Menu
Theme
K

Kevin Dunsmore

74.2
Avg Score Given
+2.0
Steam Disparity
+10.2
MC Disparity
+6.1
Combined Disparity
139
Reviews
52 early reviews (before release)|82 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|5 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

40
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
10.7
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

Does Kirby Air Riders improve upon its predecessor and its place in Switch 2's lineup, or should the Kirby Air Ride franchise be left out to pasture?

Critic
70
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
87-17.0
Combined
87-17.0

Does Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 right the ship and deliver a proper sequel to Black Ops II, or is this yet another down year for Call of Duty?

Critic
90
Steam
40+50.5
Metacritic
16+74.0
Combined
28+62.2

Does Pokémon Legends: Z-A successfully shake up the Pokémon formula and deliver another exciting adventure or is this another doomed trip to Kalos?

Critic
70
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
47+23.0
Combined
47+23.0

Dying Light: The Beast promises a full Dying Light experience, but can it capture the magic and horror of its predecessors as a standalone title?

Critic
80
Steam
87-7.5
Metacritic
82-2.0
Combined
85-4.7

Battlefield 6 doesn't deliver a solid campaign, but it does deliver where it matters most, the gameplay and multiplayer. Finally, all these years later, we can finally say that Battlefield is back.

Critic
80
Steam
67+12.7
Metacritic
69+11.0
Combined
68+11.8

Does Borderlands 4 rise to the occasion and do the beloved franchise justice or is this just another Borderlands 2 wannabe?

Critic
80
Steam
60+20.0
Metacritic
47+33.0
Combined
54+26.5

Playing Gears of War: Reloaded is a beautiful reminder of how far the industry has come and what we've lost along the way. Upfront, Reloaded is a remaster of a remaster and does nothing to improve the nearly twenty-year-old game.

Critic
70
Steam
59+11.0
Metacritic
68+2.0
Combined
64+6.5

Does Destiny 2: The Edge of Fate successfully start a new chapter for Destiny 2 or does it falter under the pressure of its Herculean task?

Critic
50
Steam
29+21.2
Metacritic
39+11.0
Combined
34+16.1

The narrative is a step in the right direction by focusing on the relationship between the two leads and delivering a truly stellar final act.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
89-9.0
Combined
89-9.0

Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster is a good remaster that might not do much to freshen up the original experience, but it does make an already good game available to a new generation of RPG fans.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
72+8.0
Combined
72+8.0

Is Assassin's Creed Shadows the hail mary Assassin's Creed and Ubisoft needed, or should this game have stayed in the shadows?

Critic
70
Steam
77-7.0
Metacritic
61+9.0
Combined
69+1.0

Does Aspyr recapture the magic of the original release, or does Star Wars Episode I: Jedi Power Battles belong in the trash compactor?

Critic
80
Steam
77+3.3
Metacritic
76+4.0
Combined
76+3.7

Is LEGO Horizon Adventures a fun-filled LEGO adventure by a different developer or should LEGO leave their game development to Traveller's Tales?

Critic
70
Steam
60+10.0
Metacritic
58+12.0
Combined
59+11.0

There’s a good reason why Treyarch and Black Ops are so beloved by the Call of Duty community. The sub-franchise usually delivers the stronger campaigns, multiplayer and third modes in the series. Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 does all of those things, especially when compared to the more recent Call of Dutys. The campaign, from Raven Software, may drop the ball at the end with its story, but it’s filled with fantastic characters and a wide variety of missions that help elevate it into must-play territory.

Critic
80
Steam
43+36.6
Metacritic
62+18.0
Combined
53+27.3

Of course, credit goes to Guerrilla Games for writing a narrative and building out gameplay that remains interesting and engaging seven years on. At $49.99 for new players and $9.99 for owners of the PS4 or PC versions, Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered’s overhauled visuals feel like a steal.

Critic
90
Steam
84+6.5
Metacritic
72+18.0
Combined
78+12.2

8/27/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

What truly holds Concord back is its lack of identity. A story or campaign would have been a great way to showcase the world, its characters and lore, yet all of that is stuffed into the Galactic Guide that few players will probably ever read. The Freegunners and game modes are fun and mostly balanced, though feel derivative when stacked up against the already established competition. Meanwhile, map design feels safe with layouts that don’t encourage much experimentation. Concord is a good, fun game from a brand-new studio that’s currently missing its identity. It may be a bit lost in space, but Concord checks off enough boxes to hopefully chart a path forward.

Critic
70
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
17+53.0
Combined
17+53.0

The updates to gameplay make Bounty Hunter feel modern, fluid and accessible, though the legacy controls are still there for purists. It would have been nice to see a remaster or remake that fixed additional quirks and greatly improved the presentation, but as a $19.99 port, Aspyr has delivered enough changes and updates to make Star Wars: Bounty Hunter feel like the game it always should have been at launch. Star Wars: Bounty Hunter is one bounty you’ll want to bring in alive.

Critic
70
Steam
81-11.3
Metacritic
77-7.0
Combined
79-9.2

It’s hard to keep something going for ten years, especially a Live Service game. The industry is littered with failed attempts at building ten-year plans. Despite Destiny’s many ups and downs and lack of consistent quality through the years, Destiny 2: The Final Shape completes Bungie’s ambitious ten-year plan and mostly sticks the landing. Its story is the most focused a Destiny tale has ever gotten, opting to focus on character interactions, linear level design and heartfelt payoffs. While this route meant a complete neglect of the series’ big bad, it did culminate in an epic finale to the Light and Darkness saga.

Critic
70
Steam
79-8.9
Metacritic
74-4.0
Combined
76-6.4

5/30/2024

Launch Window
Read Review

Ubisoft’s attempt to blend two disparate genres together backfires, creating massive balancing issues and diluting both experiences. Its lack of polish on the server side leads to outright aggravating and uneven experiences. Finally, while XDefiant is free-to-play, the fact that there’s little earn and outright unlock leaves little incentive to stick with the game beyond a couple of matches occasionally. XDefiant provides that solid, fun FPS action in small doses, but is sorely held back by a lack of focus, polish and earnable content.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
47+13.0
Combined
47+13.0

Team Ninja shot for the moon and delivered a fun open-world action game that, despite its faults, is an excellent experience. Rise of the Ronin provides a fantastic new vision for Team Ninja.

Critic
80
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
79+1.0
Combined
79+1.0
Page 1 of 7Next