Menu
Theme
Z

Zachary Holmes

80.1
Avg Score Given
-4.3
Steam Disparity
+11.9
MC Disparity
+3.8
Combined Disparity
94
Reviews
4 early reviews (before release)|84 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|6 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

55
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
7.7
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Low score spread detected. This reviewer may use a narrow scoring range or binary scoring system.

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

9/14/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

The Knightling is a delightful surprise in 2025’s action-adventure lineup. It’s not perfect—bugs, difficulty spikes, and limited side content keep it from true greatness—but it more than makes up for those flaws with heart, creativity, and sheer charm. Sliding through Clesseia on a shield, uncovering whimsical details, and gradually growing from trainee to hero is an adventure worth taking. For fans of Zelda-inspired worlds, indie action games, or simply anyone craving a fresh spin on the classic knight’s tale, The Knightling delivers a fun, heartfelt, and memorable journey.

Critic
80
Steam
88-8.4
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
88-8.4

9/10/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Katanaut is one of the most exciting indie roguelites of 2025. It blends the rewarding progression of Dead Cells, the atmospheric dread of Dead Space, and the precision combat of a Souls-like into a package that feels fresh and addictive. It isn’t perfect—combat can feel awkward at first, and some systems could use fine-tuning—but these flaws are minor compared to the sheer fun of diving into the station’s haunted corridors run after run. Whether you’re slashing through abominations with a katana, unlocking bizarre new upgrades, or just petting the cat before another doomed attempt, Katanaut delivers a memorable experience. For roguelite fans, sci-fi horror lovers, or anyone craving a game with style, substance, and plenty of replayability, Katanaut is absolutely worth the plunge.

Critic
85
Steam
92-6.9
Metacritic
67+18.0
Combined
79+5.5

Firefighting Simulator: Ignite: A fiery, fun, and authentic-enough simulator that shines brightest when played with friends. With updates and mod support, it has the potential to become the definitive firefighting game.

Critic
80
Steam
81-1.3
Metacritic
88-8.0
Combined
85-4.7

Goosebumps: Terror in Little Creek isn’t a perfect game. It’s short, simple, and clearly aimed at a younger demographic rather than hardcore horror fans. But what it does well—capturing the spooky but fun tone of R.L. Stine’s novels—it does very well. For longtime fans, the Easter eggs and references make it a treat. For younger players, it’s a safe and accessible introduction to the horror genre. For everyone else, it’s a fun, atmospheric diversion that would feel more justified at half the price. If you grew up with Goosebumps and want to relive those nostalgic chills—or if you’re looking for a spooky adventure to share with younger gamers—this is worth a playthrough. Just don’t expect it to keep you up at night… unless you were already afraid of the basement.

Critic
75
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

Chip ‘n Clawz vs. The Brainioids isn’t a massive, sprawling epic—it’s a mid-sized game with a clever hook. The fusion of action and RTS works, the humor lands more often than not, and the comic-book world is a joy to explore. But the short campaign and lack of multiplayer bots keep it from truly shining as a long-term staple. If you’re looking for something fresh, colorful, and co-op friendly, this is easy to recommend—especially if you have a buddy for couch co-op. If you’re buying solely for PvP, though, you may want to wait for updates or a larger player base.

Critic
80
Steam
88-8.3
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
88-8.3

Fate/hollow ataraxia REMASTERED is not just a companion piece to Fate/stay night—it’s a masterclass in balancing tone, character, and mystery. Its slice-of-life warmth enhances the franchise’s mythos, while its looping tragedy digs deeper into the themes of fate, justice, and the burden of memory. Yes, the new soundtrack may lack some of the raw strangeness of the original. Yes, the structure can feel repetitive at times. But taken as a whole, this remaster delivers one of TYPE-MOON’s most poignant, playful, and powerful works to a wider audience than ever before. If you’ve completed all three routes of Fate/stay night, this is essential. If not—finish them first. Then return to Fuyuki, step into the loop, and relive four days of destiny that will linger with you long after they end.

Critic
90
Steam
98-7.8
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
98-7.8

8/22/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Wildgate isn’t just another shooter—it’s a bold experiment that succeeds more often than it fails. By merging tactical ship management with fast-paced FPS action, Moonshot Games has created a truly unique multiplayer experience that scratches the itch for both Sea of Thieves-style crew chaos and extraction shooter tension. Yes, the $30 price tag is steep, the balance needs tweaking, and the community size raises eyebrows. But when you’re in the middle of a storm, dodging enemy fire while a crewmate boards a rival ship to steal their Artifact, none of that matters. Few games deliver such adrenaline-pumping, cinematic matches. For those willing to invest the time—and ideally bring a squad along—Wildgate is one of the most exciting multiplayer experiments of 2025. It’s a flawed gem, but a gem nonetheless.

