Return to Ash
Released: 7/10/2025
Score Breakdown
73.3
Critic Average
3 reviews
98
Steam User Score
107 reviews
N/A
Metacritic User Score
Disparity Breakdown
73 vs 98
Average of both sources
Review Disparities
Each point represents a critic review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
8/1/2025
Launch Window“Return to Ash is a quiet triumph. It’s not flashy. It doesn’t demand much of your time. But it leaves a mark. Like waking from a vivid dream, you’ll carry bits of it with you. Maybe it’s a line of dialogue. Maybe it’s the moment you chose kindness. Maybe it’s just that soft feeling of being seen. Serenity Forge has delivered something beautifully self-contained. For anyone in need of a reflective, emotionally resonant visual novel, Return to Ash is worth the journey.”
80
80/100
7/16/2025
Launch Window“Return to Ash is a visual novel about being dead and being alone. It has a strong premise, but one I don't think it lives up to. My biggest issue stems from how short it is as when it finally starts to get interesting, the story is over. Still, it's a fine time, and there is one strong story route in here that shows it could be done with a little more time. I still think it's worth a try, just know you'll do everything in an afternoon.”
60
60/100
7/14/2025
Launch Window“Return to Ash is a pleasant little bite-sized piece that opens up important themes in a sensitively melancholic way.”
80
80/100
