Menu
Theme
N

Nic Bunce

71.9
Avg Score Given
-13.2
Steam Disparity
-0.8
MC Disparity
-7.0
Combined Disparity
57
Reviews
14 early reviews (before release)|36 launch window reviews (within 60 days of release)|7 late reviews

Scoring Pattern

30
Lowest Score
100
Highest Score
18.5
Score Spread(variance in their own scores)

Disparity by Outlet

Disparity Over Time

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

Reviews

Dragon Quest VII Reimagined is a very, very impressive remake. 26 years after its original release, this modernised edition of the game is everything I want from an RPG, and I can imagine it landing very well with people who grew up partying with Kiefer and Maribel. It's held back from a perfect score by only the smallest of gripes around pacing.

Critic
90
Steam
92-2.0
Metacritic
74+16.0
Combined
83+7.0

It's amazing to drop back into Cult of the Lamb with the Woolhaven DLC, and the harsh new reality it imposes on your cult. I just wish it came a few years sooner, so I hadn't forgotten everything from my last run in 2022! If you're new to the game, this won't be a problem, but if you're old hat, it may be better to start New Game+ and get back to speed, rather than jumping in late, low on resources and struggling more than you need to through your first few winters.

Critic
80
Steam
93-12.8
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
93-12.8

Unlike the most recent Pokémon Scarlet & Violet, Pokémon Legends: Z-A is a game that really holds your attention. The spiritual successor to Legends Arceus, it's learned from the mistakes of the distant past and beautifully shows what city life is like in the Pokémon universe. I can see myself playing this for another hundred hours as I finish my Pokédex, shiny hunt and generally have a great time. This is easily the best Pokémon game on the market.

Critic
100
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
47+53.0
Combined
47+53.0

Disgaea 7 Complete clearly is the ultimate version of Vows of the Virtueless. The story is as quirky and fun as ever, and the bonus content is an absolute must for die-hard fans. Being able to play it on the Switch 2 on the go is also great, with the game looking and feeling fantastic in both handheld and docked mode. The only knock is the uphill struggle for newcomers with reams of tiresome tutorials – hopefully NIS will have figured out by the time Disgaea 8 rolls around.

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
60+30.0
Combined
60+30.0

Final Fantasy Tactics: The Ivalice Chronicles faithfully and lovingly remasters this deep and complicated classic for modern console. I had forgotten how much I enjoyed it, and it has been amazing sinking back into the world of Ivalice. If you can get past some of the retro gaming pitfalls above, you will see a game that absolutely loves the franchise it's in, with nods to Final Fantasy lore scattered throughout. If you're a fan of either Final Fantasy or Tactical RPGs, we strongly recommend you pick this up.

Critic
80
Steam
91-10.5
Metacritic
75+5.0
Combined
83-2.8

How does Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster hold up in 2025? In short, it holds up poorly unless you're a big fan of the franchise, or just love JRPG tropes with a passion. Even the combat mechanics that lends the game its name wear thin, leaving little about this game to really recommend against more inventive JRPGs or Switch 2 launch titles. For the first time ever I'd rather play a racing game than a JRPG...

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
72-12.0
Combined
72-12.0

Raidou Remastered is one of those games that all Persona fans should pick up without question. There are a few too many niggles that hold it back from being perfect, but for many people this could just be one of the all-time greats, and the perfect game to tide you over as you wait for Persona 4's upcoming remake.

Critic
80
Steam
93-13.1
Metacritic
81-1.0
Combined
87-7.0

6/16/2025

Launch Window
Read Review

While 'Survival' part of the title is clearly wrong, the 'Kids' bit is on the money. Survival Kids is a good option if you're looking for a chill game with a less-experienced partner or your kid when they get home from school. It's a colourful, amusing but altogether simple game that gets pretty samey if you're looking for even a semblance of challenge.

Critic
70
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
57+13.0
Combined
57+13.0

I really wanted to write about the positives of featuring more cultures in this genre, and about how cool it is to have a famous actor play the protagonist, but sadly the gameplay gets in the way of anything interesting. Unknown 9: Awakening is just a bunch of gaming tropes loosely tied together with boring and uninspired NPCs lazily lurching from set piece to set piece, as the poorly designed game creaks and groans under the weight of expectation.

