Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow

“Thief VR delivers a faithful stealth experience in virtual reality, staying true to the series core mechanics while introducing a new protagonist. Although the gameplay offers multiple approaches and effective stealth design, the combat system feels shallow and repetitive. The narrative includes interesting references to the franchise’s past, but its short length limits emotional impact. Visually and technically, the game shows clear limitations, with unpolished character models and a weak audio presentation. Overall, it’s a competent but unambitious entry that keeps the series alive without fully revitalizing it.”

“It’s a mostly triumphant return for this long-dormant franchise, one that makes excellent use of VR to enhance immersion and really makes you feel like a master thief. Though it’s not perfect, and a few issues hold it back. Whilst, as a franchise fan, I wouldn’t recommend fellow fans to run out and buy a headset for this release, it is one I can easily recommend to longtime Thief fans and newcomers that also happen to have a VR headset.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow is potentially a very cool VR game. The problem, however, lies in the many bugs that can really break the game. Consider items that spontaneously disappear that are essential to passing the level. Restarting the level is then the only option. If you can look past that, then it's all quite doable. Sneaking around and stealing stuff works surprisingly well and the gray style certainly contributes to the experience that Maze Theory wants to offer you.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadows doesn’t reinvent the genre or the platform, and although it introduces a few new mechanics, they’re not enough to push it to the top. On top of that, being multiplatform significantly holds it back in terms of graphical quality.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow is a visually good-looking game, and there is a lot here that feels at home with the license. It's just a shame Legacy of Shadow is as barebones as we see with most VR titles. There is always some interesting hook that has a game built around it, but Legacy of Shadow lacks a hook to lay the foundation. The subtle nicking of items is fun, but a game built around this beloved license simply deserved more.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow doesn’t reinvent the saga, but faithfully revives it. Dark atmospheres and stealth gameplay remain central, while Magpie adds freshness without betraying Garrett’s legacy. Weak AI and simplified progression hold it back from past heights, yet for fans of shadows and Stephen Russell’s voice, this VR journey is a modest but welcome gift—not a masterpiece, but a return that still makes us smile as we steal in silence.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow is not a bad game. It is an enjoyable, lightweight stealth adventure with good vibes, fun levels, and a clear respect for what makes the Thief fantasy appealing. It is also not essential. It is the definition of a solid seven out of ten experience. Something you play, appreciate for what it is, shrug at the rough parts, and move on.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow on PSVR2 is modest in ambition but confident in its chosen identity. It doesn't offer the sprawling systemic depth of its ancestors, nor does it push stealth AI into new territory, yet the tactile VR experience elevates what could have been forgettable into something surprisingly satisfying. The repetition, the shallow enemy behaviour, and the occasional technical hiccup undeniably pull the game down, but the undeniable charm of physically inhabiting the shadows pushes it back up. What's left is a VR stealth experience that works because it leans into the strengths of the medium, even if it can't fully escape its weaknesses.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow brings the historic franchise into virtual reality with surprising ease, building an experience grounded in physical stealth, verticality, and tactile interactions. It's not perfect, but it's still unmissable.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow feels like a return to form for the immersive sim series.”

“Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow captures the spirit of the franchise and implements it into the VR realm. While smaller in scale, the tight, intricate design makes use of the platform to create an exhilarating stealth adventure. The interactivity anchors you in the world; however, small bugs can quickly break the immersion. While the franchise has stepped away from its origins, it’s found new life in VR.”

“In the end, that bitter pill spoils Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow so thoroughly that, despite Maze Theory’s good intentions, its sweet Thief aftertaste is lost to tech limitations and janky controls—leaving a VR revival that simply can’t escape the gallows of its own shortcomings.”