Escape from Ever After
Released: 1/23/2026
Score Breakdown
83.1
Critic Average
16 reviews
98
Steam User Score
913 reviews
89
Metacritic User Score
27 reviews
Disparity Breakdown
83 vs 98
83 vs 89
Average of both sources
Review Disparities
Each point represents a critic review. Hover for details. Positive = critic higher than users. Negative = critic lower.
80
80/100
2/6/2026
Launch Window“Escape Ever After pairs a clever satirical premise with charming storybook visuals, delivering a creative RPG experience that doesn’t always maintain its momentum.”
84
84/100
2/3/2026
Launch Window“The best Paper Mario game since The Thousand Year Door just so happens to be missing the Paper Mario nametag. Escape From Ever After spins an entertaining fairy-tale yarn, backed by likeable characters, smartly designed combat, and a clear affection for the genre it’s riffing on.”
80
80/100
2/3/2026
Launch Window“Have you ever wondered what it would be like to live in an actual fairytale? To approach the castle of your archnemesis, knock down the door and…find it converted into an office space? That’s the premise behind Escape From Ever After, a delightful rpg inspired by the classic Paper Mario games. If you needed a fun game to take you back to those days and scratch an itch you didn’t know you had, Escape From Ever After is for you.”
80
80/100
1/30/2026
Launch Window“Don't judge a book by its cover. Escape From Ever After hides a depth that many “adult” games would love to have.”
83
83/100
1/30/2026
Launch Window“Escape from Ever After is one of those indie games that takes you by surprise and stays with you. It's very original and full of humor, the combat system is challenging but fair, and the design makes the most of each setting. If you're in the mood for a turn-based RPG with personality, go for it.”
80
80/100
1/30/2026
Launch Window“Escape from Ever After surpasses its inspiration with a captivating story, fun protagonists, and varied gameplay, including moves and accessories , plus extra modes that increase duration and challenge. However, the pacing of some stages makes the fights repetitive quickly.”
70
70/100
1/28/2026
Launch Window“In many ways this feels like a creative, and often funny, alternative take on the Paper Mario formula, but it isn’t quite as polished”
83
83/100
75
75/100
1/27/2026
Launch Window“Escape from Ever After establishes its lighthearted fairy tale world wonderfully with its endearing visuals, characters, and music and it plays superbly to boot thanks to its impressively strategic party setup and battle mechanics. What an absolute delight! 📖”
86
86/100
1/26/2026
Launch Window“Escape from Ever After feels like a game that knows what it’s trying to do and sticks the landing. It takes familiar turn-based RPG ideas and gives them a fun twist, with a story that’s self-aware without trying too hard to be clever. The combat stays interesting thanks to the timing-based mechanics, and the world has enough personality to keep you invested as you move through it.”
88
88/100
1/26/2026
Launch Window“Escape from Ever After is the Paper Mario style game I've been waiting for since the GameCube, with a seriously charming fairytale setting.”
90
90/100
1/23/2026
Launch Window“Escape from Ever After is much more than a turn-based RPG with increasing numbers; it's a narrative and playful experience with its own personality.”
90
90/100
1/23/2026
Launch Window“Just like its literary inspirations, Escape from Ever After has found ways to not only make them lived-in but flesh them out with unique enemies and bosses.”
80
80/100
1/22/2026
Early Review“Since the release of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door in 2004, developers—including Nintendo—have searched for the next big hit, and with Escape from Ever After, Sleepy Castle Studio delivers a charming yet deep RPG that lovingly honors its inspiration while offering strong writing, rich gameplay systems, colorful worlds, a fantastic soundtrack, and only minor flaws.”
90
90/100
1/13/2026
Early Review“Escape from Ever After is a great game, and considering how people took to last year’s Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, part of me wonders if this Paper Mario-inspired game will have the same effect. It’s really wonderful to see a two-person team like this fund a successful Kickstarter, who probably played games like Paper Mario when they were younger to understand how to deliver such a strong, reminiscent game, and I look forward to what Sleepy Castle Studio has planned next.”
90
90/100
