Seth G. Macy
Scoring Pattern
Disparity by Outlet
Disparity Over Time
Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
Reviews
11/6/2025
Launch Window“Ball x Pit is a surprisingly deep brick-breaker that relies heavily on smart strategy, clever experimentation, and careful planning more so than RNG and luck alone.”
12/5/2024
Launch Window“After a very bumpy take-off, Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024 has hit a smooth cruising altitude, with impressive new features and exciting modes that once again make it an outstanding achievement.”
10/3/2023
Launch Window“Station to Station is a relaxing, cozy railway planner with clear goals, flexibility in how you accomplish them, and the absolute perfect amount of challenge. It doesn't try to be anything more than a fun and easy going experience, and the fact you can randomize levels and crank their difficulty up a bit provides some nice variety to how you approach each session. I love its voxel-based graphics so much, the music is soothing, and it just oozes charm. Even failing a level didn’t frustrate, because it just meant I got another opportunity to roll through the blocky countryside and do a little better. Its biggest strength lies in its simplicity, and it doesn't stray too far from that initial gameplay premise. Honestly, it doesn't have to.”
2/17/2023
Early Review“Octopath Traveler 2 is a very enjoyable JRPG sequel that feels a little too safe and familiar.”
11/1/2022
Launch Window“Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2's multiplayer moves the formula forward with bigger maps and more customization without sacrificing its bulletproof mechanics. [OpenCritic note: IGN separately reviewed the multiplayer (8) and single-player campaign (6). Their scores have been averaged.]”
11/10/2021
Launch Window“Call of Duty: Vanguard's multiplayer doesn't do enough new to distinguish itself from the last few years to be a great game, but its excellent maps and Champion Hill mode mean that it's still a reliably good time.”
8/3/2021
Launch Window“Exciting combat, fantastic art direction, and interesting environments only make me wish Boomerang X were twice as long.”
6/22/2021
Early Review“A beautiful modern rendering of a PlayStation classic, Legend of Mana retains both the charms and the problems from its initial release.”
6/10/2021
Early Review“Game Builder Garage is a robust, yet easy to learn, game engine that's absolutely delightful.”
2/25/2021
Early Review“Bravely Default 2 is a long, familiar JRPG journey with excellent customizable combat and beautiful backdrops that pass the time as you work through its extended stretches of grinding.”
10/7/2020
Launch Window“Super Mario Bros. 35 is stressful, strategic, and quite a bit of fun, but its repetitive nature makes it feel a little less super after a while.”
9/27/2020
Launch Window“Dated design, clunky multiplayer systems, and unacceptable load times make playing Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles Remastered Edition a terrific chore.”
8/17/2020
Early Review“Unparalleled realism and an entire planet to explore makes Microsoft Flight Simulator a simulation like no other.”
6/25/2020
Launch Window“Fun, novel, and brimming with loot, Bounty of Blood: A Fistful of Redemption is the best of Borderlands 3's DLC batch so far.”
5/22/2020
Early Review“Simple and fun to play, Minecraft Dungeons is a good entry-level dungeon crawler, but it doesn't dig too deep.”
4/22/2020
Early Review“Trials of Mana is a great remake of a 16-bit classic, but its 16-bit roots are often hard to ignore.”
2/24/2020
Early Review“The games in the Mega Man Zero/ZX Legacy still deliver, but the bonus features are pretty standard fare.”
12/19/2019
Launch Window“Moxxi's Heist of The Handsome Jackpot starts off a little bumpy, but when it goes all-in, it hits the jackpot.”
6/26/2019
Early Review“Super Mario Maker 2 does nearly everything better than its already excellent predecessor, keeping the charm of a Mario game while introducing some incredible new ideas.”
6/9/2019
Launch Window“The great news is Commander Lilith and the Fight for Sanctuary DLC is more of the funny, loot-happy Borderlands 2 we know and love. It's a lot of fun and a novel way build anticipation for the sequel.”