Critic
50
Steam
36+14.0
Metacritic
19+31.0
Combined
28+22.5

Sam and Max: The Devil's Playhouse is exactly what you want from a remaster. It has been faithfully rebuilt, adding improvements and things that make sense, and tightening the things that were a little leaky. I loved stepping back into Sam's (lack of) shoes and holding the world to rights as a newly psychic Max. If you don't mind a bit of juvenile humour, this is still one of the funniest point-and-click adventures I've ever played, but a little prettier than I remember.

Critic
90
Steam
99-8.9
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
99-8.9

Magic: The Gathering – Bloomburrow is a fantastic set for new players and those who dip in and out of Arena, or are looking for an easy entry point. The tribal nature means you can build decks with the safety rails on, and the relatively simple mechanics introduced in the set make for a relatively shallow learning curve. Plus, did we mention the cards are adorable? All of this means that there hasn't been a better time to start learning Magic in the past few years.

Critic
60
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
31+29.0
Combined
31+29.0

Shin Megami Tensei V: Vengeance is an excellent addition to the franchise that's a must-play for franchise fans, and well worth picking up for those curious about dipping their toes in the water. The difficulty level is still there, but it has become a lot more manageable thanks to quality of life updates. Just don't be disappointed if you show up expecting Persona, as the narrative and story qualities of the latter is a world apart.

Critic
80
Steam
93-12.6
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
93-12.6

Final Fantasy VII Rebirth is a beautifully crafted experience that fans old and new will absolutely love. It almost goes too far in correcting the first game's linearity with broad open areas stuffed with things to do, but there's also key additions to the combat, and the story running through this middle chapter is masterfully retold. Really the biggest problem you'll have once the credits roll is knowing that it will be far too many years before we can finish the trilogy.

Critic
90
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
89+1.0
Combined
89+1.0

At best, the Metal Gear Solid HD Master Collection is a cynical cash grab that is trying to repackage and resell you on nostalgia. There are very few reasons to part with your cash at this point: wait for a proper ground-up remake.

Critic
40
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
64-24.0
Combined
64-24.0

8/31/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

Sea of Stars has clearly been made by people with a deep and abiding love of JRPGs. That level of passion is hard to mimic, and the result is a heavily playable game with morish visuals, a cracking story and deeply considered level design. However, while it is very good, it isn't quite perfect. Combat needed to be deeper (or at least escapable) and while the dynamism was a great touch, it wasn't enough to carry it all the way through to the end.

Critic
90
Steam
89+0.9
Metacritic
80+10.0
Combined
85+5.4

Cassette Beasts is simply one of the best Pokémon-like games I've come across, and I'm looking forward to earning a 100% completion. With a massive end-game and modder support built in at release though, I feel like I'm going to get very sidetracked on the way there.

Critic
90
Steam
94-4.3
Metacritic
84+6.0
Combined
89+0.8

3/21/2023

Launch Window
Read Review

Tchia is clearly a labour of love as Awaceb try to bring their culture to the rest of the world and show off what it has to offer. I absolutely love that tone and feel, but the way Tchia is packaged and paced means that it is ultimately feels like less than the sum of its parts.

Critic
50
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
66-16.0
Combined
66-16.0

If you like a very slow, difficult romp through a Hell-a-la-tattoo-parlour, Nadir's roguelike deckbuilding may be the game for you. But if you want something genuinely fun and interesting to play, you won't find it here.

Critic
40
Steam
63-22.7
Metacritic
N/A
Combined
63-22.7

Tales of Symphonia Remastered isn't going to win any awards. It's a soulless cash grab that has come with as little effort by Bandai Namco as possible. If you're a die-hard fan, there may be something here for you, but really you're just paying for the nostalgia hit. Those who didn't play the original and are looking to pick up and enjoy a slice of video game history should let this one go past - there will hopefully be another iteration of this in a few years' time and maybe they'll put more effort into that one.

Critic
40
Steam
N/A
Metacritic
62-22.0
Combined
62-22.0

Path of the Midnight Sun is well worth a look if you're a fan of turn-based JRPGs. If you enjoyed the old Final Fantasy and Fire Emblem games, then there's a high chance that you'll love this.

Critic
80
Steam
85-5.2
Metacritic
72+8.0
Combined
79+1.4
Page 1 of 3Next