. It is not always obvious how to proceed, but a little determination proves rewarding and entertaining as you uncover the truth behind the cast of characters and the mansion they are investigating. It is a one-shot experience, though, so don’t let the board game aesthetic fool you.”

Critics
81
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
The Horror at Highrook

The Horror at Highrook

Release Date: May 1, 2025
Shotgun Cop Man

Shotgun Cop Man

Release Date: May 1, 2025
-17.4

Latest Review

PS3Blog.net Staff at PS3Blog.net

Jul 2, 2025 | Score 80

“It's time to get rid of Satan once and for all!”

Critics
79
Steam
97
Metacritic
—
Shotgun Cop Man

Shotgun Cop Man

Release Date: May 1, 2025

Latest review: PS3Blog.net Staff at PS3Blog.net

Jul 2, 2025 | Score 80

“It's time to get rid of Satan once and for all!”

-17.4
Critics
79
Steam
97
Metacritic
—
Despelote

Despelote

Release Date: May 1, 2025
+2.1

Latest Review

Robby Bisschop at Life is Xbox

Jan 16, 2026 | Score 77

“Despelote is a unique documentary around Ecuador and the country’s newfound obsession with soccer in the early 2000s, but it sometimes misses the goal of being an entertaining game. Definitely worth playing, but more so as education than entertainment.”

Critics
80
Steam
95
Metacritic
62
Despelote

Despelote

Release Date: May 1, 2025

Latest review: Robby Bisschop at Life is Xbox

Jan 16, 2026 | Score 77

“Despelote is a unique documentary around Ecuador and the country’s newfound obsession with soccer in the early 2000s, but it sometimes misses the goal of being an entertaining game. Definitely worth playing, but more so as education than entertainment.”

Back:Fade

Back:Fade

Release Date: Apr 30, 2025
-11.6

Latest Review

Zachary Holmes at TheBigBois

May 18, 2025 | Score 70

“Back: Fade is a hot mess—and it’s all the better for it. Equal parts terrifying and ridiculous, it’s a trashy horror gem that fans of FMV, cult cinema, and experimental storytelling will love. It’s not for everyone. But if your idea of a good time includes haunted birthday parties, possessed teddy bears, and dialogue so strange it could summon demons, Back: Fade is the experience you didn’t know you needed.”

Critics
70
Steam
82
Metacritic
—
Back:Fade

Back:Fade

Release Date: Apr 30, 2025

Latest review: Zachary Holmes at TheBigBois

May 18, 2025 | Score 70

Haunted House Renovator

Haunted House Renovator

Release Date: Apr 30, 2025
+4.0

Latest Review

Terrence Johnson at ZTGD

Jan 29, 2026 | Score 60

“Quote not yet available”

Critics
52
Steam
48
Metacritic
—
Haunted House Renovator

Haunted House Renovator

Release Date: Apr 30, 2025

Latest review: Terrence Johnson at ZTGD

Jan 29, 2026 | Score 60

“Quote not yet available”

+4.0
Critics
52
Steam
48
Metacritic
—
MEMORIAPOLIS

MEMORIAPOLIS

Release Date: Apr 30, 2025
-16.4

Latest Review

Joshua Render at GameGrin

May 31, 2025 | Score 60

“MEMORIAPOLIS is great if you're looking for a game about numbers rising that will, eventually, get more interesting. If not, then maybe stick with one of the Civilization games.”

Critics
60
Steam
76
Metacritic
—
MEMORIAPOLIS

MEMORIAPOLIS

Release Date: Apr 30, 2025

Latest review: Joshua Render at GameGrin

May 31, 2025 | Score 60

“MEMORIAPOLIS is great if you're looking for a game about numbers rising that will, eventually, get more interesting. If not, then maybe stick with one of the Civilization games.”

