Menu
Theme

My Friendly Neighborhood

Released: 7/18/2023

Critics
80
vs
Users
95

Score Breakdown

79.6

Critic Average

16 reviews

95

Steam User Score

3,223 reviews

76

Metacritic User Score

34 reviews

Disparity Breakdown

Steam Disparity
-15.7

80 vs 95

Metacritic Disparity
+3.6

80 vs 76

Combined Disparity
-6.0

Average of both sources

Review Disparities

Positive = critic higher than usersNegative = critic lower than users

Each point represents a critic review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.

10/4/2025

Late Review

My Friendly Neighborhood is a genuine surprise, offering a fresh take on survival horror and forging its own identity within its genre.

80

80/100

Read

7/29/2025

Late Review

My Friendly Neighborhood toes the line between horror and humour, in an epic survival quest that turns nostalgia into apprehension. I definitely recommend this game to those looking for a less serious adventure that still provides the gratification and entertainment of bigger titles. I will certainly be revisiting it in my spare time.

87

87/100

Read

7/29/2025

Late Review

If you ever thought Resident Evil needed more felt My Friendly Neighborhood will be right up your Sesame Street.

72

72/100

Read

7/26/2025

Late Review

Nightmare on Sesame Street, err, I mean My Friendly Neighborhood, is an interesting kids show turned horror game that was incredibly entertaining for a single run, despite some outdated game design choices. I’ve made some new felt friends along the way and will certainly remember my time spent on this set, but I don’t have the stuffing required for completing the game across multiple playthroughs.

80

80/100

Read

7/24/2025

Late Review

My Friendly Neighbourhood is a surprisingly enjoyable romp with a beautiful style, good comic humor, sensible puzzles and design and engaging narrative. Its combat can be a bit hit and miss and there is a sense of back-tracking and auto-piloting that happens as you play, causing you to disconnect from the experience at times. But if you’re looking for something a little different in the vein of Poppy Playtime and the Bendy series, you’re going to have a great time with these puppets.

70

70/100

Read

7/23/2025

Late Review

My Friendly Neighborhood succeeds not just as a genre experiment, but as an experience that knows what it wants to say—and says it with flair, tape, and an arsenal of alphabet ammunition.

80

80/100

Read

7/21/2025

Late Review

My Friendly Neighborhood, a twisted love letter to classic survival horror inspired by Resident Evil, blends clever storytelling, brilliant level design, and sharp puzzles with slightly stiff combat and loads of silly cheats and bonus modes—making it a great horror game that even Oscar the Grouch couldn’t grumble about.

80

80/100

Read

9/11/2023

Launch Window

My Friendly Neighborhood may not have the blood and guts that many crave out of their horror experiences but it accomplishes so much without violence in a way that feels new and interesting. The world and story are fleshed out wonderfully and there’s an amazing message behind the game’s final moments.

90

90/100

Read

8/23/2023

Launch Window

My Friendly Neighborhood offers a unique execution of a conceit that’s otherwise become trite among horror games. Taking the “spooky kiddy thing” idea and pulling it onto a framework built from equal parts BioShock and Resident Evil smartly separates it from the ocean of similar concepts in the genre, even if none of its individual components are particularly original. It’s sadly let down from a lack of variety and consequently runs too long, unable to stay fresh or surprising enough to sustain its runtime. However, it’s a fun ride while it lasts, and it’s story is charming enough to be worth seeing through to the end.

70

70/100

Read

8/1/2023

Launch Window

My Friendly Neighborhood is a pleasant surprise and a genuine delight, one highly recommended for fans of survival horror, mascot horror and possibly even those who aren't horror fans.

80

80/100

Read

7/30/2023

Launch Window

Survival horror mechanics in a colorful puppet show? Sounds meh. Feels great.

80

80/100

Read

7/18/2023

Launch Window

Thankfully, these weaknesses are overpowered by everything else and never become apparent until after the halfway point. From beginning to end, My Friendly Neighborhood is a wonderful game full of mystery, tension, clever design, and phenomenal performances. This is a must-play title that will hopefully gain the traction and attention it deserves.

90

90/100

Read

7/17/2023

Early Review

If you're a fan of old-school survival horror, My Friendly Neighborhood is an essential playthrough that feels fresh yet familiar to fans of the genre.

80

80/100

Read

7/17/2023

Early Review

While My Friendly Neighborhood is rough in several spots, Its solid survival horror gameplay, dedication to its premise, and great replay value make it must play.

80

80/100

Read

7/17/2023

Early Review

As for the MFN offices, they’re full of detailed memorabilia like posters, props, and episode scripts, to the point where simply taking it all in is perhaps the game’s main appeal. There’s a tangible love and care that has gone into making the game’s equivalent of Sesame Street studios feel plausible, as well as a clear delight in warping our memory of a show that opened up a world of imagination for generations of children into something darker.

70

70/100

Read

7/17/2023

Early Review

Impressive efforts with a few noticeable problems holding them back. Won't astound everyone, but is worth your time and cash.

85

85/100

Read