Critic
80
Steam
78+2.0
Metacritic
70+10.0
Combined
74+6.0

8/12/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Abyssus is a confident, stylish roguelite shooter that nails the fundamentals—tight combat, meaningful progression, and a unique setting. While there’s room for more content and polish, the core experience is already highly addictive, whether you’re diving alone or with a squad of friends. If you enjoy FPS roguelites and want something with personality, atmosphere, and mechanical depth, this is a must-play. And with more content promised post-launch, Abyssus has all the makings of a long-term favorite in the co-op shooter space.

Critic
90
Steam
85+4.6
Metacritic
59+31.0
Combined
72+17.8

8/3/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Luto is a rare kind of horror game. It doesn’t rely on cheap tricks. It doesn’t shower you with jump scares or gore. Instead, it quietly burrows into your psyche and stays there. For fans of psychological horror, narrative exploration, or games that explore grief and trauma with artistic depth, Luto is a must-play. It’s challenging, both intellectually and emotionally, but it’s also rewarding. This is indie horror with a soul.

Critic
90
Steam
85+5.0
Metacritic
73+17.0
Combined
79+11.0

8/1/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Return to Ash is a quiet triumph. It’s not flashy. It doesn’t demand much of your time. But it leaves a mark. Like waking from a vivid dream, you’ll carry bits of it with you. Maybe it’s a line of dialogue. Maybe it’s the moment you chose kindness. Maybe it’s just that soft feeling of being seen. Serenity Forge has delivered something beautifully self-contained. For anyone in need of a reflective, emotionally resonant visual novel, Return to Ash is worth the journey.

Critic
80
Steam
98-18.1
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
98-18.1

7/28/2025

Early Review
Read Review

Heartworm is more than just a tribute—it’s an evolution. Equal parts chilling and contemplative, it knows when to whisper and when to scream. From the stunning environments to the rich audio and the elegant blending of old and new mechanics, every piece feels hand-placed with purpose. Vincent Adinolfi and the small team behind Heartworm have crafted something special—a horror experience with soul. It’s one of 2025’s finest indie titles and a must-play for anyone who ever felt their skin crawl in a PS1 hallway.

Critic
90
Steam
87+2.8
Metacritic
49+41.0
Combined
68+21.9

7/23/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Sunset High is a bold, smart, and emotionally resonant game that takes narrative risks and mostly pulls them off. It might not be for everyone—especially those allergic to reading or narrative-heavy gameplay—but for fans of mystery, visual novels, or character-driven experiences, it's a must-play. With memorable characters, a compelling premise, and the kind of story that sticks with you, Sunset High deserves a spot on your indie must-play list.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

7/21/2025

Early Review
Read Review

Hell Clock is for players who love a challenge, who don’t mind getting their builds broken and their egos bruised. It borrows the best parts of Diablo, PoE, Hades, and Binding of Isaac, yet still feels wholly original thanks to its bold cultural inspiration and smart mechanical design. It’s not for everyone. But if you’re someone who dreams in DPS numbers and lives for build theory, Hell Clock is absolutely worth it.

Critic
90
Steam
84+6.2
Metacritic
87+3.0
Combined
85+4.6

7/20/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Kick’n Hell is a tight, focused, and furious platformer that trades hand-holding for harsh lessons and big payoffs. With its unique kick-based locomotion, brutal difficulty, and beautifully crafted pixel hellscapes, it stands out as one of the more memorable indie releases this year. It might frustrate you. It might break you. But when you finally kick your way to the top and stare down Satan, it’ll all be worth it.

Critic
85
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

7/17/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Whether you’re a solo runner stacking item combos or a four-person squad trying not to die in the same room, this sequel proves Veewo still knows how to blend absurdity and action into a satisfying loop.

Critic
80
Steam
67+12.6
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
67+12.6

ISLANDERS: New Shores is a meditative puzzle disguised as a builder. It’s a game about placement, rhythm, and calm thinking. It’s relaxing, rewarding, and quietly brilliant. Whether you’re chasing a leaderboard run or crafting a sleepy island village in Sandbox mode, it offers just enough strategy to keep you engaged and just enough beauty to make you care. It doesn’t shout. It doesn’t overwhelm. It invites you to stay a while — and maybe build something a little better each time.

Critic
85
Steam
97-11.6
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
97-11.6

EYES ON THE EXAM is a thrilling mix of panic-inducing exams and eerie mysteries. Stay focused, or face the consequences. A unique indie gem that'll keep you on edge.

Critic
75
Steam
94-19.3
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
94-19.3

6/30/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

Empyreal offers a deep dive into a mysterious world with challenging gameplay and rich features. Dive in for a rewarding action RPG experience!

Critic
70
Steam
71-0.7
Metacritic
82-12.0
Combined
76-6.4

Super Engine GT Turbo SPEC is fun, accessible, and charming in its presentation, but ultimately limited in scope. It looks the part, plays smoothly, and feels nostalgic, but it runs out of gas too quickly for serious racing fans.

Critic
65
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
60+5.0
Combined
60+5.0

6/27/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

An electrifying mix of rhythm, platforming, and rebellion. ANTRO's unique blend of music and action keeps the adrenaline pumping. Join the revolution!

Critic
80
Steam
92-12.4
Metacritic
68+12.0
Combined
80-0.2
Page 1 of 5Next