PreviousPage 80 of 740Next
Release Date: May 7, 2025

Latest review: Impulsegamer Staff at Impulsegamer

May 29, 2025 | Score 69

“AFL 26 is a commendable iteration that refines its predecessors' foundation while introducing meaningful improvements. The enhanced marking system, deeper tactical options and more challenging goalkicking contribute to a more engaging experience, despite the persistence of some long-standing issues. While the PlayStation 5 version is fast for load times and performance, it doesn't represent a groundbreaking leap forward for next-gen hardware. Nevertheless, AFL 26 is a significant step in the right direction for Australian Rules Football gaming and fans of the sport will undoubtedly appreciate the considerable effort put into this title.”

+16.4
Critics
74
Steam
57
Metacritic
—
-12.2
Critics
74
Steam
86
Metacritic
—

Latest review: Saras Rajpal at Final Weapon

Dec 31, 2025 | Score 100

“The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom is a truly generational game. It improves on all aspects of its predecessor, Breath of the Wild. The narrative balances various tones and progresses the character arcs of its major protagonists, while introducing new and compelling NPCs. Further, the gameplay only enhances one of gaming's greatest sandboxes with a new fantastic line of abilities, activities, dungeons, and boss fights. Everything about Tears of the Kingdom is perfect, and as far as I'm concerned, it's one of the best games I've ever played in my entire life.”

+10.6
Critics
95
Steam
—
Metacritic
84
-25.2
Critics
53
Steam
79
Metacritic
—
-16.1
Critics
56
Steam
72
Metacritic
—
-2.6
Critics
76
Steam
85
Metacritic
73
-6.0
Critics
82
Steam
88
Metacritic
—
-5.5
Critics
84
Steam
90
Metacritic
—

Jan 2, 2026 | Score 75

“Two Falls (Nishu Takuatshina) is not a video game for everyone, nor does it want to be. It is an experience that requires patience and a willingness to be transported to an era of cultural and spiritual clashes. This development studio's debut offers an honest and never banal look at colonial history and the roots of the Innu people. Despite some technical uncertainties, the title manages to impress with its enchanting atmosphere and profound message.”

-16.2
Critics
75
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
-14.8
Critics
80
Steam
95
Metacritic
—
Release Date: May 1, 2025

Latest review: Chiara Roscini at Indie Games Devel

Aug 11, 2025 | Score 75

“Sub-Verge speaks to a precise audience: players who enjoy interactive storytelling, moral dilemmas, and narratives unafraid of dark outcomes. It demands patience, attention to detail, and a willingness to move forward through words rather than constant action. For others, it might feel more like an illustrated tale than a “traditional” game. But for those drawn to experiences blending psychology, science fiction, and underwater tension, Sub-Verge offers a short yet intense dive — with a final sequence that will hold your breath for you. And not just because of the oxygen. Recommended for anyone ready to immerse themselves in a tense, atmospheric tale where survival depends on the trust you earn.”

-3.2
Critics
68
Steam
71
Metacritic
—
-15.3
Critics
80
Steam
95
Metacritic
—
-7.7
Critics
80
Steam
88
Metacritic
—

Latest review: Greg Giddens at Cubed3

Jun 14, 2025 | Score 80

“With an intriguing story, classic horror and mystery tropes that align with the style and concepts behind its inspiration, in particular HP Lovecraft, The Horror at Highrook is a compelling and enjoyable investigation digital board game. It is not always obvious how to proceed, but a little determination proves rewarding and entertaining as you uncover the truth behind the cast of characters and the mansion they are investigating. It is a one-shot experience, though, so don’t let the board game aesthetic fool you.”

-9.1
Critics
81
Steam
91
Metacritic
—
+2.1
Critics
80
Steam
95
Metacritic
62

“Back: Fade is a hot mess—and it’s all the better for it. Equal parts terrifying and ridiculous, it’s a trashy horror gem that fans of FMV, cult cinema, and experimental storytelling will love. It’s not for everyone. But if your idea of a good time includes haunted birthday parties, possessed teddy bears, and dialogue so strange it could summon demons, Back: Fade is the experience you didn’t know you needed.”

-11.6
Critics
70
Steam
82
Metacritic
—
-16.4
Critics
60
Steam
76
Metacritic
—