Menu
Theme
D

David Walters

75.2
Avg Score Given
+2.4
Steam Disparity
+12.9
MC Disparity
+7.7
Combined Disparity
21
Reviews
4 early reviews (before release)|15 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|2 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

60
Lowest Score
95
Highest Score
9.7
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Low score spread detected. This reviewer may use a narrow scoring range or binary scoring system.

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

Disappointment is an understatement when it comes to Project Motor Racing. Vehicle control, sub-par graphics, and cost all contribute to the calamity that is PMR.

Critic
60
Steam
35+25.1
Metacritic
41+19.0
Combined
38+22.0

11/16/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

With so much potential to be had, RENNSPORT fumbled the bag with a limited selection of cars, paid liveries, and single-player AI that behaves unpredictably at best.

Critic
65
Steam
43+22.3
Metacritic
32+33.0
Combined
37+27.6

10/14/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

With very few options for variety, NASCAR 25 Just doesn't offer enough in terms of depth.

Critic
60
Steam
73-13.1
Metacritic
65-5.0
Combined
69-9.0

5/27/2025

Early Review
Read Review

It's racing season again, and that means a new F1 game from EA and Codemasters. F1 25 has some truly incredible moments, and lays some important building

Critic
80
Steam
88-7.5
Metacritic
75+5.0
Combined
81-1.3

The Talos Principle: Reawakened brings the past into the present with stunning detail and brand-new content to whet your puzzle-solving appetite.

Critic
95
Steam
92+3.5
Metacritic
67+28.0
Combined
79+15.8

3/28/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

MLB The Show 25 is an improvement over its predecessor, which is all I could ask for from a yearly title release.

Critic
85
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
54+31.0
Combined
54+31.0

2/20/2025

Early Review
Read Review

I am a big golf fan. I love playing it in real life, watching it, and playing various gaming titles over the years. Having spent dozens of hours playing PGA

Critic
80
Steam
69+11.3
Metacritic
55+25.0
Combined
62+18.1

10/2/2024

Early Review
Read Review

NHL 25 is a good game when it focuses on hockey, it’s when microtransactions come into play that things become tacky.

Critic
65
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
29+36.0
Combined
29+36.0

7/30/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

With the amount of customizability available in F1 Manager 2024, no two seasons will be alike and that as far from a bad thing as it can be.

Critic
80
Steam
82-2.0
Metacritic
73+7.0
Combined
77+2.5

7/24/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

SCHiM is an adorable indie platformer with a unique presentation and mechanic that make it a must-play for fans of cosy games and platformers.

Critic
85
Steam
77+7.8
Metacritic
59+26.0
Combined
68+16.9

7/16/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

Hot Lap Racing is an entertaining arcade-style racing game, but falls flat on keeping one entertained with a minimal amount to do.

Critic
65
Steam
66-0.7
Metacritic
71-6.0
Combined
68-3.3

With a massive scope of puzzles to solve, Islands of Insight has something for every puzzle enthusiast out there.

Critic
90
Steam
71+18.6
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
71+18.6

Interesting combat mechanics and a decent story headline Lysfanga: The Time Shift Warrior, and finding new ways to tackle each encounter keeps me coming back.

Critic
70
Steam
76-6.2
Metacritic
59+11.0
Combined
68+2.4

The initial release of LEGO Bricktales was a novel idea that successfully translated the childhood favourite of many to a digital platform while stumbling due to its reliance on conventional controls. LEGO Bricktales‘ Quests’ debut fixes this and delivers a truly mesmerizing experience that not only has that cool factor from playing it in augmented reality but is, by and large, the definitive version of an already fun-to-play game.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
N/A

10/9/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

EA Sports NHL 24 scratches the itch for a solid hockey title. There are significant improvements over last year’s title, but replayability, as always is up in the air for sports titles.

Critic
75
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
38+37.0
Combined
38+37.0

9/12/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

Overall, Ad Infinitum doesn’t do its best job showcasing what the experience is all about in the first hour. But, after that, it really takes off and soars. Especially the creature design, and while I am not a massive fan of the hide-and-seek horror, it plays it well here, and you truly get lost in the trenches. The sound design and voice acting aren’t the best, but it is passable enough. My biggest issue is that I had quite a bit of technical difficulties. Even when I turned the graphics setting to low, I was still experiencing framerate drops and quite a bit of screen tearing. I even managed to clip through some ladders a few times.

Critic
70
Steam
79-9.4
Metacritic
59+11.0
Combined
69+0.8

Repetitive gameplay and no sense of progression hamper an otherwise fine entry to the series. Super Mega Baseball 4 could be better if there was more to do than the same thing over and over again.

Critic
70
Steam
78-7.8
Metacritic
80-10.0
Combined
79-8.9

With amazing visuals and a steeper-than-expected learning curve, EA Sports PGA Tour is a welcome return to the market.

Critic
75
Steam
53+21.9
Metacritic
63+12.0
Combined
58+16.9

Sherlock Holmes The Awakened is a solid entry to the franchise by Ukrainian developer Frogwares, and I hope to see some DLC in the future to keep the adventure going.

Critic
75
Steam
83-7.7
Metacritic
70+5.0
Combined
76-1.3

A Space for the Unbound tries to stand on its story, but wraps it in a gameplay that is unbearably tedious.

Critic
70
Steam
97-27.2
Metacritic
77-7.0
Combined
87-17.1
Page 1 of 2Next