Borderlands 4
Released: 9/12/2025
Score Breakdown
81.8
Critic Average
15 reviews
60
Steam User Score
75,023 reviews
47
Metacritic User Score
777 reviews
Disparity Breakdown
82 vs 60
82 vs 47
Average of both sources
Review Disparities
Each point represents a critic review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
10/14/2025
Launch Window“Borderlands 4 has managed to overcome its own identity crisis and deliver a predictable but undeniably rich experience.”
90
90/100
9/25/2025
Launch Window“Sixteen years in, this is Gearbox’s cel-shaded shooter series at its best. From a well-calibrated tone, still-satisfying guns, best-in-class traversal, and an inviting open world, Borderlands 4 answers the question I asked when it was announced. How much can the Borderlands series possibly change? Turns out the answer is both not much… and a whole lot.”
90
90/100
9/19/2025
Launch Window“I really like Borderlands 4. I like it on the story front, gameplay front, mechanical front, and just all of it really. I have every intention of coming back to it and replaying it with the DLC characters in later playthroughs, and while the endgame stuff isn't that fleshed out yet, I have faith that it'll improve as time goes on. Let's just hope everyone else can enjoy it without bugs soon too!”
80
80/100
9/18/2025
Launch Window“Even a terrible UI and choppy performance didn't spoil several dozen hours of numbers-go-up bliss.”
82
82/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“To its detriment, Borderlands 4 feels like a direct response to Borderlands 3.”
70
70/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Does Borderlands 4 rise to the occasion and do the beloved franchise justice or is this just another Borderlands 2 wannabe?”
80
80/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“The sheer diversity of characters, gear, and ways to have fun is never-ending, and the open-world format is a surprisingly welcome addition to this amazing co-op FPS. Borderlands 4 is a leap in the right direction, and I can only hope that this trend continues upwards for the rest of the franchise.”
90
90/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Borderlands 4 is the redemption the saga needed - Gearbox has listened to the community and fixed everything that needed fixing. It's fresh, crazy, fun, chaotic - everything Borderlands should be and the perfect answer to that saying "two plus two always equals four". They've taken the best parts of Borderlands 2, corrected the mistakes of Borderlands 3, and added new mechanics that work without losing the essence.”
90
90/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Borderlands 4 is a great RPG shooter with rewarding, engrossing gameplay. Some of the set dressing, like the bland new characters and pointless grappling hook, take the shine off, but the sheer amount of fun we've had with the game can't be overlooked. Borderlands 4 reminds us exactly why we were such big fans of the original two games, and falls on its sword in learning the mistakes of 3.”
80
80/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Borderlands 4 is the best the series has been in decades and a testament to Gearbox’s ability to absolutely cook. Are you ready to taste the chaos?”
90
90/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Borderlands 4 gives the series the massive kick in the pants it has needed, with a fantastic open world and greatly improved combat, even bugs and invisible walls can sometimes throw off that groove.”
80
80/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Gearbox Software takes a 'back to basics' approach with Borderlands 4 that ends up being exactly what the series needed.”
80
80/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“Every time Gearbox made me laugh or grin, I would catch myself wishing for more of that authenticity”
80
80/100
9/11/2025
Early Review“It’s simultaneously a poster child for excess and restraint, which sounds paradoxical, but for a series named for existing on the border of seemingly opposed concepts, it feels right at home.”
85
85/100
